OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • sxaalex
    Pro
    • Apr 2014
    • 667

    #271
    Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

    list of Generic Faces that need to updated -Padres
    1b luis domoromo
    2b benji Gonzalez
    Rp Tayron guerrero
    SS Juan carlos gamboa
    Last edited by sxaalex; 04-14-2015, 11:20 PM.

    Comment

    • Luftbud
      Banned
      • Jul 2010
      • 59

      #272
      Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

      Originally posted by ItAllFades
      No problem. Keep an eye on the Cubs thread for when it drops.
      Will be on the lookout! Cubs almost came back again tonight! Can't wait to see what the youth movement brings.

      Comment

      • geisterhome
        MVP
        • Sep 2011
        • 2101

        #273
        Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

        Guys any news on how the V2 ROSTER is coming along?
        Spending time with Jesus!

        -Glad to be an Operation Sports Member!-

        Comment

        • volsfan39
          Rookie
          • Jan 2008
          • 373

          #274
          Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

          Catcher Luke Carlin's audio says Brett Jackson..simple fix
          "Baseball is Life"

          Streaming on Twitch
          "Volsfan39's Statis Pro Baseball (Ultimate 80's) MLB 20
          https://www.twitch.tv/volsfan3939

          Comment

          • sxaalex
            Pro
            • Apr 2014
            • 667

            #275
            Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

            Originally posted by sxaalex
            <hr style="color:#393939" size="1"> list of Generic Faces that need to updated -Red sox
            Sp Jake Cosart
            Sp Justin Haley
            Sp Madison Younginer
            Sp Michael Kopech
            Rp Jess Todd
            Rp Simon Mercedes
            1b Sam travis
            2b Carlos Asauje
            3b Jordan bettis
            3b Michael Chavis
            3b Rafael Devers
            SS Mike Miller
            of Kevin Heller
            of Shannon Wilkerson
            of Nick Longhi
            Sp Robby Scott
            Anybody have update caps of these prospect

            Comment

            • sxaalex
              Pro
              • Apr 2014
              • 667

              #276
              Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

              Originally posted by sxaalex
              list of Generic Faces that need to updated -Padres
              1b luis domoromo
              2b benji Gonzalez
              Rp Tayron guerrero
              SS Juan carlos gamboa
              Anybody have update caps of these prospect

              Comment

              • GoBucs09
                Pro
                • Feb 2009
                • 629

                #277
                Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                Originally posted by russilini
                IM SORRY IF I WAS HARSH...REALLY...IVE DONE OVER 50 SEASONS OF ROSTERS...I KNOW ITS HARD....and these rosters arent as bad as i perhaps made them seem...i checked baltmore..boston and yanks so far...i did make about 30 changes...for instance...zach davies pitch selection was way off..he doesnt throw sinker/slider according to mlb scouting report...mike hobgood is not a starter but RP ,since his injury and his velocity is down...but who ever did it, got his wind up spot on...very nice...then i added like 5 players so that baltimore would have their top 20 prospects...did same type stuff with boston...yoan BTW is perfect stance,,,excellent job...yankees missing top prospects, but then again 2 of their top prospects are only 17....good job moving the free agents to correct places...so i must have sounded harsh...im just a nut case...if i see someone with wrong stance or wind up...it ruins it for me....these rosters are very playable as they are...but ill spend a week...make about 400 changes, no matter how minor....i just need that in my game...but all in all nice work
                Russilini,

                Your first post probably should have included a list of players you think need updated. The way you wrote your first post came off as trolling, to make it worse, a new member joined in April of 2015 to defend your post which did not deserve defending and makes it look like you created a ghost account. You probably got put on ignore now so if you did have useful input, it may go unnoticed now.

                Your concern about top 20 prospects is unwarranted though as most teams were done by fans of said team who follow the team and know which prospects warrant being included and those that don't. You see, OSFM tries to find a balance between accurate MLB/AAA/AA opening day rosters and prospects. Quite frankly, 90 man rosters is not enough. If we did all 20 prospects for each team then the MLB/AAA/AA rosters would be inaccurate and someone would be on here complaining about that. It is not possible to make everyone happy.

                Most of your "criticism" has been subjective opinion, not constructive criticism.

                A lot of time and effort has gone into this roster and everyone who contributed gave up their own personal time without any compensation. Unfortunately, there is an unbelievable amount of detail required to even come close to perfect. I can't imagine any OTHER roster available out there puts in as much detail and accuracy that this roster does. I've looked at several of the of the other "top" rosters an none come close to even a fraction of a fraction of high quality as this one.

                If you know a better roster out there, please, let me know. Otherwise, more constructive feedback and less trolling might help improve these rosters.
                "I am more valuable to my team hitting .330 than swinging for home runs." - Roberto Clemente

                Comment

                • beantownbruins
                  Rookie
                  • Jul 2009
                  • 476

                  #278
                  Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                  Originally posted by GoBucs09
                  Russilini,

                  Your first post probably should have included a list of players you think need updated. The way you wrote your first post came off as trolling, to make it worse, a new member joined in April of 2015 to defend your post which did not deserve defending and makes it look like you created a ghost account. You probably got put on ignore now so if you did have useful input, it may go unnoticed now.

                  Your concern about top 20 prospects is unwarranted though as most teams were done by fans of said team who follow the team and know which prospects warrant being included and those that don't. You see, OSFM tries to find a balance between accurate MLB/AAA/AA opening day rosters and prospects. Quite frankly, 90 man rosters is not enough. If we did all 20 prospects for each team then the MLB/AAA/AA rosters would be inaccurate and someone would be on here complaining about that. It is not possible to make everyone happy.

                  Most of your "criticism" has been subjective opinion, not constructive criticism.

                  A lot of time and effort has gone into this roster and everyone who contributed gave up their own personal time without any compensation. Unfortunately, there is an unbelievable amount of detail required to even come close to perfect. I can't imagine any OTHER roster available out there puts in as much detail and accuracy that this roster does. I've looked at several of the of the other "top" rosters an none come close to even a fraction of a fraction of high quality as this one.

                  If you know a better roster out there, please, let me know. Otherwise, more constructive feedback and less trolling might help improve these rosters.
                  Well said! I was trying to respond to his comments with something similar to this but it wasn't coming out right and would have resulted in me getting kicked off the site lol. Well said man.
                  BOSTON BRUINS
                  BOSTON CELTICS
                  BOSTON RED SOX
                  NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS

                  Comment

                  • BroadStreetDog
                    Rookie
                    • Apr 2015
                    • 12

                    #279
                    Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                    Originally posted by knich
                    You're kidding right?
                    Yeah, I'm kidding. That's why I brought it up to begin with and spent three posts pointing out the merit of his poorly constructed message. He may write like a caveman, but his point about pitcher makeup had merit in the context of a corrections thread.

                    If you disagree, the only rational argument would be that you think the pitcher makeup is spot on. I have no idea if it is or isn't - I don't have the rosters - but assuming his information is accurate, of course it's relevant to improving the quality of the product.

                    Comment

                    • BroadStreetDog
                      Rookie
                      • Apr 2015
                      • 12

                      #280
                      Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                      Originally posted by GoBucs09
                      Russilini,

                      Your first post probably should have included a list of players you think need updated. The way you wrote your first post came off as trolling, to make it worse, a new member joined in April of 2015 to defend your post which did not deserve defending and makes it look like you created a ghost account. You probably got put on ignore now so if you did have useful input, it may go unnoticed now.
                      I'm not a ghost account - but I can see the forrest through the trees. Yes, he approached the topic in a terrible fashion, yes, the overall quality of your product over the years has been exceptional, and yes - to your point - he should've included more detail regarding which pitchers needed updating.

                      But if what he said is true, let's not kid ourselves and say that isn't something worth fixing.

                      Comment

                      • beantownbruins
                        Rookie
                        • Jul 2009
                        • 476

                        #281
                        Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                        Originally posted by BroadStreetDog
                        I have no idea if it is or isn't - I don't have the rosters -
                        Soooooooooo why are you commenting in this thread? Especially when your comments are defending a guy who was insanely rude to one of the lead roster makers...
                        BOSTON BRUINS
                        BOSTON CELTICS
                        BOSTON RED SOX
                        NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS

                        Comment

                        • Threeebs
                          Rookie
                          • Mar 2013
                          • 451

                          #282
                          Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                          Originally posted by geisterhome
                          Guys any news on how the V2 ROSTER is coming along?
                          Update! It's... Coming... Along!

                          It cracks me up how impatient some of you guys are. I mean you waited this long. There's a lot to do in this world. Why not keep yourself distracted by doing something else until you see a thread pop up regarding a V2 release?

                          I can't speak for everyone but for me, I prefer a near perfect product so I'll wait for another month or two if I have to. And this is coming from a fairly impatient person myself...
                          T.K.

                          Comment

                          • BroadStreetDog
                            Rookie
                            • Apr 2015
                            • 12

                            #283
                            Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                            Originally posted by beantownbruins
                            Soooooooooo why are you commenting in this thread? Especially when your comments are defending a guy who was insanely rude to one of the lead roster makers...
                            Just because I haven't played The Show since the rosters have been released - a whole three days - doesn't mean I'm not a fan of the product or disinterested in it.

                            I purchase The Show every year and am a big fan of what these guys do. They continually put out the best rosters year after year and their commitment to the quality and timeliness of it is seriously impressive. However, the purpose of this thread is to intelligently criticize the product to improve it.

                            While the guy who brought up the pitcher makeup certainly did not argue his point articulately, that doesn't discount the merit of the underlying point. Considering I have an interest in the product, I think it's easy to see why I'd want to make sure the underlying point doesn't get buried by the poor fashion in which it was presented.

                            I am not defending the poster as much as I am defending the merit of the issue raised.
                            Last edited by BroadStreetDog; 04-15-2015, 09:46 AM.

                            Comment

                            • MrOldboy
                              MVP
                              • Feb 2011
                              • 2653

                              #284
                              Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                              I noticed Mark Zagunis didn't make the final roster, he was on the roster I submitted. He's a top 20 Cubs prospect for sure. I'd honestly prefer he was in over some other prospects. With the catching depth in the system now I think maybe Contreras could be cut in favor of Zagunis. Teagarden is also injured and not on the AAA roster, but if he has to be in due to being an SCEA player than that is ok.

                              Comment

                              • rjackson
                                MVP
                                • Apr 2005
                                • 1661

                                #285
                                Re: OSFM2015 V.1 - Corrections

                                Quick question, will v2 be straight up corrections to v1 or will the CAPs be imported onto the last SCEA roster with all of their corrections as well?

                                Comment

                                Working...