Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Herky
    Working for the weekend
    • Jun 2004
    • 4715

    #1

    Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

    I'm new to The Show and was wondering if there was a difference in rosters to use for a dynasty? I plan on doing a deep dynasty and want to draft players and I know the Hybrid rosters have re-rated guys. Both sets sound fantastic but will drafted players not translate well to the Hybrid roster since The Show's ratings are different?
    GT: Herkyalert
    PSN: Herkyalert

    Iowa Hawkeyes
    Northern Iowa Panthers
    Minnesota Vikings
    Chicago Cubs
    Minnesota Twins
    Boston Celtics
    Minnesota Timberwolves
  • DeJohn11
    Rookie
    • Aug 2012
    • 193

    #2
    Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

    Depends on how happy you are with the ratings, equipment, and various animations given to the major league players by SCEA

    OSFM is focused on providing full minor league rosters

    Hybrid is focused on re-rating MLB players, giving them proper equipment, proper pitch repertoire, swing/windup animations etc. (this goes along WITH the full minor league roster)
    Madden CFM 10YF
    Year 1 Steelers 11-5 AFC 5th Seed

    Comment

    • thawkprime 21
      Rookie
      • Jul 2009
      • 275

      #3
      Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

      If what your asking is if players that the game generates for the draft as you finish seasons then the answer is yes and no. From my experiance in the past some of the created players from the draft fall inline well with the rating system while others dont.

      Im sure that once the rosters are complete the people that are working hard on them will be able to give you a better answer on this subject as they do extensive testing to make sure the rosters work properly in future seasons.

      Comment

      • kehlis
        Moderator
        • Jul 2008
        • 27738

        #4
        Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

        Originally posted by Herky
        I'm new to The Show and was wondering if there was a difference in rosters to use for a dynasty? I plan on doing a deep dynasty and want to draft players and I know the Hybrid rosters have re-rated guys. Both sets sound fantastic but will drafted players not translate well to the Hybrid roster since The Show's ratings are different?
        They aren't different from the show's ratings unless I misunderstand them.

        The drafted players can be whatever the pre-determined ratings the Show says they can be whereas the hybrid ratings are just to correct what's viewed to be incorrect ratings on actual current players.

        Comment

        • Vaporub83
          Rookie
          • Aug 2009
          • 399

          #5
          Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

          Originally posted by kehlis
          They aren't different from the show's ratings unless I misunderstand them.

          The drafted players can be whatever the pre-determined ratings the Show says they can be whereas the hybrid ratings are just to correct what's viewed to be incorrect ratings on actual current players.
          So when people say re-rate they don't mean using a different scale. It means just making players more of a realistic representation?
          Tampa Bay Buccaneers
          Dallas Mavericks

          "For those who believe, no explanation is necessary; for those who do not believe, no explanation will suffice." -Joseph Dunninger

          Comment

          • kehlis
            Moderator
            • Jul 2008
            • 27738

            #6
            Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

            Originally posted by Vaporub83
            So when people say re-rate they don't mean using a different scale. It means just making players more of a realistic representation?
            That's my understanding but I could be wrong.

            Comment

            • cusefan74
              MVP
              • Jul 2010
              • 2408

              #7
              Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

              Originally posted by Vaporub83
              So when people say re-rate they don't mean using a different scale. It means just making players more of a realistic representation?
              I've never used the hybrid roster myself, but I would hope they use some kind of scale to determine the ratings. If it was me I would want to use some kind of scale, but whatever, the guys that make it can do it however they want.

              Comment

              • Bondsfan
                MVP
                • Jan 2003
                • 1275

                #8
                Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                I've been wondering if there's going to be multiple versions of OSFM (not the hybrid). In years past there was a basic version, then several weeks later a corrected version with any mistakes corrected and some more players added. Last year, if I remember correctly, there was basically only one version. Is there plans for multiple releases for OSFM this year, or is the hope to get the whole thing out once and not touch it after that?

                Thanks for all the work you all do!

                Comment

                • rovert22044
                  OCD Roster Editor
                  • Dec 2010
                  • 2509

                  #9
                  Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                  I've used the Hybrid roster every year it's come out. It's by far the best roster release/version there is. The attention to detail is second to none. BUT, in previous years, I have had issues with the draft, but that's not the roster makers fault. The problem lies when players in the draft rate in the 70s and sometimes 80s, but a good total major leaguers are in the 60s and 70s. If you don't use 30 team control, the CPU teams will call these phenom prospects up super fast and you end up having a ton of high rated 18-20 year olds starting in their first year.

                  Again, there's nothing the roster makers can do to fix this. Just because this issue is prominent, doesn't mean the attention to detail should be thrown out the window. Their hard work is appreciated more than they know.

                  Despite these issues, I'd still HIGHLY recommend the Hybrid rosters.


                  Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                  Football Data Analyst @ Tracking Football
                  Founder/CEO @ JUCOHub

                  Comment

                  • huskerfan4life
                    #1 conrhusker fan
                    • Jul 2007
                    • 926

                    #10
                    Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                    :spit
                    Originally posted by rovert22044
                    I've used the Hybrid roster every year it's come out. It's by far the best roster release/version there is. The attention to detail is second to none. BUT, in previous years, I have had issues with the draft, but that's not the roster makers fault. The problem lies when players in the draft rate in the 70s and sometimes 80s, but a good total major leaguers are in the 60s and 70s. If you don't use 30 team control, the CPU teams will call these phenom prospects up super fast and you end up having a ton of high rated 18-20 year olds starting in their first year.

                    Again, there's nothing the roster makers can do to fix this. Just because this issue is prominent, doesn't mean the attention to detail should be thrown out the window. Their hard work is appreciated more than they know.

                    Despite these issues, I'd still HIGHLY recommend the Hybrid rosters.


                    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                    so if I were to use the v1 rosters then there would be no problem with the draft? also do the pitch edits make that much of a difference?
                    Madden 18
                    Kansas City Chiefs
                    Yr 1 (0-0) Pre-Season (0-1)

                    Follow Me On Twitch
                    https://www.twitch.tv/bigbadjz

                    Comment

                    • rovert22044
                      OCD Roster Editor
                      • Dec 2010
                      • 2509

                      #11
                      Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                      Originally posted by huskerfan4life
                      :spit



                      so if I were to use the v1 rosters then there would be no problem with the draft? also do the pitch edits make that much of a difference?

                      You shouldn't have an issue. But understand there will be a few very high rates rookies.

                      Also, as far as I know, OSFM V1 won't have pitch edits. And I personally think pitch edits are HUGE additions to the roster. Makes it just that much better.

                      I personally do a fun franchise while I wait until the Hybrid roster to drop. Then when they do, I do my serious, long franchise. Either way, OSFM V1 or Hybrids, you can't go wrong.


                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                      Football Data Analyst @ Tracking Football
                      Founder/CEO @ JUCOHub

                      Comment

                      • CaseIH
                        MVP
                        • Sep 2013
                        • 3945

                        #12
                        Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                        Originally posted by huskerfan4life
                        :spit

                        so if I were to use the v1 rosters then there would be no problem with the draft? also do the pitch edits make that much of a difference?




                        Id say you would be fine with either roster, might need to tweak the Drafted players a tad, or atleast for some.


                        I think there rating is basically the same for most things. Only 2 things I personally don't care for with the Hybrid is the way they have did speed in the past, typically make guys too fast that are slow as smails IRL, example Yadia Molina. Also RH/LH splits for some hitters are to close together, for guys that happen to hit a lot better from 1 side or the other.


                        Sim stat wise the Hybrid roster last yr anyway, was amazingly close to accurate as you could get. I did tweak it some like speed for instance, but all my stats with the Hybrid came out great.


                        Pitching eidts use to play a big role in the game, because SCEA pitch repertoires you wouldn't get as many K's, but now with the new movement on ball physics I don't see that t be a issue at all. Pitch edits are still noce to have cause SCEA doesn't do a great job with pitchers having the right repertoires.
                        Everyone who exalts themselves will be humbled, and he who humbles himself will be exalted- Luke14-11

                        Favorite teams:
                        MLB- Reds/ and whoever is playing the Cubs
                        NBA- Pacers
                        NFL- Dolphins & Colts

                        Comment

                        • teeds
                          Pro
                          • Jun 2003
                          • 551

                          #13
                          Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                          Originally posted by CaseIH
                          Id say you would be fine with either roster, might need to tweak the Drafted players a tad, or atleast for some.


                          I think there rating is basically the same for most things. Only 2 things I personally don't care for with the Hybrid is the way they have did speed in the past, typically make guys too fast that are slow as smails IRL, example Yadia Molina. Also RH/LH splits for some hitters are to close together, for guys that happen to hit a lot better from 1 side or the other.


                          Sim stat wise the Hybrid roster last yr anyway, was amazingly close to accurate as you could get. I did tweak it some like speed for instance, but all my stats with the Hybrid came out great.


                          Pitching eidts use to play a big role in the game, because SCEA pitch repertoires you wouldn't get as many K's, but now with the new movement on ball physics I don't see that t be a issue at all. Pitch edits are still noce to have cause SCEA doesn't do a great job with pitchers having the right repertoires.
                          New splits based on zips, new speed ratings, and new defensive ratings for the hybrid this year.

                          Comment

                          • WaitTilNextYear
                            Go Cubs Go
                            • Mar 2013
                            • 16830

                            #14
                            Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                            Originally posted by CaseIH
                            Sim stat wise the Hybrid roster last yr anyway, was amazingly close to accurate as you could get. I did tweak it some like speed for instance, but all my stats with the Hybrid came out great.
                            Yeah I noticed that, too. Kudos to the guys who made that possible. I bet the guys who worked on that are pretty cool.

                            Originally posted by teeds
                            New splits based on zips, new speed ratings, and new defensive ratings for the hybrid this year.
                            Speed and defensive ratings are systematically based on data this year for the Hybrid. That is a first. Or so I hear from the guys working on it.
                            Chicago Cubs | Chicago Bulls | Green Bay Packers | Michigan Wolverines

                            Comment

                            • HopiDesertPriest
                              Banned
                              • Nov 2013
                              • 597

                              #15
                              Re: Question about OSFM vs Hybrid rosters

                              may the Lord bless ALL those who work on this years OSFM AND HYBRID !!!!!

                              ** THEY ARE THE ELECT SOULS CHOSEN TO CREATE THE GREATEST ROSTERS EVER MADE **


                              so ... : )


                              osfm this weekend


                              and


                              full hybrid rosters by mid-may ?


                              that is my prophetic utterance !!!!!


                              ** I LOVE YOU, WILLARD **

                              Comment

                              Working...