I see what you're saying but you need to think about the left joystick when it comes to low/high pitches. The right joystick deals with left/right movement and timing/batspeed, not pitch height.
If you're still confused, think of the batter from an overhead view. Pulling back and pushing forward on the joystick every time makes sense because every swing, the batter (a) pulls the bat back and (b) pushes the bat forward.

Comment