For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

[rog152]

if EA could only give us one of these two features next year,which would u prefer?

[Rodster]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

No, no, no, please EA NO sliders. Rog have you read the WSB forums? Trust me I had NHL2K3, I traded it in because after playing with the sliders and using slider settings from others the game never felt right. It just plain takes the fun out of the game. A player editor would make more sense cause it's already being used in NCAA Football and Madden I think.

On another thread someone made a great point, that sliders are an easy way for the developer to mask deficencies in a game. If a game is writen well and uses a good set of global sliders there shouldn't be a need for individual game sliders.
EA please NO game sliders. This game is real close to great, just a little tweaking is all it needs.

[Rodster]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

No, no, no, please EA NO sliders. Rog have you read the WSB forums? Trust me I had NHL2K3, I traded it in because after playing with the sliders and using slider settings from others the game never felt right. It just plain takes the fun out of the game. A player editor would make more sense cause it's already being used in NCAA Football and Madden I think.

On another thread someone made a great point, that sliders are an easy way for the developer to mask deficencies in a game. If a game is writen well and uses a good set of global sliders there shouldn't be a need for individual game sliders.
EA please NO game sliders. This game is real close to great, just a little tweaking is all it needs.

[FART_PANTS]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

i would rather they got rid of the "slider" pitch before they put in game sliders.

seriously.

[FART_PANTS]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

i would rather they got rid of the "slider" pitch before they put in game sliders.

seriously.

[Cincyez]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

Player editor. Madden has sliders but the game is just right on default.

[Cincyez]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

Player editor. Madden has sliders but the game is just right on default.

[MizzouRah]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

If they introduce sliders, you won't see MVP 2004 on my shelf. No sliders!

Player editor doesn't mean much to me, but could be good for some. I just want them to tighten the game up, more K's, more endurance, etc.. fix a few of the animations, and oddities... then it's almost perfect.

Todd

[MizzouRah]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

If they introduce sliders, you won't see MVP 2004 on my shelf. No sliders!

Player editor doesn't mean much to me, but could be good for some. I just want them to tighten the game up, more K's, more endurance, etc.. fix a few of the animations, and oddities... then it's almost perfect.

Todd

[JayBee74]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

Player editor. Now you have me thinking of NCAA 2004-I can't wait for that game. I'm sure EA will have one for this game next year.

[JayBee74]

Re: For next year-Sliders or player editor-which one more important?

Player editor. Now you have me thinking of NCAA 2004-I can't wait for that game. I'm sure EA will have one for this game next year.