MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

[Knight165]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Good stuff ...nice little write-up.
There are so many little things that would go towards making this(and every) game so much more in depth.
The great thing about SCEA(for The Show at least) is that the devs seem to be genuinely interested in what we gamers are looking for.
Thanks for keeping the spotlight on these "issues".

M.K.
Knight165

[zippy2212]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Editing the coaches would be awesome! I hate having my third base coach wearing the same number as my starting catcher.

[mrnickyb]

cursor hitting???? Yeah, ok.....

[SDwinder]

Dynamic lighting/shadows and moving clouds with the wind should be priority number 1. This was handled very well in MLB2k7 360.

Rain is such an infrequent thing in baseball, that it just isnt worth spending the time to program it into the game. Football yes, baseball no. Get over it. Put all the efforts into dynamic lighting. That is one thing I really miss from the 2K series.

I would like to see the dugout and bullpen guys react to what is happening on the field in an appropriate natural way, This would enhance the reality aspect. Need more dugout and bullpen guys too. There is nobody in the bullpen at all until someone gets sent to warm up and there is not enough guys in the dugout to seem realistic. When a team is in the field there is nobody left in the dugout!

Collision detection between players and calling for a popup like in the 2k series would be great. Also, with that goes breaking up double plays at 2B. That should be a gimme.

I would like to be able to mod the rosters for exhibition play too, because the weekly updates are not always accurate.

[SDwinder]

Also, we need a behind the pitcher view for online play, but only when in the field.

[green94]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Dynamic lighting/shadows and moving clouds with the wind should be priority number 1. This was handled very well in MLB2k7 360.

Rain is such an infrequent thing in baseball, that it just isnt worth spending the time to program it into the game. Football yes, baseball no. Get over it. Put all the efforts into dynamic lighting. That is one thing I really miss from the 2K series.

I would like to see the dugout and bullpen guys react to what is happening on the field in an appropriate natural way, This would enhance the reality aspect. Need more dugout and bullpen guys too. There is nobody in the bullpen at all until someone gets sent to warm up and there is not enough guys in the dugout to seem realistic. When a team is in the field there is nobody left in the dugout!

Collision detection between players and calling for a popup like in the 2k series would be great. Also, with that goes breaking up double plays at 2B. That should be a gimme.

I would like to be able to mod the rosters for exhibition play too, because the weekly updates are not always accurate.

Actually this guy gets it. COMPLETELY. Please do all of this SCEA.

[dbray64]

I would like to see MLB 09 offer Seasons from the Past like the PC games Hardball and Tony LaRussa baseball did. The simulation PC games offer all teams and players from 1900-2008. I think an addition such as this would be really cool. I think being able to play as some of the old players would add depth to game and no other console game has done this yet. They may offer teams from the past but not an entire seasons.

[ericjwm]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Dynamic lighting/shadows and moving clouds with the wind should be priority number 1. This was handled very well in MLB2k7 360.

Rain is such an infrequent thing in baseball, that it just isnt worth spending the time to program it into the game. Football yes, baseball no. Get over it. Put all the efforts into dynamic lighting. That is one thing I really miss from the 2K series.

Actually rain occurs quite a bit in baseball, especially in Florida & Seattle. It just doesn't always cause delays or cancellations. If its a light drizzle they can & usually will play through it.

Don't you find it kind of dull with the same constant fair weather in past iterations of The Show? Wouldn't it be more interesting to play a game where theres constant worry about the weather on cloudy or overcast days/nights? Then if it does happen to start raining hard enough to cause delay, that's when bullpen strategy comes into play if your starter is still going strong at the time. It's all about variation & ways to keep every single game interesting in more ways than just on the field play.

Now if Sony implements the weather conditions like 2K did, then I'd agree with you. They did a horrible job with those lines falling from the overlays supposedly resembling rain. I don't think that'll happen with Sony though. Especially since Kolbe & Chris have mentioned in the past that they're holding out on weather till it can be done properly. Well you'd think with the power of the PS3 that would no longer be a problem.

[wookie48]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Weather is just as important as lighting in creating variation & realism. In fact weather creates different lighting, so both should be implemented together IMO.

weather is a big deal. Being cold seeing the players breathe, the way they play. Wet field being slippery. Rain outs, snowy atmosphere, overcasts.

[Revolution42]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

can we please PLEASE have realistic body types for managers??? lou pinella, mike scioscia, and all the other big-gut managers haven't been that svelte in decades! and how about a team jacket on em instead of a plain uniform. it's been documented that terry francona has been asked to wear his uniform when managing. he argues that he has a circulatory problem that requires him to bundle up in the outer-wear jackets, etc. in other words, we should almost never see francona in a full bosox uni during a mound visit.

i know this is purely cosmetic, but when you're trying to immerse yourself in a fantasy world and the manager trots out there looking nothing like his real life counterpart, you're ripped from the fantasy! The Show does such a great job in most aspects, but when i see that lean lou pinella paying a mound visit, i suddenly realize that i'm not at wrigley; i'm in my boxers on my recliner at 3 a.m. playing a video game (LOSER!).

please don't remind me that i'm a loser!

Recliner.....boxers....3a.m....excellent, you ain't a loser, you are a fanatic. I can relate. I cannot count the number of times I have found myself in the same situation. Ok....some expert rationalization went into this post....plus...there is alot worse things a guy could be doing at 3a.m. Of course, there could be some more interesting things as well. I am quite fortunate as my GF is VERY understanding. She often mentions the effect an extra inning victory over the Yankees has on me prior to "bedtime"

[GoldenGlove]

All of that stuff is cool and all, but I'd rather see improvements and tweaks to gameplay and the online then "the little things".

I'd like to see ball boys down the foul lines though. But I'd really want them to make improvements to the online portion more than anything else.

[bighou]

Only two things need to be improved or added to this game and it will be a perfect 10 out of 10.

1. Make the ball a little more obvious to see when it leaves the bat. This game does a good job of it for ground balls but when you hit home runs, you barely see the ball at all when it comes off the bat. I like to enjoy the flight of a ball when it comes off the bat to know that it's an obvious home run. MVP 05 baseball on XBOX 360 did a good job with this.

2. Can a baseball game FINALLY get a BATTING PRACTICE option. I mean, HELLO, this is a part of Baseball. Can we please get an option for Batting practice with the cage and the whole 9. I haven't seen this in a baseball game with the behind the pitcher view since Hardball on Sega Genesis. Mind you that was 1991! You put those two things in this game and it will be PERFECT!!!

Oh yeah, a wish list. Can you add Single A as well. Hey, just want to keep the game real, that's all.

Thanks

[rjackson17]

Hey you guys I agree with the weather delay! But I still think that we need the 40-man rosters to start on Auguest 31 and end on the first week of October and reset the the 40-man rosters to the 25-man rosters before the post seasons!

Thanks,

RJ

[wookie48]

Re: MLB '09: The Show - Always Room for Improvement

Also is it me does the ball seem insanely huge when in play. Maybe tone down the size of the ball?

[DaImmaculateONe]

i wanna see people not going through other people like casper the ghost