Manager Arguments.

[StevenSeagalsLipitor]

Will the Manager Arguments and animations be improved this year?

[Mjphillips]

Re: Manager Arguments.

Will the Manager Arguments and animations be improved this year?

Great question. I loved having the ability to get super pissed about a call and get kicked out in MVP 05. If they bring that back i will be really happy. I loved it when playing with friends to show my complete disapproval of the call made on the field. Just a little thing. And they shouldn't tell us when we can argue. WE KNOW WHEN A CALL IS GARBAGE!!!! Let us have the right to dispute any call we want inlcuding balls and strikes. I also want the right to charge the mound again. How cool was that? They never showed actual fighting so why take this feature out. It really is a game. If you can shoot and kill people in the shooter games and stuff why not have the look of a player charging the mound. i wouldn't want them to show the actual fight but at least show something realistic like MVP 05. Oh how I miss that game!!!!!!!.

Hahaha this post looks like I am talking to MVP 07 instead of MLB 2K7

[frat77]

Re: Manager Arguments.

The fights were a great feature. Guys got kicked out of the game and suspended if i'm not mistaken. They showed the benches clear and then would get tossed.

[ckarlic]

Re: Manager Arguments.

The fights were a great feature. Guys got kicked out of the game and suspended if i'm not mistaken. They showed the benches clear and then would get tossed.

Yeah i did bring this up in one of my postings (wishlist thread??) ..Was cool even though we didnt see any punches thrown. But at least it gave you the option to charge the mound and it was up to you wether or not you want to risk suspension or injury.

[born_bad]

Re: Manager Arguments.

I like that they tried to work this in to 2k7, but it was implemented poorly. One of my criticisms of 2k is that they tend to make some things very "videogamey" instead of realistic at time (tapping the button for jump balls in NBA, tapping the button for speed in NFL/APF). Having to tap a button quickly for manager arguments and ejections seemed lame to me.

Can you imagine if, instead, it was somehow done like the dialgoue branching system in Mass Effect. You could engage the ump or another player in a dialogue branch and then depending on your choices, you might get ejected, start a brawl. etc. That would seem a lot more realistic to me.

[ckarlic]

Re: Manager Arguments.

I like that they tried to work this in to 2k7, but it was implemented poorly. One of my criticisms of 2k is that they tend to make some things very "videogamey" instead of realistic at time (tapping the button for jump balls in NBA, tapping the button for speed in NFL/APF). Having to tap a button quickly for manager arguments and ejections seemed lame to me.

Can you imagine if, instead, it was somehow done like the dialgoue branching system in Mass Effect. You could engage the ump or another player in a dialogue branch and then depending on your choices, you might get ejected, start a brawl. etc. That would seem a lot more realistic to me.

Yeah the dialogue idea from Mass Effect would be awesome if they implemented it into 2k8.

[StevenSeagalsLipitor]

Re: Manager Arguments.

Id rather see better manager arguments than 90 minor league teams.

[beau21]

Re: Manager Arguments.

Id rather see better manager arguments than 90 minor league teams.

i dont know if i'd go THAT far but seeing the Mass Effect argument style implemented would be awesome