which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

[Wayne]

I just bought MVP 2004 for the PC because I found out that I can use mods and patches to fix up the issues. The same goes for HH2K4. Now, which game is more realistic and true to baseball? How about the console versions? I couldn't seem to get a good set of sliders for the XBOX version and was frustrated that I couldn't hit my spots well with good pitchers while the cpu could. I'm just going to sell MVP 2004 online since I can't return it now because I opened it up and I can only exchange the game. The game box is missing disc 2.

[GB33]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

I too would like to know this. I am not usually a fan of PC gaming, but with patches and DL's things can be much improved. Have read of good sliders for HH 2004 on Xbox though I do not have it (on PS2 though) so I thought of picking it up, but I am just very excited for mlb2006. But being a tight arse I wouldnt mind grabbing HH on Xbox setting rosters and sliders and being on my way.

[GB33]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

I too would like to know this. I am not usually a fan of PC gaming, but with patches and DL's things can be much improved. Have read of good sliders for HH 2004 on Xbox though I do not have it (on PS2 though) so I thought of picking it up, but I am just very excited for mlb2006. But being a tight arse I wouldnt mind grabbing HH on Xbox setting rosters and sliders and being on my way.

[metal134]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

High Heat is BY FAR more realistic. It is the most realistic baseball game to date. We'll see if MVP or MLB can surpass that, but for now, it's High Heat.

[metal134]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

High Heat is BY FAR more realistic. It is the most realistic baseball game to date. We'll see if MVP or MLB can surpass that, but for now, it's High Heat.

[Pared]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

High Heat is BY FAR more realistic. It is the most realistic baseball game to date. We'll see if MVP or MLB can surpass that, but for now, it's High Heat.

Agreed.

While I absolutely loved MVP last year, I'd still rank HH as higher on the "realism" scale.

[Pared]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

High Heat is BY FAR more realistic. It is the most realistic baseball game to date. We'll see if MVP or MLB can surpass that, but for now, it's High Heat.

Agreed.

While I absolutely loved MVP last year, I'd still rank HH as higher on the "realism" scale.

[RaidersBaby]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

Unfortunately the 2004 version of High heat was poor in many ways. The player models got worse, hissing sounds from 4 years ago were still there, the interface was one of the worst in history. They have also always used a very poor color scheme. Reds have a pinkish-purple to them and greens look awful.

High Heat 2002 remains my favorite (red box with Vlad from Montreal on the cover). Now that was a baseball game!

[RaidersBaby]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

Unfortunately the 2004 version of High heat was poor in many ways. The player models got worse, hissing sounds from 4 years ago were still there, the interface was one of the worst in history. They have also always used a very poor color scheme. Reds have a pinkish-purple to them and greens look awful.

High Heat 2002 remains my favorite (red box with Vlad from Montreal on the cover). Now that was a baseball game!

[Keirik]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

if we are talking just pure gameplay, HH without a doubt is above and beyond MVP. If you want a balance of gameplay vs graphics and presentation, then MVP.

for hardcore realism however, HH04 is better by far.

[Keirik]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

if we are talking just pure gameplay, HH without a doubt is above and beyond MVP. If you want a balance of gameplay vs graphics and presentation, then MVP.

for hardcore realism however, HH04 is better by far.

[nyisles16]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

HH was a great game - not pleasing graphically but played great out of the box.. otherwise, just wait for Pared & his sliders & you'll have a realistic game...

[nyisles16]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

HH was a great game - not pleasing graphically but played great out of the box.. otherwise, just wait for Pared & his sliders & you'll have a realistic game...

[RaidersBaby]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

Ok.

Then Baseball Pro 98

[RaidersBaby]

Re: which game is more realistic for the PC or XBOX: MVP 2004 or HH2K4?

Ok.

Then Baseball Pro 98