I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • donjn
    Rookie
    • Feb 2003
    • 288

    #1

    I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

    I have to say that All Star Baseball 2004 may fool you when you start it up. First off the menus and old time feel of everything looked great including menu music from "The Natural".

    However once I started playing thats when the bottom fell out from underneath me. Here are some of the things that make this game below par:

    1. On certain flyballs your player will appear to shoestring catch a routine flyball. And the ball actually looks like it hits the ground! This happens 2 or 3 times a game and looks terrible!

    2. When batters swing and miss their head does a 90 degree turn towards the opposite field like. It's a very weird animation and must be seen to be understood. It looks really bad.

    3. The players faces look great. Too bad the rest of the bodies have very narrow shoulders and just dont look right.

    4. On certain flyballs and ground balls the ball disappears and never quite goes into the glove of a player. On one instance on a flyball my player caught the ball and it must have been 4 feet to the left of him but then the ball disappeared into his mit. This again happens many times a game.

    5. There is little or no chance of turning any double plays. Even on routine grounders you can barely get anyone out.

    6. Even though I hate home run cameras in general I thought Id give this game a shot. Unfortunately home run camera happend during EVERY home run I saw. A total of 12 for 12. And to add insult to injury most balls are off the screen so all you see is the sky. Absolutely awful..

    7. Basically if you score a run, next inning the computer will too. Some sort of a comeback code in the following half inning alomst certainly exists..

    8. Way too many over the shoulder catches by SS and 2B players. I can just see it now. Jeter in the studio helping them with that annimation. Then the whole Acclaim team falls in love with it that it must happen 2 or 3 times a game.

    This is it for now. But these are very annoying things and I cant believe they were overlooked. MVP time..
  • JRod
    MVP
    • Jul 2002
    • 3266

    #2
    Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

    To be fair, I'm not a fan of ASB but I think your assessment is a little off.

    1) Graphical problem doesn't really hamper gamplay.

    2)Graphical

    3) Graphical

    4) Yet again graphical

    5) It's that future throw thing. You can turn it but have to be quick.

    6) Haven't hit a Homer yet

    7) Haven't seen it.

    8) Graphical but yes very annoying.


    I would say three of the thing you pointed out are legitimate gripes. But I will say that ASB doesn't do the best job of meshing animations and gameplay. Instead you are forced into a mo-cap and that affects gameplay.

    Comment

    • JRod
      MVP
      • Jul 2002
      • 3266

      #3
      Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

      To be fair, I'm not a fan of ASB but I think your assessment is a little off.

      1) Graphical problem doesn't really hamper gamplay.

      2)Graphical

      3) Graphical

      4) Yet again graphical

      5) It's that future throw thing. You can turn it but have to be quick.

      6) Haven't hit a Homer yet

      7) Haven't seen it.

      8) Graphical but yes very annoying.


      I would say three of the thing you pointed out are legitimate gripes. But I will say that ASB doesn't do the best job of meshing animations and gameplay. Instead you are forced into a mo-cap and that affects gameplay.

      Comment

      • LHayes37
        Banned
        • Jul 2002
        • 1311

        #4
        Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

        I still can't figure out why you got the game. You have almost a dozen posts refering to how you won't get the game, but you still went out and got it anyway, amazing. Stick to your guns man and for the love of God, don't come in here whining about it when you don't have enough self control. I would be rather embarrassed if I were you.

        Comment

        • LHayes37
          Banned
          • Jul 2002
          • 1311

          #5
          Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

          I still can't figure out why you got the game. You have almost a dozen posts refering to how you won't get the game, but you still went out and got it anyway, amazing. Stick to your guns man and for the love of God, don't come in here whining about it when you don't have enough self control. I would be rather embarrassed if I were you.

          Comment

          • donjn
            Rookie
            • Feb 2003
            • 288

            #6
            Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

            The reason why I tried it was because I was curious. Also the Gamestop store is one mile away from me and the guy told me I could get cash back on game returns within 7 days.

            Wait a minute. Why the F am I explaining this to you. I think you should be embrassed. After all whats worse?

            1.The guy who said he wasnt going to get it but changed his mind to try it for a day knowing he could easily get his money back and thought he would give All Star a shot?

            2. Or the idiot who rips him and spends the time searching and counting all my negative posts about it because he has nothing better to do?

            I thought so. Shut the F up

            Comment

            • donjn
              Rookie
              • Feb 2003
              • 288

              #7
              Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

              The reason why I tried it was because I was curious. Also the Gamestop store is one mile away from me and the guy told me I could get cash back on game returns within 7 days.

              Wait a minute. Why the F am I explaining this to you. I think you should be embrassed. After all whats worse?

              1.The guy who said he wasnt going to get it but changed his mind to try it for a day knowing he could easily get his money back and thought he would give All Star a shot?

              2. Or the idiot who rips him and spends the time searching and counting all my negative posts about it because he has nothing better to do?

              I thought so. Shut the F up

              Comment

              • donjn
                Rookie
                • Feb 2003
                • 288

                #8
                Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                And another thing Im not embrassed because people can change. Also I thought it was lame of me to critize a game before trying it so I thought I would give it a fair shot.

                There's nothing wrong with changing your mind and admitting that you were too harsh on a product without even trying it first.

                BUT BECAUSE

                1. I BOUGHT IT
                2. THIS IS AN OPEN FORUM
                3. AND A FREE COUNTRY

                I have my right to complain about the game so if you didnt read my post above:

                Shut the F up!

                Comment

                • donjn
                  Rookie
                  • Feb 2003
                  • 288

                  #9
                  Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                  And another thing Im not embrassed because people can change. Also I thought it was lame of me to critize a game before trying it so I thought I would give it a fair shot.

                  There's nothing wrong with changing your mind and admitting that you were too harsh on a product without even trying it first.

                  BUT BECAUSE

                  1. I BOUGHT IT
                  2. THIS IS AN OPEN FORUM
                  3. AND A FREE COUNTRY

                  I have my right to complain about the game so if you didnt read my post above:

                  Shut the F up!

                  Comment

                  • Jeff_Conine
                    Rookie
                    • Feb 2003
                    • 322

                    #10
                    Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                    </font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />

                    Wait a minute. Why the F am I explaining this to you. I think you should be embrassed. After all whats worse?

                    1.The guy who said he wasnt going to get it but changed his mind to try it for a day knowing he could easily get his money back and thought he would give All Star a shot?

                    2. Or the idiot who rips him and spends the time searching and counting all my negative posts about it because he has nothing better to do?


                    <hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

                    Can I vote for both being just as bad? And Donjin, is "Shut the F up" your catch phrase, kinda like Steve Urkel's "Did I do that"?
                    It's pretty much my favorite animal. It's like a lion and a tiger mixed... bred for its skills in magic.

                    Comment

                    • Jeff_Conine
                      Rookie
                      • Feb 2003
                      • 322

                      #11
                      Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                      </font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />

                      Wait a minute. Why the F am I explaining this to you. I think you should be embrassed. After all whats worse?

                      1.The guy who said he wasnt going to get it but changed his mind to try it for a day knowing he could easily get his money back and thought he would give All Star a shot?

                      2. Or the idiot who rips him and spends the time searching and counting all my negative posts about it because he has nothing better to do?


                      <hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

                      Can I vote for both being just as bad? And Donjin, is "Shut the F up" your catch phrase, kinda like Steve Urkel's "Did I do that"?
                      It's pretty much my favorite animal. It's like a lion and a tiger mixed... bred for its skills in magic.

                      Comment

                      • donjn
                        Rookie
                        • Feb 2003
                        • 288

                        #12
                        Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                        Yes but at least I admitted that me saying bad things about a game without owning it was a mistake. I owned up to it.

                        This guy however is a troll.

                        And by the "Shut the F up" is not my catch phrase. Its just that this guy REALLY pissed me off. I almost threw my mouse I was so pissed.

                        Deep breath....1....2..
                        Im okay

                        Comment

                        • donjn
                          Rookie
                          • Feb 2003
                          • 288

                          #13
                          Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                          Yes but at least I admitted that me saying bad things about a game without owning it was a mistake. I owned up to it.

                          This guy however is a troll.

                          And by the "Shut the F up" is not my catch phrase. Its just that this guy REALLY pissed me off. I almost threw my mouse I was so pissed.

                          Deep breath....1....2..
                          Im okay

                          Comment

                          • faster
                            MVP
                            • Dec 2002
                            • 2182

                            #14
                            Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                            hey dude, don't be a freakin ***. i find it strange too that you constantly rip a game and then went out and bought it. gee, who could have guesed you wouldn't have liked it?!

                            besides, just about everything you listed was graphics-related, and most aren't even huge deals. it's not like they are MAJOR and make the game unplayable. come one. to each his own.

                            and I can't believe ANYBODY would even look at MVP baseball positively. all the videos i've seen from the game make it still look VERY Triple Play-ish, which doesn't bode well for the game even being playable. the game has been horrible for 4 years running, what's to think this all-new incarnation will be any different?
                            "Well the NBA is in great hands but if I had to pick the single greatest player on the planet, I take Kobe Bryant without hesitation." - Michael Jordan, 2006

                            Comment

                            • faster
                              MVP
                              • Dec 2002
                              • 2182

                              #15
                              Re: I Broke Down and Bought it...ouch!

                              hey dude, don't be a freakin ***. i find it strange too that you constantly rip a game and then went out and bought it. gee, who could have guesed you wouldn't have liked it?!

                              besides, just about everything you listed was graphics-related, and most aren't even huge deals. it's not like they are MAJOR and make the game unplayable. come one. to each his own.

                              and I can't believe ANYBODY would even look at MVP baseball positively. all the videos i've seen from the game make it still look VERY Triple Play-ish, which doesn't bode well for the game even being playable. the game has been horrible for 4 years running, what's to think this all-new incarnation will be any different?
                              "Well the NBA is in great hands but if I had to pick the single greatest player on the planet, I take Kobe Bryant without hesitation." - Michael Jordan, 2006

                              Comment

                              Working...