Instant Replay?
Collapse
Recommended Videos
Collapse
X
-
Re: Instant Replay?
Originally posted by ChewingthehardfactsNew England Patriots(12-2)
NY Jets (9-4) [COLOR=blue] Giants Stadium: East Rutherford, NJ 1:00 PM EST -
Re: Instant Replay?
Originally posted by ChewingthehardfactsI think the only time they should you it for calling ball fair or foul ball on home run calls.New England Patriots(12-2)
NY Jets (9-4) [COLOR=blue] Giants Stadium: East Rutherford, NJ 1:00 PM ESTComment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
I agree with everyone in saying baseball shouldn't implement instant replay.
In a game like the NFL it makes sense because each official is assigned certain areas of the field and certain penalties to watch for. There are a lot of situations where only 1 official has a clear view of what is happening.
In baseball however the play is usually seen by all 4 umpires. Now that they are willing to conference they have been very consistent in getting the calls right, as evidenced in the ALCS.Comment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
I agree with everyone in saying baseball shouldn't implement instant replay.
In a game like the NFL it makes sense because each official is assigned certain areas of the field and certain penalties to watch for. There are a lot of situations where only 1 official has a clear view of what is happening.
In baseball however the play is usually seen by all 4 umpires. Now that they are willing to conference they have been very consistent in getting the calls right, as evidenced in the ALCS.Comment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
Instant Replay is dead......for now
The GMs couldn't come up with a consensus so it's going to be on the backburner for now.
I don't really think MLB needs it. There's really not many situations where it's needed. I would like some kind of a computer thing where you can get an accurate strike zone.Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club
"Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. ParkerComment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
Instant Replay is dead......for now
The GMs couldn't come up with a consensus so it's going to be on the backburner for now.
I don't really think MLB needs it. There's really not many situations where it's needed. I would like some kind of a computer thing where you can get an accurate strike zone.Member of the Official OS Bills Backers Club
"Baseball is the most important thing that doesn't matter at all" - Robert B. ParkerComment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
Originally posted by dieselboyAnother reason for me to watch only 2-3 full regular season games.New England Patriots(12-2)
NY Jets (9-4) [COLOR=blue] Giants Stadium: East Rutherford, NJ 1:00 PM ESTComment
-
Re: Instant Replay?
Originally posted by dieselboyAnother reason for me to watch only 2-3 full regular season games.New England Patriots(12-2)
NY Jets (9-4) [COLOR=blue] Giants Stadium: East Rutherford, NJ 1:00 PM ESTComment
Comment