Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tuned)

[TopSide83]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

with Classic pitching in Legend ? Playing with default settings for awhile now and it's not what i'm experimenting. Maybe I'm aiming more at corners than you do but if I don't, I'm usually hit hard.

Yes to both.. my pitching has held up well so far but it’s still challenging which is nice

[dowie]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Yes to both.. my pitching has held up well so far but it’s still challenging which is nice

How many games into the season are you? It's been my experience that pitching has the upper hand in April (sorta like real life).

As the season progresses the offense picks up.

I think The Show does a great job representing the ebbs and flow of real baseball.

Dowie

[TopSide83]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

How many games into the season are you? It's been my experience that pitching has the upper hand in April (sorta like real life).

As the season progresses the offense picks up.

I think The Show does a great job representing the ebbs and flow of real baseball.

Dowie

13 games im 7-6 with the tigers

[dowie]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

13 games im 7-6 with the tigers

My recommendation is to keep playing (without tweaking sliders) until the calendar reaches mid May.

If it still feels off to you, then it might be time to adjust.

Dowie

[Gabby]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Armor, I am going to start a franchise using 2011 roster. I was wondering using your sliders when you sim other games in league is there a problem with too many complete games. If so do you change any slider values when simming.
Also how do you handle the bullpen. I know when I played games using current rosters the bullpen logic was messed up. Thanks always enjoy your sliders

[Burgess]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Armor, I am going to start a franchise using 2011 roster. I was wondering using your sliders when you sim other games in league is there a problem with too many complete games. If so do you change any slider values when simming.
Also how do you handle the bullpen. I know when I played games using current rosters the bullpen logic was messed up. Thanks always enjoy your sliders

Last year we lowered SP stamina to 2, RP stamina to 0 and hook to 10 for simmed games. Worked very well

I read and used this bullpen setup and it worked great.

LR1 and 2 lowest ranked relievers with stamina less than 40. (May have to edit stamina)

SU1 best reliever that isn’t closer with stamina less than 50

SU2 blank

CL - closer stamina less than 30

MR1,2,3 relievers ranked best to worst with stamina less than 50

MR4 can be long reliever or starter (stamina doesn’t matter)

Before you play a game, for cpu, put the MR1 reliever into SU2

Also, for the cpu starter, before you play increase his stamina by 10 so they can pitch deeper into the game if they are pitching well

This setup worked the best that I ever used

[Gabby]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Last year we lowered SP stamina to 2, RP stamina to 0 and hook to 10 for simmed games. Worked very well

I read and used this bullpen setup and it worked great.

LR1 and 2 lowest ranked relievers with stamina less than 40. (May have to edit stamina)

SU1 best reliever that isn’t closer with stamina less than 50

SU2 blank

CL - closer stamina less than 30

MR1,2,3 relievers ranked best to worst with stamina less than 50

MR4 can be long reliever or starter (stamina doesn’t matter)

Before you play a game, for cpu, put the MR1 reliever into SU2

Also, for the cpu starter, before you play increase his stamina by 10 so they can pitch deeper into the game if they are pitching well

This setup worked the best that I ever used

Thanks will try sliders and bullpen setup

[dowie]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Last year we lowered SP stamina to 2, RP stamina to 0 and hook to 10 for simmed games. Worked very well

I read and used this bullpen setup and it worked great.

LR1 and 2 lowest ranked relievers with stamina less than 40. (May have to edit stamina)

SU1 best reliever that isn’t closer with stamina less than 50

SU2 blank

CL - closer stamina less than 30

MR1,2,3 relievers ranked best to worst with stamina less than 50

MR4 can be long reliever or starter (stamina doesn’t matter)

Before you play a game, for cpu, put the MR1 reliever into SU2

Also, for the cpu starter, before you play increase his stamina by 10 so they can pitch deeper into the game if they are pitching well

This setup worked the best that I ever used

Anyone know if this set up works for 24 (using modern day rosters)?

Dowie

[Burgess]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Anyone know if this set up works for 24 (using modern day rosters)?

Dowie

I’ve just been playing spring training games while waiting for 2025 opening day roster to drop

[Armor and Sword]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Anyone know if this set up works for 24 (using modern day rosters)?

Dowie

They do....really solid.

Only thing you may tweak is starter stamina....to tune where you think you want it....me I am good with the OP for any roster or era.

As far as 25.....everything will depend on what I see in February leading up to the release.

My priorities have changed with franchise mode. Since I play every pitch every inning....how far am I going to get with each iteration? Couple that with other rosters I love to play......it's not even about Franchise mode for longevity anymore.

It's all about "give us full customization to create any era we want".

Division realignment. Eliminate expansion teams, Era based rule options.....that's what I want to see more than anything.

Without Y2Y...my incentive for another Yankees 8 year and still going franchise is dead. If I can't continue on the latest game......my motivation has died.

I like playing a better version if it really is. 23 and 24 are better on the diamond than 20...there I said it. They play a better game of baseball.

But I can't get invested into multi year franchises anymore.....and that's ok. I love playing one full season and moving on to another roster.

Spice of life.

When you play a game as long as I have with The Show sometimes you gotta re-invent how you approach it.

My new approach with modern and classic baseball is one and done and move on to the next roster....it's great.

So let's see what 25 has added. If anything it will be my modern season on 25 and I will continue classic baseball on 24.....and then by year end ATG and company will have some other rosters done for 25.

So I am undecided on 25 right now......but my baseball itch is in full swing.

[Burgess]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

They do....really solid.

Only thing you may tweak is starter stamina....to tune where you think you want it....me I am good with the OP for any roster or era.

As far as 25.....everything will depend on what I see in February leading up to the release.

My priorities have changed with franchise mode. Since I play every pitch every inning....how far am I going to get with each iteration? Couple that with other rosters I love to play......it's not even about Franchise mode for longevity anymore.

It's all about "give us full customization to create any era we want".

Division realignment. Eliminate expansion teams, Era based rule options.....that's what I want to see more than anything.

Without Y2Y...my incentive for another Yankees 8 year and still going franchise is dead. If I can't continue on the latest game......my motivation has died.

I like playing a better version if it really is. 23 and 24 are better on the diamond than 20...there I said it. They play a better game of baseball.

But I can't get invested into multi year franchises anymore.....and that's ok. I love playing one full season and moving on to another roster.

Spice of life.

When you play a game as long as I have with The Show sometimes you gotta re-invent how you approach it.

My new approach with modern and classic baseball is one and done and move on to the next roster....it's great.

So let's see what 25 has added. If anything it will be my modern season on 25 and I will continue classic baseball on 24.....and then by year end ATG and company will have some other rosters done for 25.

So I am undecided on 25 right now......but my baseball itch is in full swing.

Geez Armour, you are a hard guy to follow for a guy like me who uses your exact sliders and plays the game/version as you do, lol. I have always played modern day franchises. Do your sliders on the OP work for modern day franchises on '24? Lowering SP to 2 and RP to 0 work for me as well?

I am waiting for opening day rosters to be put in the vault to start a modern day franchise on '24. Now I guess I have to buy '25 as well!!

[rhouserjr0614]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

They do....really solid.

Only thing you may tweak is starter stamina....to tune where you think you want it....me I am good with the OP for any roster or era.

As far as 25.....everything will depend on what I see in February leading up to the release.

My priorities have changed with franchise mode. Since I play every pitch every inning....how far am I going to get with each iteration? Couple that with other rosters I love to play......it's not even about Franchise mode for longevity anymore.

It's all about "give us full customization to create any era we want".

Division realignment. Eliminate expansion teams, Era based rule options.....that's what I want to see more than anything.

Without Y2Y...my incentive for another Yankees 8 year and still going franchise is dead. If I can't continue on the latest game......my motivation has died.

I like playing a better version if it really is. 23 and 24 are better on the diamond than 20...there I said it. They play a better game of baseball.

But I can't get invested into multi year franchises anymore.....and that's ok. I love playing one full season and moving on to another roster.

Spice of life.

When you play a game as long as I have with The Show sometimes you gotta re-invent how you approach it.

My new approach with modern and classic baseball is one and done and move on to the next roster....it's great.

So let's see what 25 has added. If anything it will be my modern season on 25 and I will continue classic baseball on 24.....and then by year end ATG and company will have some other rosters done for 25.

So I am undecided on 25 right now......but my baseball itch is in full swing.

Same here.

Quick question, is it okay to use current rosters with these sliders?

[vertman]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

They do....really solid.

Only thing you may tweak is starter stamina....to tune where you think you want it....me I am good with the OP for any roster or era.

As far as 25.....everything will depend on what I see in February leading up to the release.

My priorities have changed with franchise mode. Since I play every pitch every inning....how far am I going to get with each iteration? Couple that with other rosters I love to play......it's not even about Franchise mode for longevity anymore.

It's all about "give us full customization to create any era we want".

Division realignment. Eliminate expansion teams, Era based rule options.....that's what I want to see more than anything.

Without Y2Y...my incentive for another Yankees 8 year and still going franchise is dead. If I can't continue on the latest game......my motivation has died.

I like playing a better version if it really is. 23 and 24 are better on the diamond than 20...there I said it. They play a better game of baseball.

But I can't get invested into multi year franchises anymore.....and that's ok. I love playing one full season and moving on to another roster.

Spice of life.

When you play a game as long as I have with The Show sometimes you gotta re-invent how you approach it.

My new approach with modern and classic baseball is one and done and move on to the next roster....it's great.

So let's see what 25 has added. If anything it will be my modern season on 25 and I will continue classic baseball on 24.....and then by year end ATG and company will have some other rosters done for 25.

So I am undecided on 25 right now......but my baseball itch is in full swing.

Question regarding injuries when playing with classic rosters and single season replays.
So I know that with 26 or 40 man rosters you would roll with injuries off. My question is with 93 man classic rosters would you play with them on for single season replay or off? Player preference?

[dowie]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Question regarding injuries when playing with classic rosters and single season replays.
So I know that with 26 or 40 man rosters you would roll with injuries off. My question is with 93 man classic rosters would you play with them on for single season replay or off? Player preference?

IMO, personal preference when rolling with 90-man classic rosters.

BTW, for anyone still wondering:

In the 2024 real MLB season the total # of CG's was 28 and the total # of 200 IP pitchers was 4.

Using Armor's exact OP slider set, BUT changing SP stamina to 2, RP stamina to 0 and hook to 10 when simming games got me to within 5% of those #'s. I tested simming the entire season 10 x's, so I am really confident in saying the 2/0/10 sim set up works and holds up really well. The only problem is I saw several RP's pitch north of 100 games. Grrrr.



Dowie

[Armor and Sword]

Re: Armor & Sword's Clean Screen Classic/Directional MLB The Show 24 Sliders (ATG Tun

Question regarding injuries when playing with classic rosters and single season replays.
So I know that with 26 or 40 man rosters you would roll with injuries off. My question is with 93 man classic rosters would you play with them on for single season replay or off? Player preference?

Yeah with 40 man I tend to go "on" but sometimes I will do off (like I am with 1990 right now)...93 man I have them on. And if I know it's a season replay trading is not happening.