All Dodgers team

[spyder23]

Didn't see one of these, so here goes:

1b-Hodges (tough call over Garvey)
2b-Robinson
ss-Reese
3b-Cey (Cox was a great gloveman here in the late 0s and 50s)
c-Campanella
of-Wheat
of-Snider
of-Furillo


Starters

Koufax
Vance
Newcombe
Drysdale
Valenzuela
Hershiser

[Mr. Bee]

Re: All Dodgers team

Keeler over Furillo

Burleigh Grimes needs to start as a pitcher, Don Sutton needs to be there but on the bench.

Wills should be on the team, as a backup.

Other than that looks good

[Mr. Bee]

Re: All Dodgers team

Keeler over Furillo

Burleigh Grimes needs to start as a pitcher, Don Sutton needs to be there but on the bench.

Wills should be on the team, as a backup.

Other than that looks good

[spyder23]

Re: All Dodgers team

I don't think Keeler is first team material. That wasn't even the same game back then. He was with the Dodgers before the turn of the century.

I had Grimes down but where am I gonna stick him? I already have six starters lol.

[spyder23]

Re: All Dodgers team

I don't think Keeler is first team material. That wasn't even the same game back then. He was with the Dodgers before the turn of the century.

I had Grimes down but where am I gonna stick him? I already have six starters lol.

[Mr. Bee]

Re: All Dodgers team

I don't think Keeler is first team material. That wasn't even the same game back then. He was with the Dodgers before the turn of the century.

I had Grimes down but where am I gonna stick him? I already have six starters lol.

About Keeler, I know, I'm just the voice of support for 19th century and deadball players. I'm facinated about the innovations and adaptive playing style of those players. I think if you took Keeler and put him in the present day he would have enough baseball talent and ability to be one of the all-time greats, considering that he was going off nothing but pure innate talent, like most of the greats from that era. But I definately think that he's first team material - CERTAINLY over Furillo.

(Also, he never technically played for the Dodgers. Go Superbas!)

Grimes would start over every pitcher there except Koufax and Drysdale

Rotation should be

Koufax
Drysdale
Grimes
Vance
Newcombe

[Mr. Bee]

Re: All Dodgers team

I don't think Keeler is first team material. That wasn't even the same game back then. He was with the Dodgers before the turn of the century.

I had Grimes down but where am I gonna stick him? I already have six starters lol.

About Keeler, I know, I'm just the voice of support for 19th century and deadball players. I'm facinated about the innovations and adaptive playing style of those players. I think if you took Keeler and put him in the present day he would have enough baseball talent and ability to be one of the all-time greats, considering that he was going off nothing but pure innate talent, like most of the greats from that era. But I definately think that he's first team material - CERTAINLY over Furillo.

(Also, he never technically played for the Dodgers. Go Superbas!)

Grimes would start over every pitcher there except Koufax and Drysdale

Rotation should be

Koufax
Drysdale
Grimes
Vance
Newcombe