MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

[J_Posse]

Re: MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

How the hell is Josh Hamilton not a 96 or 97? He was the best player in the AL last season, won MVP and led his team to the World Series. He's the epitome of a 5-tool player and deserves a higher rating. His durability issues shouldn't lower his ratings that much, especially when guys with more questionable durability (Nelson Cruz and A-Rod) are in his range.

I like the rest of the Rangers ratings, in particular Cruz and Feliz, and it doesn't even include Mike Napoli. Rangers are going to be damn good even if they tweak the ratings a little.

[BlackBetty15]

Re: MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

I remember that throw but didn't know about those stats. Thanks!

Anytime time brother! It was by sheer luck I actually stayed up and watched it! I had just watched some good ol hot stove after work and was falling asleep to the top 50 OF/IF assist in major league history and saw some plays that literally took me back. It seemd like only yesterday that I saw ichiro embarass terrance long from RF on a zip line to third. It was in 2001 against the A's I think. The number one overall play was when jose guillen played for the pirates and bobbled a catch at the wall in RF, he picked up the ball and literall from the farthest part of RF, he gunned the crap out of homeplate on a rope to embarasas a runner. Number 3 was a bad to the bone as well...it was when ken caminiti sangged a rope at third, and from his butt he threw an absolute ROPE to first base. I mean this throw was harder than some pros do with their feet set. Amazing...Had some vintage ken griffey jr ropes and of course my all time fav roberto clemente ropes and assists. Wortht he time to watch as it will bring back some good memories of where you were and what you were doing when that play happened.

[jeffy777]

Re: MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

How the hell is Josh Hamilton not a 96 or 97? He was the best player in the AL last season, won MVP and led his team to the World Series. He's the epitome of a 5-tool player and deserves a higher rating. His durability issues shouldn't lower his ratings that much, especially when guys with more questionable durability (Nelson Cruz and A-Rod) are in his range.

I like the rest of the Rangers ratings, in particular Cruz and Feliz, and it doesn't even include Mike Napoli. Rangers are going to be damn good even if they tweak the ratings a little.

Agreed man. Hamilton should be higher.

[Scottdau]

Re: MLB 2K11 Player Ratings - Partial List (Pastapadre)

Don't they base this off the last three years?