MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

[Steve_OS]

It’s like Christmas morning! The MLB The Show 25 player ratings (at least some) were revealed!...

Written By: Kyler Wolff

Click here to view the article.

[NAFBUC]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

Great article Kyler! Agree with pitcher sub-ratings overall. Going back to The Show 24, the strikeout attribute was very low overall based on strikeouts per 9 innings.
This could be a side effect of trying to channel more offense to the game.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

If Ohtani has a 96 Durability rating again and Trout's is 90 again, then they got it wrong. And then everything is open to speculation. I hate it for Online users but as a strictly offline guy, at least I have benefit of editing.

[Hunkulese]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

I'm not sure what they do for the regular ratings, but in DD, I'm pretty sure they use a three-year formula that's weighted towards the more recent stats. Vlad's rating being lower than Harper makes sense if you look at the three-year sample size.

[Hunkulese]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

If Ohtani has a 96 Durability rating again and Trout's is 90 again, then they got it wrong. And then everything is open to speculation. I hate it for Online users but as a strictly offline guy, at least I have benefit of editing.

How can you have a problem with Ohtani? In the past 4 seasons, he played in 155, 157, 135, and 159 games, and he pitched in three of them. Having to reconstruct a pitching arm is just standard practice with how they use pitchers these days and doesn't really say anything about his durability.

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

How can you have a problem with Ohtani? In the past 4 seasons, he played in 155, 157, 135, and 159 games, and he pitched in three of them. Having to reconstruct a pitching arm is just standard practice with how they use pitchers these days and doesn't really say anything about his durability.

Only because it keeps him healthy enough to pitch.

[goldenroad]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

Soto just had the highest WAR season of his career, so he's actually better now than he's ever been.

Witt should've been a 99 too though. Thanks for the article!

[The_Subspace_Mariner]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Ratings Reaction: What They Got Right and Wrong

It’s like Christmas morning! The MLB The Show 25 player ratings (at least some) were revealed!...

Written By: Kyler Wolff

Click here to view the article.

Dude....you want WAAAAAAYYYYYY too many 90+ overall players.

If it were me rating these guys, there'd be like ten 90+ guys in the entire league.