O.S. Full Minors 2010

[BatsareBugs]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

The real one is not out..some d-bag is posting fakes

Which is why I think the rosters should include the PSN ID of people who upload them.

[Bedard4CY]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

MLBPA ( i think ) has stupid rules that players have to play in the majors first before they can be in a video game..even though minor leaguers get paid and have the job, and play in stadiums just like major leaguers. i agree 100%

[mburke2]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

I think it's lame we have to have someone even MAKE this roster...

Why can't REAL players be already incorporated into the game rather than so many fake players?

Idk how many times people have to say this... because of licensing issues, Sony CANNOT incorporate players into the game unless they have had major league service time. Period.

[Gopher]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

Which is why I think the rosters should include the PSN ID of people who upload them.

Seconded

[Bedard4CY]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

Secounded

Thirded. I'm thinking of making some rosters myself next year of all minors for people who don't like to wait. obviously not even in the same league as Knight and Ridins', but worth making for some people. just some attributes, positions, names, and potentials. i think it would be pretty fun

[BatsareBugs]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

I think it's lame we have to have someone even MAKE this roster...

Why can't REAL players be already incorporated into the game rather than so many fake players?

Because minor league players aren't in a union and it drive up licensing fees. Surely you won't want to pay $200 for this game now would you? This was the case in MVP Baseball, in ASB Baseball, and always has been for MLB The Show. Sure there could be someone who could take the time to adjust ratings and somethings for the "fake players" pre-release with different names, but that too would take months (and you might not even agree with some of the players).

[c29]

Have to appear in a MLB game first

[RAZRr1275]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

Guys can we please refrain from posting things like "when are they coming out?' or "there's one uploaded on sportsconnect". That info is already in many places in the thread and on Knight and Ridins profiles. Posting pointless questions like that are only making that info harder to find. Thanks. btw I will be working off of Knight's V2 once that comes out.

[bobeureally27]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

MLBPA ( i think ) has stupid rules that players have to play in the majors first before they can be in a video game..even though minor leaguers get paid and have the job, and play in stadiums just like major leaguers. i agree 100%

The MLBPA is the Major League Baseball Players Association. Minor league players are NOT a part of the MLBPA. Therefore, minor league players cannot be included. It's not a stupid rule at all. Why should a Major League Baseball game include players that are not in the MLBPA?

[elsabreto138]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

MLBPA ( i think ) has stupid rules that players have to play in the majors first before they can be in a video game..even though minor leaguers get paid and have the job, and play in stadiums just like major leaguers. i agree 100%

Its not the MLBPA, its the people who make the game. They only signed for the players that are in the MLBPA, the minor leaugers arent in the MLBPA yet, not until they appear in at least one game. This is also the reason we had Jon Dowd instead of Barry Bonds in MVP. Same reason Bill Belicheck isnt in Madden, Kevin Millar, Bill Parcells yadda yadda. you cant expect the makers of the game to go up to all the minor leaugers and say "sign this, we want to put you in a video game!"

[VanillaGorilla]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

The MLBPA is the Major League Baseball Players Association. Minor league players are NOT a part of the MLBPA. Therefore, minor league players cannot be included. It's not a stupid rule at all. Why should a Major League Baseball game include players that are not in the MLBPA?

It's 2010, why can't Sony or 2K also find a way to license the minor leaguers?

[Bedard4CY]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

I'm saying that it's stupid there are different associations. They play in the same conditions, they get paid, they play in stadiums, people watch, there's no difference. Talent level is very close as well

[DIESEL]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

Okay...I'm out the door guys.
Ridin' has the file...is working on it some(fixing AAA and such...)
..and will post it in a bit.

Thanks for the well wishes and prayers.
Gonna need them

M.K.
Knight165

Hope everything works out man.

THANK YOU for everything you do for this community.

[bobeureally27]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

Its not the MLBPA, its the people who make the game. They only signed for the players that are in the MLBPA, the minor leaugers arent in the MLBPA yet, not until they appear in at least one game. This is also the reason we had Jon Dowd instead of Barry Bonds in MVP. Same reason Bill Belicheck isnt in Madden, Kevin Millar, Bill Parcells yadda yadda. you cant expect the makers of the game to go up to all the minor leaugers and say "sign this, we want to put you in a video game!"

Actually, Kevin Millar is a different situation. He came into the league as a replacement player during the strike. The players that crossed the picket line during the strike were denied entry into the MLBPA. This is also true for Ron Mahay, Damian Miller and Matt Herges. Barry Bonds simply opted out of the MLBPA.

[elsabreto138]

Re: O.S. Full Minors 2010

It's 2010, why can't Sony or 2K also find a way to license the minor leaguers?

If i can quote myself, "you cant expect the makers of the game to go up to all the minor leaugers and say "sign this, we want to put you in a video game!""