which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

[geraldparr]

for those of you who have already played most of this year's crop of baseball games, i was just wondering which game forces you and allows you to use strategy the most....i have always been a fan of realistic/sim style sports games rather than arcade style....any answers to this question would be appreciated!!

[SpartyGreen]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

I've played everything except MLB, and I would say ASB. The reason is that the players in the game really perform like their real-life counterparts, meaning that decisions made by the user are of utmost importance.

[SpartyGreen]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

I've played everything except MLB, and I would say ASB. The reason is that the players in the game really perform like their real-life counterparts, meaning that decisions made by the user are of utmost importance.

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

ASB.....and maybe HH, MVP not so much. Its all about execution. WSB, i dont know enough.

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

ASB.....and maybe HH, MVP not so much. Its all about execution. WSB, i dont know enough.

[fsquid]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

OOTP5, I've used more double switches and defensive subs in that game than I can think of.

[fsquid]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

OOTP5, I've used more double switches and defensive subs in that game than I can think of.

[SpartyGreen]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
OOTP5, I've used more double switches and defensive subs in that game than I can think of.

<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Agreed. Sorry, I was only going by console games.

[SpartyGreen]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
OOTP5, I've used more double switches and defensive subs in that game than I can think of.

<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
Agreed. Sorry, I was only going by console games.

[jasongst]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
I've played everything except MLB, and I would say ASB. The reason is that the players in the game really perform like their real-life counterparts, meaning that decisions made by the user are of utmost importance.

<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

Are you trying to say that it adds strategy by making it important to account for the different players' abilities? Your statement got me all confused. That would make sense though: you want a game to make you take into account the speed of the runners when you are thinking of stealing or doing a hit &amp; run, and you should have to consider the players' fielding ability when you decide your lineup and field position during an inning, etc.

[jasongst]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
I've played everything except MLB, and I would say ASB. The reason is that the players in the game really perform like their real-life counterparts, meaning that decisions made by the user are of utmost importance.

<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">

Are you trying to say that it adds strategy by making it important to account for the different players' abilities? Your statement got me all confused. That would make sense though: you want a game to make you take into account the speed of the runners when you are thinking of stealing or doing a hit &amp; run, and you should have to consider the players' fielding ability when you decide your lineup and field position during an inning, etc.

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

thats exactly what he's saying ....and if not, thats what im saying. ASB forces you to do this

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

thats exactly what he's saying ....and if not, thats what im saying. ASB forces you to do this

[Skyboxer]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

The best pitcher/batter strategy goes to MVP IMO. That might change after I play HH but compared to ASBB and WSBB it isn't even close.

[Skyboxer]

Re: which game forces you to use strategy the most (simulation style) ??

The best pitcher/batter strategy goes to MVP IMO. That might change after I play HH but compared to ASBB and WSBB it isn't even close.