THE POLL....

[3rdAnswer]

Re: THE POLL....

ASB = Realistic Gameplay, tons of options, alot of things to unlock, you can customize the game to any difficulties in-between = Perfect Game

ASB = Perfect Game

[3rdAnswer]

Re: THE POLL....

ASB = Realistic Gameplay, tons of options, alot of things to unlock, you can customize the game to any difficulties in-between = Perfect Game

ASB = Perfect Game

[EChavez]

Re: THE POLL....

WSB is my fav - I just like the gameplay and franchise mode the best and it is a very nice looking game as well

[EChavez]

Re: THE POLL....

WSB is my fav - I just like the gameplay and franchise mode the best and it is a very nice looking game as well

[Skyboxer]

Re: THE POLL....

I've played MVP,WSBB and ASBB. I have HH but have not opened yet.
For me it's MVP. Fun factor through the roof....

[Skyboxer]

Re: THE POLL....

I've played MVP,WSBB and ASBB. I have HH but have not opened yet.
For me it's MVP. Fun factor through the roof....

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: THE POLL....

MVP would have been my choice if it werent for the Triple Playish fielding....everything else is realistic. I would even overlook the very thin and gimmicky franchise mode with no minor league system and it's quirky AI is also a bit questionable

ASB is just too real to deny fif your a big baseball fan

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: THE POLL....

MVP would have been my choice if it werent for the Triple Playish fielding....everything else is realistic. I would even overlook the very thin and gimmicky franchise mode with no minor league system and it's quirky AI is also a bit questionable

ASB is just too real to deny fif your a big baseball fan

[Skyboxer]

Re: THE POLL....

Triple playish fielding? The fielding in MVP is not even close to that....there could have been more animation/types of fielding but to say it is Triple Playish is overboard...At least the players are not all "squating" 95% of the time.

Also I am a huge BB fan and ASBB is far from a great game. Vacuum catches,bland boring graphics and sound. IMO It's almost like watching paint dry. ASBB is the only game I could not bare to play anymore. I own all but that game.

[Skyboxer]

Re: THE POLL....

Triple playish fielding? The fielding in MVP is not even close to that....there could have been more animation/types of fielding but to say it is Triple Playish is overboard...At least the players are not all "squating" 95% of the time.

Also I am a huge BB fan and ASBB is far from a great game. Vacuum catches,bland boring graphics and sound. IMO It's almost like watching paint dry. ASBB is the only game I could not bare to play anymore. I own all but that game.

[bryan_05]

Re: THE POLL....

Now it is down to WSB, HH, and MVP

No way am I getting ASB, that game has let me down every year since the 1st year for N64. Thats the only one I liked.

[bryan_05]

Re: THE POLL....

Now it is down to WSB, HH, and MVP

No way am I getting ASB, that game has let me down every year since the 1st year for N64. Thats the only one I liked.

[Quint75]

Re: THE POLL....

Overall so far:
-MVP is the most pure fun.
-ASB and WSB are the best looking, with MVP not far behind.
-HH has the best ball physics and overall game play, though all do this pretty well.
-MVP has the best batter/pitcher interface (by far!), followed by WSB, ASB and HH.
-HH is the most realistic as far as results go but they really need to do a bit more to the pitching interface, IMO.
-HH and ASB have the best/most features and depth, with WSB close behind.

I purchased all 4 and am playing each one. So far MVP has me coming back the most, though all 4 are very strong titles. ASB needs a bit more tweaking (it is still just a bit too hard to score from second on most singles and a wild throw on a stolen base is immediately scooped up by the OF'er with no chance to advance the runner) but it is light years beyond last years game. I need more playing time with all of them, HH especially, before I issure a final verdict. But even the game that comes in 4th place will still be one helluva video baseball game. What a glorious year for baseball games!!!

[Quint75]

Re: THE POLL....

Overall so far:
-MVP is the most pure fun.
-ASB and WSB are the best looking, with MVP not far behind.
-HH has the best ball physics and overall game play, though all do this pretty well.
-MVP has the best batter/pitcher interface (by far!), followed by WSB, ASB and HH.
-HH is the most realistic as far as results go but they really need to do a bit more to the pitching interface, IMO.
-HH and ASB have the best/most features and depth, with WSB close behind.

I purchased all 4 and am playing each one. So far MVP has me coming back the most, though all 4 are very strong titles. ASB needs a bit more tweaking (it is still just a bit too hard to score from second on most singles and a wild throw on a stolen base is immediately scooped up by the OF'er with no chance to advance the runner) but it is light years beyond last years game. I need more playing time with all of them, HH especially, before I issure a final verdict. But even the game that comes in 4th place will still be one helluva video baseball game. What a glorious year for baseball games!!!

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: THE POLL....

HH has the worst ball physics out of the 4 games...ASB and MVP have the best

WSB and ASB have the best franchise mode and depth

HH has the most realistic results and stats and correct gameplay

MVP has the best batting / pitching engine

WSB has the most colorful graphics but some odd animations at times

HH has the worst interface,

WSB has the best sliders for configuring gameplay followd by HH

ASB has the most realistic GM and salary and trading rules

HH has good fielding control

ASB has difficult batting

MVP has fun franchise mode

MVP has oddball AI

MVP has the best baserunning and HH is a close second