PS3 vs 360 version

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bisons18
    Rookie
    • Jan 2005
    • 101

    #1

    PS3 vs 360 version

    Which one is better between the PS3 version and the 360 version? I played on 360 and it's pretty amazing, but I don't have a next-gen console and I'm looking to buy one.
  • kumala
    Pro
    • Oct 2002
    • 599

    #2
    Re: PS3 vs 360 version

    360 by far is the better version. ps3 has framerate issues and doesn't look as good to me. just my observations though.

    Comment

    • kac
      Pro
      • Feb 2003
      • 530

      #3
      Re: PS3 vs 360 version

      I have them both and I think the ps3 version runs smoother I was surprised because the review I read said the 360 version ran smoother.The 360version has stutering when throwing the ball from the outfield the ps3 version is very smooth and I think the graphics are the same but look cleaner on the ps3.

      Comment

      • Altimus
        Chelsea, Assemble!
        • Nov 2004
        • 27283

        #4
        Re: PS3 vs 360 version

        I have both systems and played both.

        360 version is the way to go. Cleaner graphics, has self shadowing (not a big deal but PS3 doesn't), and even though the 360 has some frame issues the PS3 is a disaster in this sometimes. Hitting on the PS3 because of this became an issue for me.

        Don't know what is going on with the poster above me but PS3 frame rate is worse. Every review even says so. Games are pretty identical except what I just described.

        Comment

        • kac
          Pro
          • Feb 2003
          • 530

          #5
          Re: PS3 vs 360 version

          Originally posted by PrimeTime23
          I have both systems and played both.

          360 version is the way to go. Cleaner graphics, has self shadowing (not a big deal but PS3 doesn't), and even though the 360 has some frame issues the PS3 is a disaster in this sometimes. Hitting on the PS3 because of this became an issue for me.

          Don't know what is going on with the poster above me but PS3 frame rate is worse. Every review even says so. Games are pretty identical except what I just described.
          Im sorry but I have stuttering in the 360 version that I dont have on the ps3 version and to me the ps3 version looks cleaner.In the 360 version I have stuttering when throwing the ball from the outfield in my ps3 version it is very smooth.

          Comment

          • findinghomer
            Pro
            • Mar 2007
            • 550

            #6
            Re: PS3 vs 360 version

            why would you buy the game for BOTH systems ? you sure your just not a fan boy? haha

            Comment

            • jtdribbles25
              Banned
              • Aug 2003
              • 1415

              #7
              Re: PS3 vs 360 version

              I have it for both systems as well. I prefer the 360 versions graphics but I have framerate issues with it. The ps3 version is smoother and I actually like the controller a little better, though it doesn't have rumble(yet) which sux for painting the corners sometimes. just my .02

              Comment

              • Glenn33
                MVP
                • Jul 2002
                • 2455

                #8
                Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                I have both systems. I own the 360 version but I rented the PS3 version to compare.

                The 360 is clearly rhe way to go. It looks much better (the self shadowing is huge - especially in day games). Also - I saw some jaggies in the pS3 version. i don't think stuttering is an issue in either version - except in cutscenes. And in that case - the PS3 was worse.

                Go with the 360 version.

                Comment

                • Instant C1a55ic
                  2022 Clark Cup Champions!
                  • Mar 2007
                  • 2959

                  #9
                  Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                  PS3 version is garbage, the piece of **** sutters along like that fat kid from billy madison. I even found myself yelling "ttt-today junior!" when the damn thing locked up for about 15 seconds after the outfielder caught the ball. The 360 version is much smoother and has a WAY better frame rate. The graphics look the same, but the lighting and distance viewing within the stadiums look more clear, and you can actually make out what the signs say in the distance, the ps3 is just blurry...i can see why the PS3 is the worst selling system as of now...what a hunk of junk.
                  NFL - Denver Broncos
                  NCAAF - Boise State Broncos
                  Champions Indoor Football - Sioux City Bandits 9-2
                  MLB - Toronto Blue Jays 56-45
                  NHL - Colorado Avalanche 2022 STANLEY CUP CHAMPIONS
                  United States Hockey League - Sioux City Musketeers
                  2022 Clark Cup Champions

                  Comment

                  • bisons18
                    Rookie
                    • Jan 2005
                    • 101

                    #10
                    Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                    Thanks for your help guys!

                    Comment

                    • brunnoce
                      MVP
                      • Mar 2005
                      • 4133

                      #11
                      Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                      Originally posted by alexbraun
                      I even found myself yelling "ttt-today junior!" when the damn thing locked up for about 15 seconds after the outfielder caught the ball.
                      lol!!
                      ---------------
                      PSN: brunnoce
                      Thanx Knight165

                      Comment

                      • kac
                        Pro
                        • Feb 2003
                        • 530

                        #12
                        Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                        Originally posted by findinghomer
                        why would you buy the game for BOTH systems ? you sure your just not a fan boy? haha
                        I bought it for the ps3 because my 360 broke down for the 6 time and I wanted to play a baseball game and im no fan boy there are games that look and play better on the 360 but I feel this is not one of them.The poster asked a question and I gave him my oppinion and you had a smart reply.

                        Comment

                        • ezevthokie9
                          Rookie
                          • Dec 2004
                          • 114

                          #13
                          Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                          Everyone else is putting opinions so I'll put mine too . I own a ps3 with this game and my roommate owns a 360 and this game. I can honestly say that we cannot tell a difference in this game. We're playing on a 42" plasma HDTV and they both look identical. I have not seen any types of stuttering frame rates (besides the occasional "loading" box) or anything of the sort. Besides, didn't 2kSports say these games are exactly the same in every aspect? Theres my 2 cents on it

                          Comment

                          • modog123
                            Rookie
                            • Mar 2004
                            • 145

                            #14
                            Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                            I own the 360 version and rented the PS3 version just to compare. I actually can't see much difference visually between the two, but I'm one who is having a lot better framerate results with the 360. I see a lot of stuttering in all screens, batting, fielding, and replays on the PS3 that I don't see on the 360. The worst I've seen is when I choose windy for the weather and the jerseys are rippling. It almost looks like a picture slide show. I'm using the HDMI output on the PS3, and viewing it in 720p.
                            "Boston's tenth man could not be wrong
                            Up from third base to Huntington
                            They'd sing another victory song"

                            Tessie - Dropkick Murphys

                            Comment

                            • BigL
                              Pro
                              • Sep 2005
                              • 612

                              #15
                              Re: PS3 vs 360 version

                              Originally posted by bisons18
                              Which one is better between the PS3 version and the 360 version? I played on 360 and it's pretty amazing, but I don't have a next-gen console and I'm looking to buy one.
                              Its the same game, dont let anybody tell you any different. I have it for the PS3 and my buddy has it for the 360. I just got back from playing it at his house and the graphics are the same. There is no difference and my friend plays it on an HDTV and I play it on the PS3 on a regular TV and Icould not tell the difference in the graphics. On HDTV you will notice more detail like rocks in the dirt and stuff like that, but im sure if you play teh PS3 one on an HDTV you'll see that too. Game play is the same too.

                              Comment

                              Working...