Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TravisG_06
    Banned
    • Aug 2010
    • 88

    #1

    Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

    What's your opinion. I say absolutely not.

    *EDIT* Sorry, forgot to include the article that sparked this debate.



    And this is the counter-argument

    Last edited by TravisG_06; 10-20-2010, 12:22 PM.
  • rsox
    All Star
    • Feb 2003
    • 6309

    #2
    Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

    Other than the fact that both had drinking problems what is there to compare?.

    We have not seen enough of Hamilton to really compare him to anyone.

    Comment

    • snepp
      We'll waste him too.
      • Apr 2003
      • 10007

      #3
      Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

      No.



      /thread
      Member of The OS Baseball Rocket Scientists Association

      Comment

      • ghm125
        john14:6
        • Jul 2002
        • 2439

        #4
        Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

        love Josh Hamilton....not even close,as far as his off field issues read his book its awesome....hes come a long way...but no MM...
        VIOLATION!!!!!!!!

        Comment

        • 55
          Banned
          • Mar 2006
          • 20857

          #5
          Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

          Originally posted by snepp
          No.



          /thread
          This x 1000...

          Comment

          • baseball66
            Banned
            • Mar 2009
            • 1505

            #6
            Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

            Originally posted by rsox
            Other than the fact that both had drinking problems what is there to compare?.

            We have not seen enough of Hamilton to really compare him to anyone.
            Lol, good one.

            Comment

            • st0rmb11
              All Star
              • Nov 2008
              • 5167

              #7
              Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

              What brought this comparison up?

              Cincinnati Reds

              UNC Tarheels

              Twitter: @st0rmb11

              PS4

              Comment

              • Speedy
                #Ace
                • Apr 2008
                • 16143

                #8
                Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                Originally posted by st0rmb11
                What brought this comparison up?
                I'm curious as to the answer of this as well. I see nothing comparable between Mantle and Hamilton other than the position they both play(ed).
                Originally posted by Gibson88
                Anyone who asked for an ETA is not being Master of their Domain.
                It's hard though...especially when I got my neighbor playing their franchise across the street...maybe I will occupy myself with Glamore Magazine.

                Comment

                • lilbiggio
                  MVP
                  • Jun 2004
                  • 2105

                  #9
                  Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                  Who starts a debate and then doesn't take the affirmative.


                  *Thread Fail.

                  Comment

                  • TravisG_06
                    Banned
                    • Aug 2010
                    • 88

                    #10
                    Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                    This article is what has sparked the debate

                    Comment

                    • TravisG_06
                      Banned
                      • Aug 2010
                      • 88

                      #11
                      Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                      Counter argument

                      Comment

                      • Gibbz
                        All Star
                        • Aug 2005
                        • 8240

                        #12
                        Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                        Originally posted by TravisG_06
                        Verducci's article might've been over the top, but this one is downright insulting to Hamilton.

                        Comment

                        • ZB9
                          Hall Of Fame
                          • Nov 2004
                          • 18387

                          #13
                          Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                          I dont know about any Mickey comparisons. That is not really fair

                          but I do know that Hamilton's 4 HRs so far in this series against NY is the most ever against the Yankees in an ALCS, (and the Yanks have been in A LOT of ALCSs)....
                          Last edited by ZB9; 10-20-2010, 12:56 PM.

                          Comment

                          • lilbiggio
                            MVP
                            • Jun 2004
                            • 2105

                            #14
                            Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                            Alright now that we got somethings to go off of now (and those articles were crazy on both sides), I have to agree with you there's no way you can compare Hamilton to Mickey Mantle. That's going a little far right now..

                            While Hamilton and Mantle are both 5 tool players that roam the outfield, there are lots of players through the history of the game that have done that. The fact which makes Mantle standout over all of them is that he could get the job done from both sides of the plate, and for what it's worth Josh Hamilton can only get it done on the left.


                            The only guy in the current day MLB that's even close to being in the same breath of Mickey Mantle, is an extremely healthy Carlos Beltran, and I'm only saying him because he plays a good outfield too. There are plenty of situational switch hitters who probably strike fear in people a lot more than Beltran did this past year.

                            Comment

                            • ZB9
                              Hall Of Fame
                              • Nov 2004
                              • 18387

                              #15
                              Re: Can Josh Hamilton and Mickey Mantle be compared to one another?

                              I would compare Hamilton moreso to Roy Hobbs than to the Mick

                              Comment

                              Working...