Unrealistic stats continuing

[Cavicchi]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Who can argue with that kind of logic? Brilliant.

Since you want logic, here goes with a list of games played and assists for some outfielders:

1. Victorino 62 games and 7 assists

2. Sam Fuld 53 games and 6 assists

3. Corey Patterson 58 games and 13 assists--yes, 13 assists!

4. Anthiny Gose 58 games and 6 assists--interesting to note his durability is 77 but missed just 2 games.

5. Parmalee 53 games and 6 assists

6. Mastroanni 50 games and 8 assists

7. Peter Bourjois 61 games and 6 assists

8. Julio Borbon 51 games and 7 assists

9. Peguero (Giants) 59 games and 8 assists

10. Andres Torres 53 games and 8 assists

11. Reimhold 49 games and 7 assists

12. Carlos Gomez 54 games and 9 assists --has good arm strength rating

13. LF Davis (R) arm strength 63 accuracy 54--51 games and 5 assists

14. Jose Tabata arm strength 49 accuracy 42--55 games and 5 assists

Actually, arm ratings seem to have no bearing on these assist totals. I fail to see any logic applied here.

I left out Colvin but I've already mentioned him above.

[etched Chaos]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Cavicchi stop it, please, this thread is about legitimate concerns that are leaguewide, not focused on what sounds like your fave player. One or two players is an anomaly that is easy to happen, when it's as pronounced as it was in my screenshots, that's a problem. All you're doing is clogging this thread up with posts that have little bearing on what I had originally posted.

[Cavicchi]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Since you want logic, here goes with a list of games played and assists for some outfielders:

1. Victorino 62 games and 7 assists

2. Sam Fuld 53 games and 6 assists

3. Corey Patterson 58 games and 13 assists--yes, 13 assists!

4. Anthiny Gose 58 games and 6 assists--interesting to note his durability is 77 but missed just 2 games.

5. Parmalee 53 games and 6 assists

6. Mastroanni 50 games and 8 assists

7. Peter Bourjois 61 games and 6 assists

8. Julio Borbon 51 games and 7 assists

9. Peguero (Giants) 59 games and 8 assists

10. Andres Torres 53 games and 8 assists

11. Reimhold 49 games and 7 assists

12. Carlos Gomez 54 games and 9 assists --has good arm strength rating

13. LF Davis (R) arm strength 63 accuracy 54--51 games and 5 assists

14. Jose Tabata arm strength 49 accuracy 42--55 games and 5 assists

Actually, arm ratings seem to have no bearing on these assist totals. I fail to see any logic applied here.

I left out Colvin but I've already mentioned him above.

Cavicchi stop it, please, this thread is about legitimate concerns that are leaguewide, not focused on what sounds like your fave player. One or two players is an anomaly that is easy to happen, when it's as pronounced as it was in my screenshots, that's a problem. All you're doing is clogging this thread up with posts that have little bearing on what I had originally posted.

^^^ No favorite players there, and none were mentioned by me.

[nomo17k]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

^^^ No favorite players there, and none were mentioned by me.

I can see your argument about outfield assists, which the game might produce too many in simmed games, though I haven't look in detail yet (soon I might)... it's also an issue that the game often substitute players for which they are not really qualified to play, and the stats are tallied together... so it's possible some of those assists come from playing in other positions.

But it's not really nice of you to continue the off-topic discussions... Simmed game results being off here and there isn't really the focus of this thread, so I hope you understand that point at least. The thread is not really productive right now.

[Cavicchi]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

I can see your argument about outfield assists, which the game might produce too many in simmed games, though I haven't look in detail yet (soon I might)... it's also an issue that the game often substitute players for which they are not really qualified to play, and the stats are tallied together... so it's possible some of those assists come from playing in other positions.

But it's not really nice of you to continue the off-topic discussions... Simmed game results being off here and there isn't really the focus of this thread, so I hope you understand that point at least. The thread is not really productive right now.

Okay, sorry, I thought it was about unrealistic stats when games are simmed.

[nowitsourtime]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Okay, sorry, I thought it was about unrealistic stats when games are simmed.

It's about ridiculous inflated batting stats an pitcher ERA when you get multiple seasons into a franchise or road to the show.It is not the fact that a reliever, which the position itself lends itself to higher ERA due to the limited amount of innings and quick hook times, has a higher than normal ERA less than a half a year into the first season.

The OP mentions a trend that occurs year after year in a franchise. Your example takes a 2 month sample size. If all closers had a high ERA, then you have a point. But you've cherry picked one closer who's having a less than stellar two months.

[Gagnon39]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Is there a concise breakdown of how do deal with this issue? This thread is now over twenty pages and I don't know if I can find it. What's the latest, is it going to be patched? Do we just need to edit some of the A potential players and if so, how many?

[NateRego93]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Can we please go back on topic here, I really want to start my franchise already but hearing and seeing how messed up the stats can get over the years is a real bummer, I want one of the devs to reply in this thread about this matter.

[Mackie011]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Looking for an answer to this as well.

I have spent a lot of time into mid of my second year and things are pretty wild and not very fun right now.

This is very frustrating as I feel I can't play my franchise when I look around the league stats.

[Steven78]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Kimbrel is inching towards that 4.0 ERA now.

[bcruise]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Kimbrel is inching towards that 4.0 ERA now.

Shocking result yesterday. But that's how quickly it can turn for anyone who pitches so few innings.

[nomo17k]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

You never know with what Bud Selig does to baseball. His goal is not to make MLB play sim. It's just a game, so realism is not the goal. Kimbrel struggling just reflects that.

[NateRego93]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

I guess this thread is dead along with me playing any franchise games this year, ohh well MLB 12 it is!

[Cavicchi]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

Kimbrel is inching towards that 4.0 ERA now.

Shocking result yesterday. But that's how quickly it can turn for anyone who pitches so few innings.

Relax guys, he has been in the 3 ERA before, but so far, never over 4 at any point of the season.

[Jimbo614]

Re: Unrealistic stats continuing

I'm curious about something...
How do these inflated numbers compare to Baseball in the 1930's?
Seems to me, I recall that the League BA in 1934 was over .300