BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Bamafan3723
    THE Standard in CFB
    • Jul 2003
    • 7287

    #1426
    Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

    Bumping this back up for anyone to use as a reference for this year. This thread consists of MLB 08 and MLB 09 edits. Page 71 is where MLB 09 The Show starts so I'm sure alot of these will transfer to MLB 10. Also, could a mod move this to the roster forum where it won't get buried so easily?
    "The best thing about being a football player at Alabama...winning...winning." -Mark Barron

    Comment

    • Bamafan3723
      THE Standard in CFB
      • Jul 2003
      • 7287

      #1427
      Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

      Originally posted by decga
      I agree with you 100%. I was going to post this. S. Drew's stance is spot on for Longoria..
      Originally posted by Rod_Carew29
      what's up? No offense, but some of you guys with this 'spot on' stuff ...ya gotta stop the madness...LOL

      I'm gonna be serious here:

      Last I saw, Longoria's bat either touches/rests on his shoulder or.....it's at a fairly low angle..and he's a little open in his stance

      Stephen Drew's stance (while open; even though I don't like the front leg positioning), has the bat too high--top-of-the-helmet-high

      Originally I used Branyan, which is more like it

      And then I changed to Crede as someone suggested, but Crede's stance is closed slightly

      I think I'm going back to Branyan unless....
      IF Longoria's stance/hand-bat positioning has changed, then I apologize...

      So what's the deal?
      Originally posted by DLowery
      Im going through possible Longoria's:

      Stephen Drew (bat is held a little too high)
      Cory Sullivan (too closed of a stance)
      Luis Gonzalez (a little too hunched over)
      Russell Branyan (a little too open?)
      Joe Crede (closed stance, maybe too much bat movement?)

      Out of those what do you think?
      Link of Evan batting in spring training
      Link of Evan taking BP
      Has anyone checked to see if Longoria's stance is the same in 10 as it was on 09?
      "The best thing about being a football player at Alabama...winning...winning." -Mark Barron

      Comment

      • ShowTyme15
        LADetermined
        • Jan 2004
        • 11853

        #1428
        Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

        Some of the stances can't be transferred over that easily. There are over 100 Generic stances so you have to figure out which is which. For Example if someone was given todd Hollandworth's stance last year how are we supposed to know which generic stance is Hollandsworth's? cause his isn't listed anymore.

        Comment

        • Bamafan3723
          THE Standard in CFB
          • Jul 2003
          • 7287

          #1429
          Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

          Originally posted by ShowTyme15
          Some of the stances can't be transferred over that easily. There are over 100 Generic stances so you have to figure out which is which. For Example if someone was given todd Hollandworth's stance last year how are we supposed to know which generic stance is Hollandsworth's? cause his isn't listed anymore.
          Obviously not all that worked last year will work this year, because there are some new stances added, but anyone can look through and see what stances worked for whomever last year and try them out in MLB 10. EX: Navarro still works great for Martin Prado of the Braves.
          "The best thing about being a football player at Alabama...winning...winning." -Mark Barron

          Comment

          • redsrulenc
            MVP
            • May 2009
            • 1428

            #1430
            Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

            Originally posted by bennysiegel4
            I was suggesting Soriano as a stance for Brandon Phillips...
            Any other year I'd agree, but after Soriano changed his stance, it doesn't work as well this year. I made the move over to Headly, and I've also heard Rolen. But I think I'mma use Headly for now.
            Check out my three critically acclaimed dynasties in the Dynasty HQ section:

            Run For The Playoffs - A Louisville Bats AAA dynasty

            Gimmie A Hell! Gimmie A Yeah! - This is Blue Mountain State Football.

            Single-A Baseball on The Show? Un-Flocking-Believable! - Go Myrtle Beach Pelicans!

            Comment

            • JK_Livin22
              Rookie
              • Apr 2009
              • 25

              #1431
              Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

              Originally posted by Bamafan3723
              Has anyone checked to see if Longoria's stance is the same in 10 as it was on 09?
              For Longoria I've been looking at Buster Posey, Mike Schmidt (too closed), Generic 39, (just a little too much bend), and Hank Blalock (would be near perfect if not for the slight lower body movement, imho)
              Last edited by JK_Livin22; 03-08-2010, 08:16 PM. Reason: add more content

              Comment

              • Bamafan3723
                THE Standard in CFB
                • Jul 2003
                • 7287

                #1432
                Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                Originally posted by redsrulenc
                Any other year I'd agree, but after Soriano changed his stance, it doesn't work as well this year. I made the move over to Headly, and I've also heard Rolen. But I think I'mma use Headly for now.
                What about David Dellucci?
                "The best thing about being a football player at Alabama...winning...winning." -Mark Barron

                Comment

                • GhettoDefendant7
                  Rookie
                  • Mar 2010
                  • 28

                  #1433
                  Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                  Anyone have a good one for adrian gonzalez? It seems that he has a more open stance in real life.

                  Comment

                  • JK_Livin22
                    Rookie
                    • Apr 2009
                    • 25

                    #1434
                    Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                    Originally posted by redsrulenc
                    Any other year I'd agree, but after Soriano changed his stance, it doesn't work as well this year. I made the move over to Headly, and I've also heard Rolen. But I think I'mma use Headly for now.

                    After looking at this photo (see link below), and setting the batter stances on screen to match the angle of Brandon Phillips in the picture, the list of the ones I thought were closest is:

                    Josh Bard
                    Cliff Floyd
                    David Eckstein
                    Nick Swisher
                    Vernon Wells
                    Reggie Willits
                    Scott Rolen
                    Mark Teahen
                    Raul Ibanez
                    Ryne Sandberg
                    Generics 5, 26, 64, 84, 89
                    and the very popular Chase Headley

                    I ended up going with Generic 89, for now anyway...

                    Last edited by JK_Livin22; 03-09-2010, 10:58 AM. Reason: add more content

                    Comment

                    • AmazinMets
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2010
                      • 5

                      #1435
                      Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                      Hey Rod,

                      Who are you using for the following guys?

                      David Wright
                      K-Rod
                      Jeff Francouer
                      Luis Castillo
                      Gary Matthews Jr
                      Carlos Beltran

                      Comment

                      • Rod_Carew29
                        All Star
                        • Apr 2004
                        • 7872

                        #1436
                        Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                        Wright-Jackie Robinson. There MAY be a slightly better one, but I'm not really doing the Mets until I get through the other 29

                        K-Rod-Papelbon

                        Francoeur-Generic 80

                        Castillo-Brian Roberts; remember with most switch-hitters, I use their stance from the left side.

                        Matthews, Jr.-his own

                        Beltran-Loney


                        Originally posted by AmazinMets
                        Hey Rod,

                        Who are you using for the following guys?

                        David Wright
                        K-Rod
                        Jeff Francouer
                        Luis Castillo
                        Gary Matthews Jr
                        Carlos Beltran
                        For 2017...
                        Don't Call It a Comeback

                        Comment

                        • Rod_Carew29
                          All Star
                          • Apr 2004
                          • 7872

                          #1437
                          Re: Longoria

                          Last night..I found about 5 that were close (one key, being the bat position REAL close to his shoulder)

                          Counsel, Votto, S. Hairston and Monroe...but I settled on Sullivan...looks the best to me

                          Originally posted by JK_Livin22
                          For Longoria I've been looking at Buster Posey, Mike Schmidt (too closed), Generic 39, (just a little too much bend), and Hank Blalock (would be near perfect if not for the slight lower body movement, imho)
                          For 2017...
                          Don't Call It a Comeback

                          Comment

                          • AmazinMets
                            Banned
                            • Mar 2010
                            • 5

                            #1438
                            Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                            Originally posted by Rod_Carew29
                            Wright-Jackie Robinson. There MAY be a slightly better one, but I'm not really doing the Mets until I get through the other 29

                            K-Rod-Papelbon

                            Francoeur-Generic 80

                            Castillo-Brian Roberts; remember with most switch-hitters, I use their stance from the left side.

                            Matthews, Jr.-his own

                            Beltran-Loney

                            Thanks carew!

                            Comment

                            • AmazinMets
                              Banned
                              • Mar 2010
                              • 5

                              #1439
                              Re: BATTING STANCE/PITCHING DELIVERY THREAD

                              If you find a better one for Wright please post it though..his knees are alot more bent this year and Jackie Robinson looks too upright for him...what do you think of Cody Ross?

                              Comment

                              • Rod_Carew29
                                All Star
                                • Apr 2004
                                • 7872

                                #1440
                                Gary Matthews, Jr.

                                looked at Matthews, Jr from the left side..
                                I'm going with Gwynn Jr.

                                and Tatis' 'own' stance is incorrect...so, I'm going with what I used last year, Yadier Molina's stance

                                Catalonotto...I'm using Vlad Guerrero's stance

                                Originally posted by AmazinMets
                                Thanks carew!
                                For 2017...
                                Don't Call It a Comeback

                                Comment

                                Working...