Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

[Steve_OS]

With Vladimir Guerrero Jr. becoming the cover athlete for MLB The Show 23 last week (and...

Written By: Chase Becotte

Click here to view the article.

[ChaseB]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

The cover athletes and their rankings (from worst to first):

17) MLB The Show 20 – Javier Baez
16) MLB The Show 23 – Jazz Chisholm
15) MLB 15: The Show – Yasiel Puig
14) MLB 11: The Show – Joe Mauer
13) MLB 12: The Show – Adrian Gonzalez
12) MLB The Show 19 – Bryce Harper
11) MLB The Show 18 – Aaron Judge
10) MLB The Show 21 – Fernando Tatis Jr.
9) MLB 10: The Show – Joe Mauer
8) MLB 09: The Show – Dustin Pedroia
7) MLB 08: The Show – Ryan Howard
6) MLB 14: The Show – Miguel Cabrera
5) MLB 06: The Show – David Ortiz
4) MLB The Show 16 – Josh Donaldson
3) MLB 07: The Show – David Wright
2) MLB 13: The Show – Andrew McCutchen
1) MLB The Show 22 – Shohei Ohtani

I actually had a lot of fun making this list since it had been quite some time since I looked back at some of the seasons some of these dudes had.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

My Top Five, in no particular order.

David Wright
McCutch
Miggy
Adrian Gonzalez
Mauer (both)

[ripcandlestickpark]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

For 19, I thought the placeholder cover from when Harper was still a free agent was a lot better than the final cover that was quickly put together after he signed.

[countryboy]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

I know it’s not the standard editions but my two favorite covers are ‘19 and’17 collector editions.




I love the “simplicity” of ‘19


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ChaseB]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

The '19 Collector's box is sharp, I had forgotten that one.

As for the cover athlete rankings, I'm still getting over David Wright putting up 8 WAR during the year he was on the cover and not getting a single MVP vote. There's no way that ever happens today.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

For 19, I thought the placeholder cover from when Harper was still a free agent was a lot better than the final cover that was quickly put together after he signed.

I'm no Harper fan by any stretch but that placeholder was so unique, it was much better than his Philly cover. Also, Bryse can slash thru World Series now, only Cooperstown left on that bucket list.

[IndianSummer]

Re: Ranking Every MLB The Show Cover By Year Since 2006

The '19 Collector's box is sharp, I had forgotten that one.

As for the cover athlete rankings, I'm still getting over David Wright putting up 8 WAR during the year he was on the cover and not getting a single MVP vote. There's no way that ever happens today.

Anytime the baseball writers are in charge of making educated logical decisions that is what happens. They are the same folks that vote on HOF.