Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • annan
    Banned
    • Feb 2004
    • 355

    #1

    Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

    I was wondering what your thoughts were. To me it seems like there is no noticeable difference when I take an above average defender (bagwell) out and sub in someone who is a poor defender or even is playing out of position. No difference in reaction time, catching, etc.

    We all know about the super arms in the OF, but i was wondering if you guys felt the same way about general defensive play. It's to the point that I am thinking of going back to mvp where I could really see a difference in a good and bad defender. I love pitching and hitting in this game, but once the ball is in play, something just doesn't feel right.

    Any thoughts?
  • annan
    Banned
    • Feb 2004
    • 355

    #2
    Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

    Any thoughts? Am I crazy or do defensive attributes really play out in the field?

    Comment

    • kac
      Pro
      • Feb 2003
      • 530

      #3
      Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

      Originally posted by annan
      I was wondering what your thoughts were. To me it seems like there is no noticeable difference when I take an above average defender (bagwell) out and sub in someone who is a poor defender or even is playing out of position. No difference in reaction time, catching, etc.

      We all know about the super arms in the OF, but i was wondering if you guys felt the same way about general defensive play. It's to the point that I am thinking of going back to mvp where I could really see a difference in a good and bad defender. I love pitching and hitting in this game, but once the ball is in play, something just doesn't feel right.

      Any thoughts?
      I have been thinking the same thing every time I try to enjoy this game and overlook the problems something happens that makes me want to quit playing.Its sad that I have a 360 and I have to go back to a ps2 to play a decent baseball game.

      Comment

      • baa7
        Banned
        • Jul 2004
        • 11691

        #4
        Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

        There is no diffence, and there wasn't last year either. Do a test. Max out a player's hitting ratings and and set his fielding ratings to zero. I'm guessing the guy will be rated 100, easy. Now max out the fielding ratings and lower hitting ratings to zero. I'll bet the guy isn't rated above 40 or so. The only ratings that make any real difference are the offensive ratings. That's why the CPU will put hitters in fielding positions they don't belong -- their defensive ratings make no difference.

        Comment

        • annan
          Banned
          • Feb 2004
          • 355

          #5
          Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

          Well that is disappointing to hear. Has anyon ebeen able to work around this (maybe with sliders???), or are you all just living with it?

          Comment

          • baa7
            Banned
            • Jul 2004
            • 11691

            #6
            Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

            Originally posted by annan
            Well that is disappointing to hear. Has anyon ebeen able to work around this (maybe with sliders???), or are you all just living with it?
            With 2K5, I spent many hours re-rating most of the players in the game -- lowering most fielding ratings, in other words. It made a huge difference. The CPU would then sub in defensive specialists late in the game when it had a lead. But it's a lot of work.

            Comment

            • annan
              Banned
              • Feb 2004
              • 355

              #7
              Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

              That sounds like a serious pain (one which I dont have the time to do). Do you know if anyone has done this (as I know they have altered OF arm ratings) and posted a roster for download? Thanks.

              Comment

              • stretch45
                Rookie
                • Feb 2006
                • 149

                #8
                Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

                i would say no but the pitching is great in this game

                and also i learned u can bounce off the wall without falling did it once thats 1 time so think like the oufield play

                Comment

                • annan
                  Banned
                  • Feb 2004
                  • 355

                  #9
                  Re: Do u guys feel like the defensive ratings matter in this game?

                  How do u bounce of the wall without falling over?

                  Comment

                  Working...