Major League Baseball 2K8 360 Impressions

[chapmanosu1]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

XBOX 360

Only played two games.

Game does stutter some, but only during batter intros every once in awhile or after a throw in the field. DOES NOT KILL GAME. Never happened while swinging or pitching.

Graphics do seem somewhat bland. On par w/ last year's, possibly worse. Grass was the worst part IMO.

Did not use swing stick as I was playing with a friend and didn't want to fool with it.

The new pitching seems like it will be fun. Struggled with it though, but hadn't watch any tutorials.

Games were shootouts in the 16-17 per team range, but we were on pro and neither of us could pitch so a lot of pitches were meatballs. Loved fielding.

Feel free to PM with questions, I'll answer a few if I got an answer b/c I plan on cutting back on this particular forum until things calm down.

Seems like it will be a good game. Slightly better than last years.

[HK-47]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Man, I want to play this game so freakin' bad!!!!

I don't know when my repaired 360 will arrive.

I got The Show for the PS3 though!Man, the game would be perfect if they added swing stick and worked on signature batting stances and pitcher windups/delivers.K-Rod's is WAY off!Even Ryan Howards stance is wrong!THE FREAKIN' COVER BOY!!!


Anways, keep up the impressions!:wink:

[A.M. Son]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

I'm cracking guys, I'm really cracking.

I'm sick of this game. I've tried my hardest to like it, but there are just too many flaws. I can't believe 2K is the only option for 360 owners, thanks a lot Take Two.

This is the third year I've had to deal with a sub-bar baseball game. Not having a good baseball game to play is the only reason I regret owning a 360. I can't believe this. The game's overall presentation is so discombobulated. I don't understand why there has to be a dive "button" rather than using the right analog stick. Batting is just plain unfair--is it possible to hit a ground ball or to pull or push a ball without aiming?

Just like NHL2K8, MLB2K8 turned into a mess of ideas executed with no precision at all. I feel like I'm playing a work-in-progress. I can't believe we're paying 60 bucks for audio from 2005.

As baseball fans, we NEED EA to buyout Take-Two. Brinkman has not done enough. Either that or Blue Castle should take-over.

I'm really frustrated guys. I'm not a *****, I've just had enough of being screwed out of good game.

Couldn't agree more. I wish I didn't have the same sentiment, but this game just feels plain unfinished. I don't mind the trigger based dives, but on the whole I agree with all that you wrote.
The framerate problems with batter walkups and other moments just plain sap the life from this game, and the stuttery throwing of balls is just silly. I really wish I had a PS3 today... and that's the first time I've ever thought that...

[ehh]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

The pitching is cool but very boring IMO

Just curious, if 2K8's pitching is boring then how do you stay awake through The Show which still has the same meter for years or simply pressing a button and "let ratings do the work"?

[gamerk2]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

I am impressed. The new pitching mechanic works really well. Good hitters will crush mistakes, decent ones will hit line drives. Takes a good game to get used to, but works very well once you get used to it.

Pitches move more realistically, but still move to the plate quickly. If you are late on everything, try practiceing with pitch speed set to 40 instead of 50, it helps a bit at first.

The new throwing mechanic on the field works really well. Throw a high ball to Giambi and watch what happens. Bad fielders will get exposed this year.

Little things will get noticed as you play. If a go-ahead/tieing run crosses home, he might do a fist pump, for instance. I had Matsui hit a go-ahead 2-run HR in the 8th, and he promptly had a curtain call.

I already had a takeout slide knock a 2nd basemen sensless, and stop a few dp oppertunities.

To be sure, there are a few bugs. For instance, i once heard Morgan say "Rivera has only given up 40 HR balls dating back to the 2005 season." A lot of the commentary is recycled. Also, there is a stutter between batters/innings. Nothing game-breaking though.

Franchise is mostly the same, but with full minors, has an extra level of depth. The ability to track how players progress year by year is a nice touch too.

EDIT

A few other points: there are many more foul balls this year, which really shows off how far the hitting engine has progressd. In a sample of 5 games, i also had routhly an even split between groundballs, linedrives, and flyballs.

EDIT 2

Average score over my 5 sample games (on Pro difficulty for now) was 6-5; with one shootout (15-12 i believe) and a 1-0 game excluded.


I'd give the game an 8.0 for overall package, with commentary and presentation loweing the score. Based on gameplay alone, I'd give the game a solid 8.5. If you are willing to forgive the games faults, you will have a good time with it. If you don't, I can see why some people will call the game a refurbashed 2k7.

[tomahawk77]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

I played a game.

it is pretty much the same game as last year except they added quirky new pitching and fielding controls.

the graphics haven't been changed in 3 years.


hopefully it grows on me after some more games.

[HK-47]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Can anyone tell me if Angels second baseman Howie Kendrick has his signature batting stance?PLEASE!

[Oldschool17]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

IMO this is the worst looking and playing baseball game since the late 90's...The last game I remember being this bad was the old EA TRIPLE PLAY series.

Stuttering framerates on and offline...Choppy online play...Horrendous graphics, art and textures and just an overall unpleasant experience...A complete waste of $65.

Now there is no question why a demo and reviews did not come out...I hate to say it but this game took a HUGE STEP backwards...The 3 year plan just turned into a 10 year plan because there is no way this game is on the right track...Its a joke

IMO both the SHOW and MLB2k8 are huge disappointments...The Show is by far a better game but Online play for the Show is horrendous while everything about 2k8 is horrendous. If Sony fixes the online servers for the Show there is no question which game is light years the best game.

I personally wouldn't recommend anyone picking up MLB2k8...that is unless you prefer stuttering framerates, terrible graphics and choppy gameplay.

[Motown]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Just curious, if 2K8's pitching is boring then how do you stay awake through The Show which still has the same meter for years or simply pressing a button and "let ratings do the work"?

Dude, why do you CONTINUOUSLY bash The Show??? especially when you've NEVER PLAYED THE GAME...PAL...fanboys...good lord

[Fatalah]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

MLB2K8 makes me wonder what exactly they (Kush Games) spent 12 months working on. Honestly guys---does this game represent 12 months of work?

I'm upset because this costs us 60 bucks, and I'm not sure this game is worth it. I'm going to e-mail 2Ksports tomorrow.

NHL 07 to 08 shows clear progress. For people that bought MLB2K7, does anyone else feel scammed? If 2K8 achieved constant 60fps, I probably wouldn't be complaining. But this game is clunky in every department.

From the commentary, to crowd sound, to batting controls, definitely fielding control, to menus! I'm pissed, I'm sorry if I'm ripping into this game.

But we should be allowed to vent. This should not be a friendly message board to 2Ksports' baseball any longer. It's time we demand change. Don't look past the flaws.

[bowlerguy92]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Whoa! I have the dome open in Toronto!

[Cubbies2166]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Does anybody know if there are any downloadable stadiums yet?

Also can anybody tell me what Kosuke Fukudome's rating is, or at least the player that is supposed to be him?

[bigfnjoe96]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

I finally finished my 1st game. This title seems to be suffering from the same problem 2k6 had in reference to Choppiness & Studdering. If you really want to see it bad allow the game to replay @ the end & you'll see what I'm talking about.

I can't believe 2k allow this to happen AGAIN... This game is not caching correctly with the Hard Drives & this is why we are seeing the problems that we are seeing.

How do you not double check to make sure your game is caching correctly with the Hard Drives before you ship. I enjoyed getting my butt whoop due having to learn the NEW Total Control Analog Settings. I saw a lot of stuff that wasn't in 2k7, but this caching problem is really not cool..

[HK-47]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Dude, why do you CONTINUOUSLY bash The Show??? especially when you've NEVER PLAYED THE GAME...PAL...fanboys...good lord

The Show fan boys are the WORST.The 2k Foums prove that.They pretty much ruined the MLB section of those forums.They have a crazy hatred for 2k.

[ennepetal]

Re: Major League Baseball 2K8 (360/PS3) Impressions

Holy moly!

50 new pages since I checked this this a.m.! How am I meant to sift through all that?

Lots of complaining, though. Looks like two years in a row with no baseball game for me.

That makes me a little sad.