Question for the roster pros in here. I use OSFM rosters and in my Yankees franchise have been editing/rerating the minor leaguers and a few of the major leaguers who seem to be rated inaccurately. I’m a huge Baseball America nerd and yes, I peeled through all the acouting reports for my farmhands trying to be as accurately as possible. I’ve been using the following guidelines based on overall rating:
85+ All-Star Players (big range, subject to actual tools for each player)
80-84 MLB cornerstone players, not quite all-star caliber
75-79 Unspectacular major league regulars
70-74 Fill-ins, platoon guys, or guys with one strong tool
65-69 AAA regular
60-64 AA regular
55-59 A+ regular
50-54 Low-A / Short-season ball regular
40’s - Rookie ball, high school draftees, teenage international guys
I find prospects with big tools (plus-plus arm or speed) won’t fit into this mold because their offensive attributes will be behind their overall rating. Just wondering if Im on the right track here?
85+ All-Star Players (big range, subject to actual tools for each player)
80-84 MLB cornerstone players, not quite all-star caliber
75-79 Unspectacular major league regulars
70-74 Fill-ins, platoon guys, or guys with one strong tool
65-69 AAA regular
60-64 AA regular
55-59 A+ regular
50-54 Low-A / Short-season ball regular
40’s - Rookie ball, high school draftees, teenage international guys
I find prospects with big tools (plus-plus arm or speed) won’t fit into this mold because their offensive attributes will be behind their overall rating. Just wondering if Im on the right track here?