Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

[stretch150]

First off, I already have ASB 2004 and was thinking about returning WSB for MVP. I like WSB, I don't like how all the players bodies look the same in WSB. I do have a couple of questions about MVP

1. When a homerun is hit, does the ball bouch off the score board or decks? I hear yes and no.
2. Does the career mode seem pretty good?
3. Are teh injuries in the game seem to happen pretty realistic?
4. How are the stadiums?
5. Do players look different?
6. What woud you rate the gameplay in MVP on a scale of 1 to 10 with one being the lowest.

Hopefully some of you guys will be able to take the time to answer the questions for me.. Thanks in advance.

[kumala]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

I think you should trade in asb for mvp and keep wsb. As for homeruns, they disappear in the stands although some other people have said that it does hit the facade and walls. I've only seen hit these things on foul balls. the franchise mode is good but not as in depth as wsb. As for gameplay, this game rocks. I would give a 9 for its creativity with the pitch and batting interface and it just plays well. As for the stadium graphics, I think the could have done a little better. Sometimes it seems a little blurry. But overall very good. It will be worth the purchase.

[kumala]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

I think you should trade in asb for mvp and keep wsb. As for homeruns, they disappear in the stands although some other people have said that it does hit the facade and walls. I've only seen hit these things on foul balls. the franchise mode is good but not as in depth as wsb. As for gameplay, this game rocks. I would give a 9 for its creativity with the pitch and batting interface and it just plays well. As for the stadium graphics, I think the could have done a little better. Sometimes it seems a little blurry. But overall very good. It will be worth the purchase.

[Running1st]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

1. When a homerun is hit, does the ball bouch off the score board or decks? I hear yes and no.
-Yes they hit some items (e.g at the BOB.. dead center field.)

2. Does the career mode seem pretty good?
-Some glitches with CPU pitching rotations.

3. Are teh injuries in the game seem to happen pretty realistic?
-I haven't experienced injuries. But I heard there are some.

4. How are the stadiums?
-One comment... not completely accurate. See my stadium inaccuracy post.

5. Do players look different?
-Oh yeah, they are chubby, skinny, tall, lanky, ect..

6. What woud you rate the gameplay in MVP on a scale of 1 to 10 with one being the lowest.
-Hands down pitcher interface is much better than WSB. You have complete control of how accurate your pitcher thows.

My recommendation is that if you plan on playing simulation (franchise) stick with WSB but if you don't care to much about simulation accuracy (picthing rotations or error tracking) go with MVP.

FunFactor:
WSB -8.5
MVP -9.2

[Running1st]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

1. When a homerun is hit, does the ball bouch off the score board or decks? I hear yes and no.
-Yes they hit some items (e.g at the BOB.. dead center field.)

2. Does the career mode seem pretty good?
-Some glitches with CPU pitching rotations.

3. Are teh injuries in the game seem to happen pretty realistic?
-I haven't experienced injuries. But I heard there are some.

4. How are the stadiums?
-One comment... not completely accurate. See my stadium inaccuracy post.

5. Do players look different?
-Oh yeah, they are chubby, skinny, tall, lanky, ect..

6. What woud you rate the gameplay in MVP on a scale of 1 to 10 with one being the lowest.
-Hands down pitcher interface is much better than WSB. You have complete control of how accurate your pitcher thows.

My recommendation is that if you plan on playing simulation (franchise) stick with WSB but if you don't care to much about simulation accuracy (picthing rotations or error tracking) go with MVP.

FunFactor:
WSB -8.5
MVP -9.2

[Skyboxer]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

MVP and WSBB are both keepers. They each offer totally different things IMO.

[Skyboxer]

Re: Thinking about returning WSB and getting MVP. Let me know why I should

MVP and WSBB are both keepers. They each offer totally different things IMO.