MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

[xNobleEaglex]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: "And with the loss, the ______ would fall 2 games under .500 on the year."

Why it is incorrect: I could be 57-40 or 40-57, but they still think I'm 2 games under .500 on the year. This bug was also present in '09.
<table id="post2040975579" class="tborder" align="center" border="0" cellpadding="6" cellspacing="0" width="100%"><tbody><tr valign="top"></tr></tbody></table>

[cardsfan2222]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? Season + Franchise

Incorrect Commentary? Soup says something to the effect of "And with this being just the first week of the season, I doubt they'll let him go past 7 innings" relating to my starting pitcher

Why was it incorrect? I've heard this line throughout the month of April.

Repost of this. I've heard this multiple times through the first month of the season.

[jestep123]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: With a right handed hitter at the plate I will hit the ball to right field and Matt says something like "and --- pulls the ball into the stands foul down the right side and out of play."

Why it is incorrect: Right handed hitters do not pull the ball to right side.

[jkeefeholmes]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Incorrect Commentary After umps review a HR and comeback and signal it is a HR, Matt says they reverse the call, and now rule it a HR.

Why is it IncorrectBecause they ruled a HR to begin with. Not to mention it wasn't even close, you could see from home plate it was clearly fair

[cardsleadtheway]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: On a 3-1 count, I throw a strike and Matt (I think) says "and from 0-2 to 3-2 he is really making him work out there."

Why it is incorrect: The count was never 0-2 at any time in the AB.

[I_am_Canadian]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: On a 2-0 count I take a strike and Matt says "and he's able to work the count into his favour now at 2-1".

Why it is incorrect: The count was already in my favour. He should say this if it had been 1-1 and I took another ball.

[jim416]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

GAme Mode

Franchise

Incorrect commentary

Dexter Fowler got a hit, showed him smiling on first base as Matt said that baseball had a new hit king and possessed more hits than anyone in baseball.

Why it is incorrect

Self explanatory.

[harvey88]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: On a 2-0 count I take a strike and Matt says "and he's able to work the count into his favour now at 2-1".

Why it is incorrect: The count was already in my favour. He should say this if it had been 1-1 and I took another ball.

I hear this comment at least once a game. Always when the count goes from 2-0 to 2-1.

[Mattheus]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: Playing as the Yankees at the start of some games at home they start talking about "New Yankee Stadium." They begin talking about the same field dimensions and how no one knows how the ball park is going to play and how there will be an adjustment period because no one has played in it before.

Why is it incorrect: This is the 2nd year of the stadium's existence. Last year it was established the stadium is very hitter friendly. I think the adjustment period they discuss is really over. I just don't think they should still be calling it "New Yankee Stadium." It's the 2nd year, they won a championship in it. It's just Yankee Stadium.

[MatrixTN]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Mode
RTTS (possibly other regular gameplay modes)

Commentary
I popped out to first, in foul territory near the dugout and Matt said "And he pulls this one out of the first row!" or something to that effect.

Wrong
It was not into the stands, it was very close but was not going out of play otherwise (really close to landing in the dugout).

[loogs]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? franchise
Incorrect Commentary? and boy, you never wanna run on ichiro
Why was it incorrect? jeff francouer NY Mets, threw a runner out at home plate and was referred to as ichiro.

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? franchise
Incorrect Commentary? warming up in the bullpen
Why was it incorrect? happens a lot that when warming up pitchers in the bullpen, matt will say that the other team is warming up the pitcher that you just started warming up. not by name but by rightie/ lefty.

<!-- / message -->

<!-- / message -->

[5th_fathom]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game mode (Exibition, Franchise, etc..)? franchise

Incorrect Commentary? warming up in the bullpen
Why was it incorrect? happens a lot that when warming up pitchers in the bullpen, matt will say that the other team is warming up the pitcher that you just started warming up. not by name but by rightie/ lefty.

I am re-reporting this.

If I tell a Lefty to get up and start throwing, Matt announces that my opponent has lefty up and warming. I've checked my opponents bullpen to be sure.

[5th_fathom]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: "They have their closer warming up in the bullpen"

Why was it incorrect?: Whenever I send my Set-Up man to warm up in the bullpen, Matt announces that my closer is up and throwing.

[cardsleadtheway]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

Game Mode: Franchise

Incorrect Commentary: I hear this one often. On a 2-0 count, pitcher (either team) throws a strike and they say "He misses with that one to fall behind 2-1"

Why was it incorrect?: Pitcher didn't miss. He just threw a strike.

[biker_jim_uk]

Re: MLB '10 Incorrect Commentary Thread

PLaying as the Mets in RttS I have also heard them referred to as the Nationals, also today noticed the PA errors too (Shea Stadium, winner with just his 3rd loss etc).

Also I have noticed when I pinch hit and get on base the commentary treats the subsequent batters as PH's too. eg I'll be on 1st after PH for the pitcher, next batter up is the Leadoff hitter who is 1-3 on the night, he'll then strike out and the commentator will do the 'he brought a bat for THAT!!!' or 'he waits all night and then does that' etc that refer to it being his first AB.

Not entirely incorrect but in later years of RttS players are still being referred to as young (David Wright for eg) even though it is 2016 and they are now seasoned veterans. On a similar note they still refer to Citi Field as a new stadium across the ballpark when it is now 6 years+ old.