My strikeout numbers will be on the low side too, but I don't feel like messing with my sliders now because once I change one thing I'll have to change another. You may want to lower the CPU swing frequency slider so they'll take more pitches, so they won't be constantly hitting the first or second pitch. That is the only thing I can think of right now that would help it.
I play on all star so I'm not sure if it's still there or not, but my controller vibrates when I'm touching the outside of the zone. Do you have xbox or ps2? I play on xbox, so maybe that's not on the ps2 version.
You are probably better than me since you said it's easy to hit on all star, so they may not be good for you but here they are. I based them off of a slider set I got about two years ago(forget who's, someone from mvpmods) and have tweaked them to my playing style.
GAMEPLAY OPTIONS(You don't have to use these, just posting them in case you wanted them)
Difficulty = All Star
Fielding = Manual
Batting View = Pitch 6/Bat 4
Fielding View = Zoom
Strike Zone = Off
Hot/Cold Zones = Off
Pitch Cursor = Off
Hitter's Eye = Off
Catch Circle Assist = On
Variable Strike Zone = On
Base Umpire Blown Calls = On
Fielding Aid = On
Vector Line = On
Throw Meter = On
Player Names = On
Player Icons = On
Auto Replay Frequency = Medium
Check Swing Frequency = Medium
Missed Swing Replays = On
Injuries = On
Suspensions = On
Errors = On
DH Rule = AL Only
Batter Overlay = Statistics
Pickoff Return = Automatic
Trade Deadline = On
CPU Initiated Trades = On
Fair Trades = On
Budgets = On
Financial Advisor= On
Rained Out Games = On
Energy Level Effect = On
Team Chemistry Effect = On
Variable "Stuff" = On
Cooperstown Effect = On
GAMEPLAY TUNING
User Pitch Meter Difficulty = -40
Pitch Speed = 0
CPU Pitcher Ball Rate = 21
User Pitcher Fatigue = 24
CPU Pitcher Fatigue = 18
User Pitch Control = -50
CPU Pitch Control = -7
Bullpen Fatigue Rate = 6
Bullpen Fatigue Grace = 12
User Batting Contract = 4
CPU Batting Contact = -1
User Batting Power = 5
CPU Batting Power = -9
User Bunting Ability = 15
CPU Bunting Ability = 15
User Foul Ball Frequency = 45
CPU Foul Ball Frequency = 45
CPU Swing Frequency = -20
User OF Speed (Manual) = -10
User OF Speed (MVP) = 0
CPU Outfielder Speed = -12
User INF Speed (Manual) = -5
User INF Speed (MVP) = 0
CPU Infielder Speed = -8
User Throw Speed = -5
CPU Throw Speed = -5
User Throw Accuracy = -15
CPU Throw Accuracy = -15
User Catch Errors = 10
CPU Catch Errors = 20
User Dive Difficulty = 10
CPU Catch Effort = -30
User Baserunning Speed = 5
CPU Baserunning Speed = 1
User Runner Aggression = 7
CPU Runner Aggression = 7
User Runner Steal Speed = 0
CPU Runner Steal Speed = -4
User Runner Steal Delay = -5
CPU Runner Steal Delay = -5
CPU Steal Rate = 14
Runner Injury Freq. = 5
Pitcher Injury Freq. = 5
Batter Injury Freq. = 0
Fielder Injury Freq. = 15
Pitching MG Difficulty = 0
They're not perfect, but they're good enough for me. I am probably going to be raising some of the injury sliders and probably raise the user power slider(because I haven't hit a HR with these yet) but the rest of it I'm pretty satisfied with.
Good luck with finding the right sliders, and don't be afraid to do some tweeking of your own(if you have time) because that's what got me to my set.
Comment