MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

I am looking for a minor deal for the Mariners lineup. Either a First Baseman or an Outfielder, preferably on either side.

I am looking at Connor Joe(Pirates), Jonathan India(Reds), Akil Baddoo(Tigers) or Jesus Sanchez (Marlins)

Since I am new to the MLB I don't know what would be an appropriate value for a small deal like that. At least the first two are more or less regulars in their teams lineups.

Conner Joe is one of those guys who does it all too and the Pirates would probably part with him without a fight. I bet the reds would part with India for a power bat.

[Detroit Tigers]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Interested in RF Oscar Gonzalez (NYY by way of CLE). I’m DET. What’s he worth? I have my entire irl roster in-tact. Shoot me an offer.

[Cyrus09]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Conner Joe is one of those guys who does it all too and the Pirates would probably part with him without a fight. I bet the reds would part with India for a power bat.

Sadly the Mariners lack of power is one of the biggest problems for me so far, next to the defense in the outfield.

I think I will go for Joe then, a younger guy on a position of need for them should be enough? The only starting position where I have a good backup is at C, but he is playing 1st base now.

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Interested in RF Oscar Gonzalez (NYY by way of CLE). I’m DET. What’s he worth? I have my entire irl roster in-tact. Shoot me an offer.

I would think NY would part with Oscar G for minor league depth at a position of need for NY. One minor leaguer for another.

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Sadly the Mariners lack of power is one of the biggest problems for me so far, next to the defense in the outfield.

I think I will go for Joe then, a younger guy on a position of need for them should be enough? The only starting position where I have a good backup is at C, but he is playing 1st base now.

I would think they would go for a young OF or Pitcher with team control for Conner Joe. Their infield seems set.

[Jeffrey Smith]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Fair trade to pick up Jazz Chisolm from the Marlins? Im playing with the A’s. Don’t want to include Ruiz or Gelof in any trade.

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Fair trade to pick up Jazz Chisolm from the Marlins? Im playing with the A’s. Don’t want to include Ruiz or Gelof in any trade.

I would imagine Jazz would be costly and I can't think of anyone Miami would want from Oakland besides Gelof, and Miami already has Arraez at 2B. Jazz is still cheap and Miami doesn't have any young OF prospect talent coming up.

If you're doing 30 team control you could try to swing a 3 team deal to try to get Jazz?

[Stucatz]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Nationals offered Me
TOP PROSPECT CF J. Woods
For
TOP PROSPECT SP R. TIEDEMANN

15 min into starring into the trade screen and debating i ultimately decline but what a crazy offer i could revisit at 1 point or year

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

Nationals offered Me
TOP PROSPECT CF J. Woods
For
TOP PROSPECT SP R. TIEDEMANN

15 min into starring into the trade screen and debating i ultimately decline but what a crazy offer i could revisit at 1 point or year

That's a pretty fair offer if you're looking for a young CF to build around.

[Cyrus09]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

I just saw an article that Chisholm could be the next Miami player traded. How do you guys think a deal like that could look? Similar to Arraez?

I thought about it for the Mets, they could need the additional offense and speed. Or the Blue Jays, of course.

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

I just saw an article that Chisholm could be the next Miami player traded. How do you guys think a deal like that could look? Similar to Arraez?

I thought about it for the Mets, they could need the additional offense and speed. Or the Blue Jays, of course.

I'm doing a Miami rebuild, and I did a 3 team trade with Miami, Cleveland, and Arizona. I'm not at the PS5 so I don't remember every player involved, but Arizona ended up with Bieber (all players start my franchise healthy) Miami ended up with Jordan Lawler, and Cleveland ended up with Jazz since they're in need of outfielders. It helps that I do 30 team control.

[KLima878]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

I'm using the Pirates and slowly losing ground on making the playoffs and most likely going to be a seller. I'm looking to move David Bednar who has been great as my closer. I'm thinking of moving him to the Orioles who are only 3 games out of first behind the Yankees and need bullpen help. Some type of package would be Bednar for one of either Colby Mayo or Heston Kjerstad type package.

Is this unrealistic? I know both are high prospects but figured the Orioles have a ton of positional prospects and could use some of them to help with their World Series run.

[Nickda55]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

What do you guys do to make trades realistic? Playing as the As, and Orioles have Jackson Holliday on the trade block.

I typically use the trade finder, but some of the options they're giving me, don't even cover what the team is seeking. Started making me feel that maybe the Trade Finder is a bit cheap.

Any house rules you guys follow to make things a bit more realistic?

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

What do you guys do to make trades realistic? Playing as the As, and Orioles have Jackson Holliday on the trade block.

I typically use the trade finder, but some of the options they're giving me, don't even cover what the team is seeking. Started making me feel that maybe the Trade Finder is a bit cheap.

Any house rules you guys follow to make things a bit more realistic?

30 team control is the best answer. Holliday is always on the trade block for some reason so with 30 team control you can just go to Baltimore and take him off.

Or you can just let the trades happen between teams and undo the trades that are unrealistic. That's what I do.

[Nickda55]

Re: MLB The Show 24 Trade Discussion

I ended up trading Gelof and Rooker for Holliday. Not sure if it's the most realistic, but they were seeking a RF and a 2B. Orioles have a losing record, and are 10 games behind 1st. I figured, I can give them Rooker and Gelof since they can have control over both of them for a few years as they rebuild.

What do you guys do to make trades realistic? Playing as the As, and Orioles have Jackson Holliday on the trade block.

I typically use the trade finder, but some of the options they're giving me, don't even cover what the team is seeking. Started making me feel that maybe the Trade Finder is a bit cheap.

Any house rules you guys follow to make things a bit more realistic?