MLB '10: The Show Updated Rosters Available

[bxgoods]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Still at work...but in a nutshell:

they updated the rosters with player moves but really didn't change too many of the whacky ratings??? Is this correct??

As a Mets fan...what are Wright and Reyes?

Reyes Potential B
Wright Potential A

[metsman8669]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Reyes Potential B
Wright Potential A

Thanks...so it does seem like they altered things.

Why is everyone still up in arms??

[bxgoods]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Thanks...so it does seem like they altered things.

Why is everyone still up in arms??

Because they think there are too many A potential fake players in the minor league, it still makes it easy for superstar players to get traded in season.

[malachijohn666]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

What about the issue with pwr vs. lefties? Was that supposed to be fixed?

[metsman8669]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

What about the issue with pwr vs. lefties? Was that supposed to be fixed?

Hopefully they did fix it but if I recall, Russell said that was strictly a graphical error...it had nothing to do with their actual performance v LH.

[baseball66]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

What about the issue with pwr vs. lefties? Was that supposed to be fixed?

I'm must have missed that one, fill me in.

[ShowTyme15]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Hopefully they did fix it but if I recall, Russell said that was strictly a graphical error...it had nothing to do with their actual performance v LH.

That is exactly what Russell said. It's a graphical error that doesn't affect the game play!

[firktaf]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Hopefully they did fix it but if I recall, Russell said that was strictly a graphical error...it had nothing to do with their actual performance v LH.

This.

And a graphical error like this cannot be fixed in a roster update. If it gets fixed, then it'll get fixed in a patch.

[19]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

But don't you think that between the A's and B's there is 314 Pitchers to only 61 Position players is just a bit off?

I agree that the top 100 could reasonably get A's, but there is no way that out of the top 375 prospects 314 of them are pitchers. If you could change any player to any position then there wouldn't be a problem when it comes down to accurate minor league players with the correct potential.

I'm sorry, but this is unacceptable to me, someone obviously went through and changed the Potential ratings for the MLB players that were wrong. You would think while doing that, they could have changed all those fake A players to Bs and Cs. I don't understand why they just couldn't have used the same number of As, B's, & C's that were on the rosters in '09. '09 had it perfect, about 30 A's with CAPs, and mostly B's and C's (which is what I based my roster outline off of I've been working on since the end of January, all of which, now seems like a waste of time). It's just amazing to me how something so simple can get screwed up so badly. It would be nice to get a explaination from SCEA, because this was mentioned numerous times, and acknowledged in the Player Potential thread after the initial roster file was found to have the "bug".

[pezone]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Are you serious? Jeter has an "A" potential?! Now, I'm a Yankee fan but there's now way Jeter it's an A, not even a B..He is 35 years old, his stats are gonna start declining...

has he showed signs of declining??? Many believe he should have been MVP last year!!!

[cardsfan2222]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

With the potential not being locked this year, is that only based on performance during a season, or is it possible that potential could be changed if a players other attributes are edited?

One reason I think there could be more A potential players in the minors this year is because they added single A players for each team. That's 450 more roster spots this year, and if the potentials were evenly distributed for all 5 letter grades, that would add 90 more players for each letter this year. So if last year there were 30-40 A potential minor leaguer's, this year there would be 120-130. That wouldn't explain why most of those are pitchers, but it could explain the higher number at least.

[19]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

So if last year there were 30-40 A potential minor leaguer's, this year there would be 120-130.

There wasn't 30-40. On the out of the box roster, there were 6 A players in the minors, plus the 20 you could create. The numbers are off this year and I would love to know why.

[Bill1]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Anyone having login problems. trying to login to get the rosters.

[CubFan23]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

Anyone having login problems. trying to login to get the rosters.

yea, it's been down for about 20 mins or so, just checked and still no go

[Bill1]

Re: New Rosters Out!!!!

yea, it's been down for about 20 mins or so, just checked and still no go

So it not just me. thank. will try again in a half hour. really want to get this franchise going.