MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

[Joey]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

I could have sworn I saw a separate thread on animations somewhere...

They do make a very good game, but some of the things that have been left untouched over the past couple of years gets annoying. the biggest thing is the unnatural swing mechanics. I dont like that 95% of the swings morph into a generic swing and follow through. the japanese game mentioed above has very good swing mechanics and even the old EA games had better mechanics. It has been said that perhaps these new player models they have are going to fix that so I will wait to pass judgement until I see if it has changed or stayed the same. they can add all the new stuff they like, but until the mechanics and whatnot are correct the game will always "look" the same to me.

[jd369]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

I could have sworn I saw a separate thread on animations somewhere...

I think I saw that one to capt obvious. My post wasnt soely about animations, it was a reply to the argument about buying the "same" game every year and some posts about nothing being better. I get tired of hearing that there is very little or nothing to improve on so I wanted to point out a MAJOR area that needed to be improved on that would go a long way on not making the game feel stale every year. Regardless of if there is a thread on animations or not, the post was on topic for the discussion, but hey, at least you look cool on an interent message board.

[Joey]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Yes, you saw it and posted basically the same thing in that thread. Just not sure why some people feel the need to rehash the same thing over and over.

I think I saw that one to capt obvious. My post wasnt soely about animations, it was a reply to the argument about buying the "same" game every year and some posts about nothing being better. I get tired of hearing that there is very little or nothing to improve on so I wanted to point out a MAJOR area that needed to be improved on that would go a long way on not making the game feel stale every year. Regardless of if there is a thread on animations or not, the post was on topic for the discussion, but hey, at least you look cool on an interent message board.

[EnigmaNemesis]

Those Screenshots don't do anything or me.
They look the same models and equipment as in 09, with better lighting.
They are using the same cleats and Ryan Howard has the same sunglasses model as he had in 09.

Same models? Ok man.


Sent from the dugout using Tapatalk

[jd369]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Hmmm, perhaps its because some things can cover more than one specific topic. In this case the mechanics need to be improved AND it is something that can make the game less stale. Doesn't really matter if you think it needs to be re-hashed or not, if the post is on topic for the discussion there aint a thing wrong with it. If you dont feel like reading it dont read it. ANY thread/post that pertains to MLB the show is a valid thread/post.

[Joey]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Ok, I conceed, mechanics are a valid topic in a thread titled "MLB 11 The Show Screenshots". You win, I'm done.

Hmmm, perhaps its because some things can cover more than one specific topic. In this case the mechanics need to be improved AND it is something that can make the game less stale. Doesn't really matter if you think it needs to be re-hashed or not, if the post is on topic for the discussion there aint a thing wrong with it. If you dont feel like reading it dont read it. ANY thread/post that pertains to MLB the show is a valid thread/post.

[AtlBraves09]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Those Screenshots don't do anything or me.
They look the same models and equipment as in 09, with better lighting.
They are using the same cleats and Ryan Howard has the same sunglasses model as he had in 09.

Have you seen the screen shot comparison thread? I assume you havent because you would not have posted that comment. If fact, it has a Ryan Howard screen in there. Take a look and get back to me.

[Pared]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

I think I saw that one to capt obvious. My post wasnt soely about animations, it was a reply to the argument about buying the "same" game every year and some posts about nothing being better. I get tired of hearing that there is very little or nothing to improve on so I wanted to point out a MAJOR area that needed to be improved on that would go a long way on not making the game feel stale every year. Regardless of if there is a thread on animations or not, the post was on topic for the discussion, but hey, at least you look cool on an interent message board.

Enough with this as it's completely unnecessary. He said it to get the conversation from straying off-topic which you are doing even more at this point.

Back on topic please.

[wrigleyville33]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Same models? Ok man.


Sent from the dugout using Tapatalk

They aren't new models at all. You can say they are improved. SCEA was implying that we would be seeing brand new player models. They didn't say they were going to just improve them.

[EnigmaNemesis]

They aren't new models at all. You can say they are improved. SCEA was implying that we would be seeing brand new player models. They didn't say they were going to just improve them.

What? They are brand new skeletal structures built from the ground up.


Sent from the dugout using Tapatalk

[Blzer]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

They aren't new models at all. You can say they are improved. SCEA was implying that we would be seeing brand new player models. They didn't say they were going to just improve them.

The model is the skeleton, not the jersey texture and all that which you see on the outside. Proportionately, all of the models have been redone to mold that of a human much more accurately.

[Scottdau]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

Did they really need to fix that much. Making the shoulders and arms and neck and face more life like was all it really needed.

[PLite14]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

I think the people who expected the new player models to be something revolutionary are bound to be disappointed. The fact of the matter is they already looked pretty darn good, and if they did actually re-do the entire skeleton, we will only see small improvements pertaining to the things many have complained about the last couple years (shoulders, 'T-rex' arms, etc).

[Scottdau]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

I still don't know how someone can not tell those player models look different. Just look at the necks and heads alone. They are now even more fuller. These player models are night and day from last years. Look at the Cody Ross picture. I very impressed with these models this year.

[Pared]

Re: MLB 11 The Show Screenshots (3 More)

They aren't new models at all. You can say they are improved. SCEA was implying that we would be seeing brand new player models. They didn't say they were going to just improve them.

I believe they are all new.

Let me ask you something - do you expect them to look radically different? Why would you state they "aren't new models at all?" Would you expect them to not look human?

It's a ridiculous argument that really doesn't need to be this difficult.

The player models look better - yes or no?