XBN Reviews All baseball games

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • fossen
    Bl*bfl*th z*p!
    • Jul 2002
    • 7098

    #31
    Re: XBN Reviews All baseball games

    </font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
    They probably had the same guy as last time, Jeff Pearlman (I think that's his name) of Sports Illustrated. ASB is very tough to jump into, and if you're a big shot writer with More Important things to do, you're not going to fiddle with options trying to find something that suits you. You're going to write the game off as terrible without a second thought. It's really frustrating to get a bad review because the reviewer is ignorant. I think ASB suffers from this problem more than anyone because their default options are just way too hard and a lot of the things that make the game good aren't readily apparent.

    <hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
    FatPitcher, you're a pretty classy guy.

    Pearlman did do the reviews. In general, I think XBN has the best reviews of any of the magazines, and I can understand the thinking in getting an guest writer with sports credentials in. But Pearlman is a stone cold idiot.

    The MVP review in XBN has been posted at Gamers.com. And it qualifies as one of the worst reviews I've ever seen: MVP Baseball 2003

    I would quote it, but it's awsome majesty can only be comprehended with a full read.

    Comment

    • **DONOTDELETE**
      Hall Of Fame
      • Oct 2025
      • 19598

      #32
      Re: XBN Reviews All baseball games

      I think Game Informer got most of the baseball games pretty right this year...at least from my opinion, they seem very close to what I would have scored them except MVP would be about an 8.0 for me....its equal to ASB in value. More fun but less realistic.

      Comment

      • **DONOTDELETE**
        Hall Of Fame
        • Oct 2025
        • 19598

        #33
        Re: XBN Reviews All baseball games

        I think Game Informer got most of the baseball games pretty right this year...at least from my opinion, they seem very close to what I would have scored them except MVP would be about an 8.0 for me....its equal to ASB in value. More fun but less realistic.

        Comment

        Working...