Should I get this game (for 360)?

[CFav]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

RENT IT! I did, brought it back and got my copy of another baseball game for the PC and DL'ed the 2007 MOD for it, and I am as happy as can be w/ it...

Oh and to be fair, I should add that I only play the game in franchise/GM modes. If you like to just play games and are not concerned the game lacking a good simulation in terms of franchise/GM play, then I would say it is worth IMO $40-$50...but I still wouldn't pay $60 for it. But again, this is just my opinion. Rent it and formulate your own.

[baa7]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

you should pick it up, period, just like BAA paid $60 for it!

No, I paid $10 actually. That's the only reason I bought it, because I rented it first and decided it wasn't worth purchasing.

[baa7]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

I don't have a problem with the game being HR happy. I never said it was real life baseball

Well, we certainly agree there, so I'm not sure what you're going on about here. That's exactly what I've been saying all along: the game is a HR fest that doesn't really represent the sport of MLB baseball. It's an arcade, flyball-happy, 'fun' video version, sure. And it sounds like you feel the same way.

[Jordanfan23]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

I believe you said it was so HR happy it was almost unplayable a few weeks ago, but you are still playing it, so it must have some good, yes?

And where did you rent it from, b/c you have had it for a month now?

Also, what baseball game does emulate what you watch at a real park, b/c I want a copy ASAP?

[Failure]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

I believe you said it was so HR happy it was almost unplayable a few weeks ago, but you are still playing it, so it must have some good, yes?

And where did you rent it from, b/c you have had it for a month now?

Also, what baseball game does emulate what you watch at a real park, b/c I want a copy ASAP?

MVP 05

[RoyalBoyle78]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

MVP 05

not 100%, MVP was great, but there still were issues.

[Failure]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

yeah but it was more of a sim than MLB 2k7 is...

the hitting system was awesome.

[jpup]

Re: Should I get this game (for 360)?

I've been reading lots of reviews and postings here and I'm still torn about getting this game. I don't usually play baseball too much but I just love College Hoops 2k7 and I'm sure 2k sports did a great job here too.

I love the demo but, like other baseball games of the past, will this game get old/boring quickly?

Also, do you have to play every single game in a season or can you have the computer sim some of them?

Thanks!!

if you don't like baseball, you shouldn't buy it. why would you buy a game of something that you don't like. It plays like baseball. If you like baseball, you will like it. It's a good game and when using correct sliders is one of the top 2 or 3 baseball game ever made as far as gameplay. It still has a ways to go, but it's much better than almost everything before it.