Okay guys, I've been tinkering with the original sliders from Armor's thread and I think I MAY have found an excellent combination to achieve realism. I've played only a couple games with them but the results and feel of hitting, pitching, and the game overall just feel so right.
Now, of course these may only work for me, but I think they're definitely worth a try. I was struggling with hitting on All Star and the hybrid version as well. I was also pitching too well with the same sliders. These seem to balance everything out.
All Star Difficulty for Hitting and Pitching
HUMAN
Contact 5
Power 5
Timing 6
Foul Frequency 5
Solid Hits 5
Starter Stamina 6
Reliever stamina 5
Control 4
Consistency 3
CPU
Contact 5
Power 4
Timing 5
Foul Frequency 4
Solid Hits 3
Starter Stamina 6
Reliever Stamina 5
Control 4
Consistency 3
Strike Frequency 1
Pitch Speed 6* (whatever works for you)
Anything else leave at default.
I use auto fielding like Armor suggested, but do what you want with that as well.
Let me know what you think.
Now, of course these may only work for me, but I think they're definitely worth a try. I was struggling with hitting on All Star and the hybrid version as well. I was also pitching too well with the same sliders. These seem to balance everything out.
All Star Difficulty for Hitting and Pitching
HUMAN
Contact 5
Power 5
Timing 6
Foul Frequency 5
Solid Hits 5
Starter Stamina 6
Reliever stamina 5
Control 4
Consistency 3
CPU
Contact 5
Power 4
Timing 5
Foul Frequency 4
Solid Hits 3
Starter Stamina 6
Reliever Stamina 5
Control 4
Consistency 3
Strike Frequency 1
Pitch Speed 6* (whatever works for you)
Anything else leave at default.
I use auto fielding like Armor suggested, but do what you want with that as well.
Let me know what you think.