Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • code_red
    Rookie
    • Mar 2003
    • 1

    #1

    Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

    Mvp or Wsb...which is better sim?
  • PInck33
    Rookie
    • Aug 2002
    • 225

    #2
    Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

    not trying to be an *** but why dont you rent both and found out for yourself. Only you can tell what game think is more realistic

    Comment

    • PInck33
      Rookie
      • Aug 2002
      • 225

      #3
      Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

      not trying to be an *** but why dont you rent both and found out for yourself. Only you can tell what game think is more realistic

      Comment

      • MizzouRah
        All Star
        • Jul 2002
        • 8547

        #4
        Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

        For a sim, I would say go with High Heat.


        Todd

        Comment

        • MizzouRah
          All Star
          • Jul 2002
          • 8547

          #5
          Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

          For a sim, I would say go with High Heat.


          Todd

          Comment

          • osmagic
            Rookie
            • Mar 2003
            • 7

            #6
            Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

            i bought MVP and rented WSB in case i needed to take back MVP and get WSB ... i'm not very impressed with the gameplay in WSB. the pitching stinks, it's too easy to hit and the players and movement look very choppy for as detailed as the graphics are. all the players basically look the same. and the body images aren't very realistic. i'm going with MVP all the way here.

            I do have to say that WSB's franchise mode is VERY fun. i rented it yesterday and sat and played like 20-some seasons from 12:00 to like 7:00 with the cubs and FINALLY won a world series in the year 2025!! ... so, for all you cubs fans, you'll have to wait that long for another title!! but that's pretty much it with WSB, the rest stinks ... YEAH EA SPORTS!!!

            Comment

            • osmagic
              Rookie
              • Mar 2003
              • 7

              #7
              Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

              i bought MVP and rented WSB in case i needed to take back MVP and get WSB ... i'm not very impressed with the gameplay in WSB. the pitching stinks, it's too easy to hit and the players and movement look very choppy for as detailed as the graphics are. all the players basically look the same. and the body images aren't very realistic. i'm going with MVP all the way here.

              I do have to say that WSB's franchise mode is VERY fun. i rented it yesterday and sat and played like 20-some seasons from 12:00 to like 7:00 with the cubs and FINALLY won a world series in the year 2025!! ... so, for all you cubs fans, you'll have to wait that long for another title!! but that's pretty much it with WSB, the rest stinks ... YEAH EA SPORTS!!!

              Comment

              • yakimiiis
                Rookie
                • Mar 2003
                • 104

                #8
                Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                I should have done the same as osmagic, but instead I jumped the gun and returned MVP for WSB. WSB was for sale on eBay within two hours.

                I agree with everything else said, though -- MVP has some annoying quirks, but I can't sit through any other baseball game after having played it. WSB is choppy, floaty, boring, and a whole lot of other unflattering adjectives in comparison.

                Y

                Comment

                • yakimiiis
                  Rookie
                  • Mar 2003
                  • 104

                  #9
                  Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                  I should have done the same as osmagic, but instead I jumped the gun and returned MVP for WSB. WSB was for sale on eBay within two hours.

                  I agree with everything else said, though -- MVP has some annoying quirks, but I can't sit through any other baseball game after having played it. WSB is choppy, floaty, boring, and a whole lot of other unflattering adjectives in comparison.

                  Y

                  Comment

                  • jgo777
                    #55
                    • Feb 2003
                    • 623

                    #10
                    Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                    It probably depends what you're looking for and what you mean by "sim". I have both and so far I've been less than impressed with WSB's gameplay. It's a real pretty game and the franchise mode is deep, but I just don't have much fun actually playing the games. If I never played MVP I'm sure I would have been real happy with WSB, but MVP kind of ruined WSB for me.
                    XBL: Tanc

                    Comment

                    • jgo777
                      #55
                      • Feb 2003
                      • 623

                      #11
                      Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                      It probably depends what you're looking for and what you mean by "sim". I have both and so far I've been less than impressed with WSB's gameplay. It's a real pretty game and the franchise mode is deep, but I just don't have much fun actually playing the games. If I never played MVP I'm sure I would have been real happy with WSB, but MVP kind of ruined WSB for me.
                      XBL: Tanc

                      Comment

                      • wizdom
                        Rookie
                        • Mar 2003
                        • 120

                        #12
                        Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                        wsb aint no sim. imo too many hits,k's, and homeruns but they do have a loot of little extra's

                        Comment

                        • wizdom
                          Rookie
                          • Mar 2003
                          • 120

                          #13
                          Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                          wsb aint no sim. imo too many hits,k's, and homeruns but they do have a loot of little extra's

                          Comment

                          • LIGHTNING
                            MVP
                            • Jul 2002
                            • 1610

                            #14
                            Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                            MVP is NOT a simulation and anyone who thinks it is does not know baseball. It is a game for CASUAL baseball fans who are more interested in FUN than realism. There are way too many hits, too many hits are line drives, too few strikeouts, and CPU batting is not realistic. It is just too easy to hit in MVP compared to the other baseball games, especially ASB 2004. None of the baseball games are a true simulation of baseball, but HH 2004 is the closest.

                            Comment

                            • LIGHTNING
                              MVP
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 1610

                              #15
                              Re: Mvp or Wsb.... Which is a better sim?

                              MVP is NOT a simulation and anyone who thinks it is does not know baseball. It is a game for CASUAL baseball fans who are more interested in FUN than realism. There are way too many hits, too many hits are line drives, too few strikeouts, and CPU batting is not realistic. It is just too easy to hit in MVP compared to the other baseball games, especially ASB 2004. None of the baseball games are a true simulation of baseball, but HH 2004 is the closest.

                              Comment

                              Working...