The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

[PjPage59]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Can we please make it so that all the rosters represent everything current. That would be super ideal. Especially after us waiting so long. I think its imperative to all of us that the rosters represent the MOST current and therefore the most accurate to what's happening around the league.

Like today, the Yankees claimed Taylor Trammell off waivers from the Dodgers, and even though I'm not going to be using the Yankees, I still think something of a move that minor makes a massive impact on our realism.

Love the effort with the prospects, ratings, gear/equipment, stances, pitch styles, etc... but Idk, me personally I think we would ALL LOVE it if the rosters represented the league RIGHT NOW as opposed to opening day. So much has happened in the league already.. forget injuries.. but at least the roster movement. Thats so important to me.

I strongly disagree with this. Opening day is the best place to start. It's the best for realism and that's what a franchise should be. If you want little moves like that before you start, edit the roster yourself beforehand.

[The Kid 24]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Can we please make it so that all the rosters represent everything current. That would be super ideal. Especially after us waiting so long. I think its imperative to all of us that the rosters represent the MOST current and therefore the most accurate to what's happening around the league.

Like today, the Yankees claimed Taylor Trammell off waivers from the Dodgers, and even though I'm not going to be using the Yankees, I still think something of a move that minor makes a massive impact on our realism.

Love the effort with the prospects, ratings, gear/equipment, stances, pitch styles, etc... but Idk, me personally I think we would ALL LOVE it if the rosters represented the league RIGHT NOW as opposed to opening day. So much has happened in the league already.. forget injuries.. but at least the roster movement. Thats so important to me.

Important for you, yea… Most of us here prefer OD rosters.


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Mongo16]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I strongly disagree with this. Opening day is the best place to start. It's the best for realism and that's what a franchise should be. If you want little moves like that before you start, edit the roster yourself beforehand.

I agree with this. I plan to make the transactions happen the day they happened in my franchise mode

[Fcshuckers73]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

So pumped for these!! Opening day is always best, imo. Transactions that happen in the real MLB are done out of necessity sometimes. However, I may not need to make the same moves or other teams may not need to make matching moves. Injuries and performance make my universe unique and its own world.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[prxblmz]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

True, you all make valid points.

[PjPage59]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I agree with this. I plan to make the transactions happen the day they happened in my franchise mode

That's exactly how I play my Franchise as well.

[seb2314]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I agree with most people on here. We can always make the transactions ourselves. Keep it that way and we're all excited for this release.

[Funkycorm]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I sim years into the future then play so OD rosters aren't a personal priority to me. But neither is using the most up to date transactions roster either. I look beyond that and more at what rosters are best for simming into future seasons so I am in a different minority here.

[StonewallTexan]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Can we please make it so that all the rosters represent everything current. That would be super ideal. Especially after us waiting so long. I think its imperative to all of us that the rosters represent the MOST current and therefore the most accurate to what's happening around the league.

Like today, the Yankees claimed Taylor Trammell off waivers from the Dodgers, and even though I'm not going to be using the Yankees, I still think something of a move that minor makes a massive impact on our realism.

Love the effort with the prospects, ratings, gear/equipment, stances, pitch styles, etc... but Idk, me personally I think we would ALL LOVE it if the rosters represented the league RIGHT NOW as opposed to opening day. So much has happened in the league already.. forget injuries.. but at least the roster movement. Thats so important to me.

Please do not do this. Opening Day rosters are much more useful for franchise purposes.

[Mongo16]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

I agree with most people on here. We can always make the transactions ourselves. Keep it that way and we're all excited for this release.

I agree, plus doing the transactions properly in the edit roster screen is almost impossible. Julio Teheran got DFA’d by the Mets and the Cubs sign him. In the edit roster screen you have to basically trade him from FA

[1CK1S]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Can we please make it so that all the rosters represent everything current. That would be super ideal. Especially after us waiting so long. I think its imperative to all of us that the rosters represent the MOST current and therefore the most accurate to what's happening around the league.

Like today, the Yankees claimed Taylor Trammell off waivers from the Dodgers, and even though I'm not going to be using the Yankees, I still think something of a move that minor makes a massive impact on our realism.

Love the effort with the prospects, ratings, gear/equipment, stances, pitch styles, etc... but Idk, me personally I think we would ALL LOVE it if the rosters represented the league RIGHT NOW as opposed to opening day. So much has happened in the league already.. forget injuries.. but at least the roster movement. Thats so important to me.

No

Because it's only three to four weeks into the season and it's not like last year where this roster and the minors came out at the start of July

[mdiggitydawg]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

lol, do the work yourself then.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

My thoughts exactly! Not like Cyclonic and his group are getting paid...it's a labor of love, let's not kill it

[Cycloniac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question for the room:

When you play franchise, do you usually set lineups/rotations for the CPU manually? Like are you planning to advance to regular season and set opening day lineups/rotations for the teams?

Last year (and in years past) before release, I did a final ratings tweak to the hitting attributes so teams would have the right guys playing DH and the correct positions. This helped the CPU default lineups be more realistic (at least in terms of the correct players being in the game, not batting order necesserily).

It's a little tedious, but it does work.

Is this something people would like me to do, or are you planning to adjust lineups yourself?

[Lisac]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question for the room:

When you play franchise, do you usually set lineups/rotations for the CPU manually? Like are you planning to advance to regular season and set opening day lineups/rotations for the teams?

Last year (and in years past) before release, I did a final ratings tweak to the hitting attributes so teams would have the right guys playing DH and the correct positions. This helped the CPU default lineups be more realistic (at least in terms of the correct players being in the game, not batting order necesserily).

It's a little tedious, but it does work.

Is this something people would like me to do, or are you planning to adjust lineups yourself?

I sim to Opening Day and than use Fansgraphs to set all Lineups/Rotations and Bullpens

[StonewallTexan]

Re: The TrueSim Roster Project: MLB 24

Question for the room:

When you play franchise, do you usually set lineups/rotations for the CPU manually? Like are you planning to advance to regular season and set opening day lineups/rotations for the teams?

Last year (and in years past) before release, I did a final ratings tweak to the hitting attributes so teams would have the right guys playing DH and the correct positions. This helped the CPU default lineups be more realistic (at least in terms of the correct players being in the game, not batting order necesserily).

It's a little tedious, but it does work.

Is this something people would like me to do, or are you planning to adjust lineups yourself?

I leave everything on CPU control (never set lineups outside of my teams myself), so yes, that is helpful.