I know its early, but I got bored and want to run with this.
Now, going by current vote totals in calculating the starters
American League
C Joe Mauer - Twins
1B Justin Morneau - Twins
2B Robinson Cano - Yankees
3B Evan Longoria - Rays
SS Derek Jeter - Yankees
OF Ichiro - Mariners
OF Josh Hamilton - Rangers
OF Carl Crawford - Rays
DH Vladimir Guerrero - Rangers
BACKUPS
C - Victor Martinez - Red Sox
1B - Miguel Cabrera - Tigers
1B - Paul Konerko - White Sox
2B - Ty Wigginton - Orioles
SS - Elvis Andrus - Rangers
3B - Adrian Beltre - Red Sox
3B - Michael Young - Rangers
OF - Magglio Ordonez - Tigers
OF - Shin Soo-Choo - Indians
OF - Alex Rios - White Sox
OF - Brett Gardner - Yankees
Pitchers
Cliff Lee - Mariners
David Price - Rays
Clay Bucholz - Red Sox
Ricky Romero - Blue Jays
Jered Weaver - Angels
Andrew Bailey - Athletics
Andy Pettitte - Yankees
Jon Lester - Red Sox
Neftali Felix - Rangers
Rafael Soriano - Rays
Jose Valverde - Tigers
Mariano Rivera - Yankees
Joakim Soria - Royals
# Represented each team:
Baltimore Orioles - 1
Boston Red Sox - 4
Chicago White Sox - 2
Cleveland Indians - 1
Detroit Tigers - 3
Kansas City Royals - 1
Los Angeles Angels -1
Minnesota Twins - 2
New York Yankees - 5
Oakland Athletics - 1
Seattle Mariners - 2
Tampa Bay Rays - 4
Texas Rangers - 5
Toronto Blue Jays - 1
National League
C Yadier Molina - Cardinals
1B Albert Pujols - Cardinals
2B Chase Utley - Phillies
3B Placido Polanco - Phillies
SS Hanley Ramirez - Marlins
OF Jason Heyward - Braves
OF Ryan Braun - Brewers
OF Andre Ethier - Dodgers
BACKUPS
C - Miguel Olivo - Rockies
1B - Adrian Gonzalez - Padres
1B - Ryan Howard - Phillies
1B - Joey Votto - Reds
2B - Martin Prado - Braves
2B - Brandon Phillips - Reds
3B - Ryan Zimmerman - Nationals
3B - David Wright - Mets
3B - Scott Rolen - Reds
OF - Andrew McCutchen - Pirates
OF - Chris Young - Diamondbacks
OF - Corey Hart - Brewers
OF - Jayson Werth - Phillies
Pitchers
Ubaldo Jimenez - Rockies
Josh Johnson - Marlins
Adam Wainwright - Cardinals
Roy Halladay - Phillies
Roy Oswalt - Astros
Brian Wilson - Giants
Heath Bell - Padres
Jonathan Broxton - Dodgers
Billy Wagner - Braves
Carlos Marmol - Cubs
Chris Carpenter - Cardinals
Tim Lincecum - Giants
# Represented each team:
Arizona Diamondbacks - 1
Atlanta Braves - 3
Chicago Cubs - 1
Cincinnati Reds - 3
Colorado Rockies - 2
Florida Marlins - 2
Houston Astros - 1
Los Angeles Dodgers - 2
Milwaukee Brewers - 2
New York Mets - 1
Philadelphia Phillies - 5
Pittsburgh Pirates - 1
San Diego Padres - 2
San Francisco Giants - 2
St. Louis Cardinals - 4
Washington Nationals - 1
I think I got every team, and rosters of 33. Whew, that took some time
So go ahead, rip my team apart and ask me why I took so and so over so and so.
Now, going by current vote totals in calculating the starters
American League
C Joe Mauer - Twins
1B Justin Morneau - Twins
2B Robinson Cano - Yankees
3B Evan Longoria - Rays
SS Derek Jeter - Yankees
OF Ichiro - Mariners
OF Josh Hamilton - Rangers
OF Carl Crawford - Rays
DH Vladimir Guerrero - Rangers
BACKUPS
C - Victor Martinez - Red Sox
1B - Miguel Cabrera - Tigers
1B - Paul Konerko - White Sox
2B - Ty Wigginton - Orioles
SS - Elvis Andrus - Rangers
3B - Adrian Beltre - Red Sox
3B - Michael Young - Rangers
OF - Magglio Ordonez - Tigers
OF - Shin Soo-Choo - Indians
OF - Alex Rios - White Sox
OF - Brett Gardner - Yankees
Pitchers
Cliff Lee - Mariners
David Price - Rays
Clay Bucholz - Red Sox
Ricky Romero - Blue Jays
Jered Weaver - Angels
Andrew Bailey - Athletics
Andy Pettitte - Yankees
Jon Lester - Red Sox
Neftali Felix - Rangers
Rafael Soriano - Rays
Jose Valverde - Tigers
Mariano Rivera - Yankees
Joakim Soria - Royals
# Represented each team:
Baltimore Orioles - 1
Boston Red Sox - 4
Chicago White Sox - 2
Cleveland Indians - 1
Detroit Tigers - 3
Kansas City Royals - 1
Los Angeles Angels -1
Minnesota Twins - 2
New York Yankees - 5
Oakland Athletics - 1
Seattle Mariners - 2
Tampa Bay Rays - 4
Texas Rangers - 5
Toronto Blue Jays - 1
National League
C Yadier Molina - Cardinals
1B Albert Pujols - Cardinals
2B Chase Utley - Phillies
3B Placido Polanco - Phillies
SS Hanley Ramirez - Marlins
OF Jason Heyward - Braves
OF Ryan Braun - Brewers
OF Andre Ethier - Dodgers
BACKUPS
C - Miguel Olivo - Rockies
1B - Adrian Gonzalez - Padres
1B - Ryan Howard - Phillies
1B - Joey Votto - Reds
2B - Martin Prado - Braves
2B - Brandon Phillips - Reds
3B - Ryan Zimmerman - Nationals
3B - David Wright - Mets
3B - Scott Rolen - Reds
OF - Andrew McCutchen - Pirates
OF - Chris Young - Diamondbacks
OF - Corey Hart - Brewers
OF - Jayson Werth - Phillies
Pitchers
Ubaldo Jimenez - Rockies
Josh Johnson - Marlins
Adam Wainwright - Cardinals
Roy Halladay - Phillies
Roy Oswalt - Astros
Brian Wilson - Giants
Heath Bell - Padres
Jonathan Broxton - Dodgers
Billy Wagner - Braves
Carlos Marmol - Cubs
Chris Carpenter - Cardinals
Tim Lincecum - Giants
# Represented each team:
Arizona Diamondbacks - 1
Atlanta Braves - 3
Chicago Cubs - 1
Cincinnati Reds - 3
Colorado Rockies - 2
Florida Marlins - 2
Houston Astros - 1
Los Angeles Dodgers - 2
Milwaukee Brewers - 2
New York Mets - 1
Philadelphia Phillies - 5
Pittsburgh Pirates - 1
San Diego Padres - 2
San Francisco Giants - 2
St. Louis Cardinals - 4
Washington Nationals - 1
I think I got every team, and rosters of 33. Whew, that took some time
So go ahead, rip my team apart and ask me why I took so and so over so and so.