Need some roster feedback

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • turty11
    All Star
    • Apr 2013
    • 8923

    #1

    Need some roster feedback

    For the first time since I got the show im just not enjoying scea ratings. Im going through using multiple sites/rating formulas re-rating all the MLB players and would like some feedback. I like what ive seen from gameplay and simming franchise, and want to know your thoughts.

    Only teams done are the Oriels, Yankees, Red Sox, and Rays so if you test it out use those teams

    roster is called bal nyy bos tam re
    Last edited by turty11; 05-19-2014, 01:41 PM.
    NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4
  • VeranKai
    Rookie
    • Mar 2014
    • 31

    #2
    Re: Need some roster feedback

    Sure, I'll check it out today or tomorrow. What were you disliking about the standard ratings the most this year?

    Also, I just uploaded a roster based on OSFM with most of the pitchers adjusted per Steamer(U) [though the lineups/rotations are more spring training based]. It's called OSFM ST and uploaded by my username if you're interested.

    Comment

    • VeranKai
      Rookie
      • Mar 2014
      • 31

      #3
      Re: Need some roster feedback

      What settings do you typically play? And do you alter the sliders at all?

      Comment

      • turty11
        All Star
        • Apr 2013
        • 8923

        #4
        Re: Need some roster feedback

        i play any/everything from rookie to all-star, for the most part i just play default sliders but atm im trying 7 cont/4 pow/3 field speed/6 field react for both cpu and human

        mostly i just hated the stats i was getting with scea rosters.. i had multiple season sims where there were multiple 55+ base stealers in each league, guys like mike napoli hitting 340+ and so on
        NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4

        Comment

        • drsublime
          MVP
          • Apr 2009
          • 1696

          #5
          Re: Need some roster feedback

          Originally posted by turty11
          i play any/everything from rookie to all-star, for the most part i just play default sliders but atm im trying 7 cont/4 pow/3 field speed/6 field react for both cpu and human

          mostly i just hated the stats i was getting with scea rosters.. i had multiple season sims where there were multiple 55+ base stealers in each league, guys like mike napoli hitting 340+ and so on
          Napoli did hit .320 in 2011.. so its possible...
          ~~~~~~~~~
          DrSublime (PSN/Xbox/Steam/Origin)

          Comment

          • turty11
            All Star
            • Apr 2013
            • 8923

            #6
            Re: Need some roster feedback

            Originally posted by drsublime
            Napoli did hit .320 in 2011.. so its possible...
            its not a 1 time thing tho. in my latest franchise sim he hit 400 through august >< ortiz had 44 homers cabrera was hitting sub 300 and so on. ive never really liked the sim stats in the show but this year it just seems worse to me, maybe because i expect more on next-gen (gameplay wise as-well. still billions of superman catches , atleast in my games)
            NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4

            Comment

            • drsublime
              MVP
              • Apr 2009
              • 1696

              #7
              Re: Need some roster feedback

              Originally posted by turty11
              its not a 1 time thing tho. in my latest franchise sim he hit 400 through august >< ortiz had 44 homers cabrera was hitting sub 300 and so on. ive never really liked the sim stats in the show but this year it just seems worse to me, maybe because i expect more on next-gen (gameplay wise as-well. still billions of superman catches , atleast in my games)
              baseball is the hardest one to predict though because there is so much of a variance in year to year stats... 5 years ago no one would have through Pujols would be hitting sub 300, and he's doing that consistently now.
              Brady Anderson never should have hit 50 homeruns, but he did etc... Adam Dunn hit .180 or something ridiculous etc, crazy things happen

              I get your point, but its baseball, it doesn't always make sense
              ~~~~~~~~~
              DrSublime (PSN/Xbox/Steam/Origin)

              Comment

              • turty11
                All Star
                • Apr 2013
                • 8923

                #8
                Re: Need some roster feedback

                yep, the unpredictability is what makes it good, until your a red sox fan this year O.o!

                after years of madden/nba 2k ive come to not like default rosters, and i hate making them but i always find myself doing it anyways...id probly still be doing it if i loved scea's roster ><
                NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4

                Comment

                • VeranKai
                  Rookie
                  • Mar 2014
                  • 31

                  #9
                  Re: Need some roster feedback

                  Gotcha. Yeah, the first few sims I did had crazy amounts of complete games and shutouts haha.

                  Well you seem to be leaning to the low side in ratings. I definitely encourage you to keep going with these - especially since it sounds like you have fun doing it!

                  Comment

                  • turty11
                    All Star
                    • Apr 2013
                    • 8923

                    #10
                    Re: Need some roster feedback

                    fun no...but it is a good way to buy time until the nba game !

                    im using fangraphs for defensive ratings and some of the numbers are astonishingly low, i actually had to make a mental minimum rating cap like nba2k has
                    NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4

                    Comment

                    • turty11
                      All Star
                      • Apr 2013
                      • 8923

                      #11
                      Re: Need some roster feedback

                      anyone tried them yet?
                      NBA 2k19 Roster and Draft project for PS4

                      Comment

                      Working...