Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Bloodhound79
    Rookie
    • Jul 2005
    • 174

    #1

    Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

    I am a big into playing several years in franchise mode in any sports game that I get. That's just what I enjoy. I should state that I've never played any version of 2k or The Show. My past foray into the baseball video game market was MVP 2003, then 2005, then 2006 (all on the PS2). I recently purchased a PS3, and will be new to whichever game I buy (right now I'm leaning towards the Show).

    So, with that being said, which of the two games has the better franchise mode, in your opinion, and why? Oh, and I'm NOT talking about RTTS, just strictly Franchise/GM modes.
  • myghty
    MVP
    • Mar 2005
    • 2395

    #2
    Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

    Well if you like to manage prices on EVERYTHING go with the Show. There are countless things you have to manage in the Franchise mode. (Advertisments, Transportation, Maintenence, Prices of Food, Stadium Expansions, etc.)
    "In a year that has been so improbable, the impossible has happened." - Vin Scully

    PS5/PSN: myghty

    Comment

    • Benz87
      #OwnTheFuture
      • Jan 2005
      • 1320

      #3
      Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

      The Show has everything 2K8 will have and then some.
      Green Bay Packers | Milwaukee Bucks | Milwaukee Brewers

      Comment

      • Glenn33
        MVP
        • Jul 2002
        • 2455

        #4
        Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

        Originally posted by jkwon0709
        The Show has everything 2K8 will have and then some.
        Agreed. If franchise is the main deciding factor - go with The Show. The beauty of the show is you can do as little or as much as you want with regards to managing the team. You can have the CPU do as little or as much as you want with regards to managing your franchise.

        Comment

        • TwinsTerritory
          Rookie
          • Mar 2007
          • 439

          #5
          Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

          The bad things I've read about the Show that 2K does better:

          **The Show allows you to play just one game on any given day. AA, AAA or MLB. Not all three. I'm pretty sure (not 100%) that 2K8 will allow you to play all four.

          **2K gives the minor leaguers names and attributes that go with a real player The Show randomly generates them.

          These are just a few things that make a Franchise mode deeper. Not sure if they affect what you're looking for or not...

          Comment

          • Bloodhound79
            Rookie
            • Jul 2005
            • 174

            #6
            Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

            One negative on The Show, that I've read, is the lack of a full minor league system. Does 2K have full minor leagues?

            Comment

            • TwinsTerritory
              Rookie
              • Mar 2007
              • 439

              #7
              Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

              Yeah, the Show has just AA and AAA with random players. 2K offers A, AA, AAA with a lot of players that represent someone.

              That's my biggest thing about 2K I like better...

              Comment

              • boomhauertjs
                All Star
                • Feb 2004
                • 5373

                #8
                Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                Originally posted by TwinsTerritory
                **The Show allows you to play just one game on any given day. AA, AAA or MLB. Not all three. I'm pretty sure (not 100%) that 2K8 will allow you to play all four.
                In the podcast interview with Ben Brinkman, he said that you can play all 4 games in a day.

                Comment

                • TwinsTerritory
                  Rookie
                  • Mar 2007
                  • 439

                  #9
                  Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                  Okay, thought so...

                  That's somthing else that I like. I don't get why you'd put all of the minors in and then allow just one game per day.

                  I don't think I'll play all four everyday, but it'll be fun to have that choice.

                  Comment

                  • Bloodhound79
                    Rookie
                    • Jul 2005
                    • 174

                    #10
                    Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                    Originally posted by TwinsTerritory
                    Yeah, the Show has just AA and AAA with random players. 2K offers A, AA, AAA with a lot of players that represent someone.

                    That's my biggest thing about 2K I like better...
                    Ooooh, that is quite intriguing actually. Though, my favorite team who I'll be using for my Franchise, the Tigers, has pretty much depleted their minor league system to have the stacked major league roster that they have now. Maybe it'd be better to have an all fake minor league lineup

                    Comment

                    • Instant C1a55ic
                      2022 Clark Cup Champions!
                      • Mar 2007
                      • 2959

                      #11
                      Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                      Originally posted by Bloodhound79
                      Maybe it'd be better to have an all fake minor league lineup
                      I know this wont happen. I know for a fact that the roster makers will change what and who they can to have 100% accurate minor league line-ups. I wouldnt even worry unless you cant get them.
                      NFL - Denver Broncos
                      NCAAF - Boise State Broncos
                      Champions Indoor Football - Sioux City Bandits 9-2
                      MLB - Toronto Blue Jays 56-45
                      NHL - Colorado Avalanche 2022 STANLEY CUP CHAMPIONS
                      United States Hockey League - Sioux City Musketeers
                      2022 Clark Cup Champions

                      Comment

                      • Pigskin11
                        Rookie
                        • Sep 2007
                        • 185

                        #12
                        Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                        I am getting both games and was actually leaning towards doing my franchise on 2k8. First off I really dont care about adjusting prices of stuff, Id choose being able to play all my minors over that anyday. Also the GM mode in 2k is pretty sweet because you'll have various tasks like release a overpaid veteran or sign a hitter who batted over .300 last year. Plus add in the trading card feature and unless The show has something really cool I havent heard about im going with 2k. Ill run a RTTS on the show and give franchise at least a look since Ive never played the show before.

                        Comment

                        • bbking26
                          Rookie
                          • Jul 2004
                          • 494

                          #13
                          Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                          I also just do franchise

                          Will there be roster share like CHoops?
                          Brian Kelly will have ND back this year.

                          Arizona State will bounce back this year too.

                          The Cubs will end the streak next year

                          Comment

                          • Pigskin11
                            Rookie
                            • Sep 2007
                            • 185

                            #14
                            Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                            Originally posted by bbking26
                            I also just do franchise

                            Will there be roster share like CHoops?
                            No, 2kshare is not in mlb 2k8.

                            Comment

                            • bowlerguy92
                              MVP
                              • Feb 2005
                              • 1034

                              #15
                              Re: Frannchise Mode: 2k vs. The Show

                              I think The Shows franchise mode is PHENOMINAL. I love being able to prive everything and have complete control over really cool things.

                              Comment

                              Working...