gamepro review not so good at all

**Erratic** · 03-26-2004, 02:30 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

i think i am in the minority here but i only play bb games for the gameplay. I dont particpate in seasons, franchise's ect.

All i do, is play sinlge exibition games, vs. freinds/family and play online games.

So when i came down to MVP the only thing to bother me was how porley fielding was in the infield and how slow they all moved. None of this player progression or happyness stuff bothered me.

In MLB, the games just didn't seem very realistic or fun, but none of that 10 pitcher stuff bothered me.

I loved WSB last year, but i just hope that the infield is quick and smooth, the outfield doesn't all run like cecil fielder and the hitting animatinos are smooth.

I just want a baeball game where when i play exibition games, there aren't any basic flaws that ruin the game. But apparently i am asking for alot.

**wwharton** · 03-26-2004, 03:10 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

<blockquote>Quote:<hr />
pitchingcoach36 said:
After being jazzed up as hell for the new MVP (and not even renting because of the progression/roster bugs)...and renting MLB (It was ok, no offense at all tho,imo..and 10 pitchers only sucks)...I am still having more fun playing WSB. If they fixed the stealing problem (as it's been said they have) and the hitting's just a little improved...then I'm going to love this game. For me the biggest thing's the stealing

<hr /></blockquote>

I don't need an overhaul of WSB to be happy either but how can you even comment on MVP without playing it? I don't know why people do that. Search back to when ESPNFL came out and look at all the negative posts. Same with Madden if that was your football game of choice. Would it be fair to make a judgement on either without trying it out for yourself? Honestly if you don't want to try the game just b/c of what others say that's fine and your decision but you shouldn't really post opinions on it simply based on the opinions of others.

**wwharton** · 03-26-2004, 03:10 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

<blockquote>Quote:<hr />
pitchingcoach36 said:
After being jazzed up as hell for the new MVP (and not even renting because of the progression/roster bugs)...and renting MLB (It was ok, no offense at all tho,imo..and 10 pitchers only sucks)...I am still having more fun playing WSB. If they fixed the stealing problem (as it's been said they have) and the hitting's just a little improved...then I'm going to love this game. For me the biggest thing's the stealing

<hr /></blockquote>

I don't need an overhaul of WSB to be happy either but how can you even comment on MVP without playing it? I don't know why people do that. Search back to when ESPNFL came out and look at all the negative posts. Same with Madden if that was your football game of choice. Would it be fair to make a judgement on either without trying it out for yourself? Honestly if you don't want to try the game just b/c of what others say that's fine and your decision but you shouldn't really post opinions on it simply based on the opinions of others.

**wwharton** · 03-26-2004, 03:10 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

<blockquote>Quote:<hr />
pitchingcoach36 said:
After being jazzed up as hell for the new MVP (and not even renting because of the progression/roster bugs)...and renting MLB (It was ok, no offense at all tho,imo..and 10 pitchers only sucks)...I am still having more fun playing WSB. If they fixed the stealing problem (as it's been said they have) and the hitting's just a little improved...then I'm going to love this game. For me the biggest thing's the stealing

<hr /></blockquote>

I don't need an overhaul of WSB to be happy either but how can you even comment on MVP without playing it? I don't know why people do that. Search back to when ESPNFL came out and look at all the negative posts. Same with Madden if that was your football game of choice. Would it be fair to make a judgement on either without trying it out for yourself? Honestly if you don't want to try the game just b/c of what others say that's fine and your decision but you shouldn't really post opinions on it simply based on the opinions of others.

**ruiz00tx** · 03-26-2004, 04:45 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Just curious, what's the big gripe about games only allowing 10 pitchers on a roster. I think that is the norm. The most any team will ever carry is probably only 11, it's not like teams run around with 13 or 14 pitchers on the roster.

If your beef is you just want the option to carry more than 10 pitchers, I get that. If your beef is that 10 pitchers is unrealistic, then I don't.

I hope this game is good, otherwise I'm waiting til Gran Turismo or NCAA for my next purchase.

**ruiz00tx** · 03-26-2004, 04:45 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Just curious, what's the big gripe about games only allowing 10 pitchers on a roster. I think that is the norm. The most any team will ever carry is probably only 11, it's not like teams run around with 13 or 14 pitchers on the roster.

If your beef is you just want the option to carry more than 10 pitchers, I get that. If your beef is that 10 pitchers is unrealistic, then I don't.

I hope this game is good, otherwise I'm waiting til Gran Turismo or NCAA for my next purchase.

**ruiz00tx** · 03-26-2004, 04:45 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Just curious, what's the big gripe about games only allowing 10 pitchers on a roster. I think that is the norm. The most any team will ever carry is probably only 11, it's not like teams run around with 13 or 14 pitchers on the roster.

If your beef is you just want the option to carry more than 10 pitchers, I get that. If your beef is that 10 pitchers is unrealistic, then I don't.

I hope this game is good, otherwise I'm waiting til Gran Turismo or NCAA for my next purchase.

**GameDude** · 03-26-2004, 09:15 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Most National League teams carry 11 pitchers, and sometimes 12.

**GameDude** · 03-26-2004, 09:15 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Most National League teams carry 11 pitchers, and sometimes 12.

**GameDude** · 03-26-2004, 09:15 PM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

Most National League teams carry 11 pitchers, and sometimes 12.

**ruiz00tx** · 03-27-2004, 02:14 AM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

No team carries 12 pitchers, I guarantee it!

**ruiz00tx** · 03-27-2004, 02:14 AM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

No team carries 12 pitchers, I guarantee it!

**ruiz00tx** · 03-27-2004, 02:14 AM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

No team carries 12 pitchers, I guarantee it!

**GameDude** · 03-27-2004, 03:47 AM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

The Giants have from time to time. They're thinking about starting out with 12 to start this season. You can quote me on that.

**GameDude** · 03-27-2004, 03:47 AM

Re: gamepro review not so good at all

The Giants have from time to time. They're thinking about starting out with 12 to start this season. You can quote me on that.

gamepro review not so good at all

Recommended Videos

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment