NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert 71

[J_Posse]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

If people really want individual ratings to be the deciding factor then it shouldn't be just a 99 only for the goat.. It's hypocritical for everyone to want one thing and then complain because of the result.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The only way LBJ doesn't earn a 99 (again, which he won't) is because he didn't play the same level of defense of the previous two seasons. He should definitely still be the best player in the game and league, but I think they may have knocked down his defensive ratings - and maybe defensive awareness too - which hurt his overall rating. His last few 99 overall ratings were very well deserved, IMO.

from Spurs Nation/Bills Backer HQ using Tapatalk

[KingTocco]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

I was gonna like your post, but Noah?! Love Noah's game, but no way should be in the 90's.

How can you not have Noah in the 90s?

He literally carried his entire team the whole year, was a candidate for MVP too. He's a great defender, tenacious rebounder, and he was a great facilitator on offense too.

Not high 90s but I think he definitely deserves a 90-91 rating.

[J_Posse]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

How can you not have Noah in the 90s?

He literally carried his entire team the whole year, was a candidate for MVP too. Meaning he's a super role-player and nothing more.

He's a great defender, tenacious rebounder, and he was a great facilitator on offense too.

Not high 90s but I think he definitely deserves a 90-91 rating.

No, he's a better passing version of Ben Wallace type player. He is nowhere near a top tier, elite level player such as LeBron, Kevin Durant and Chris Paul.

from Spurs Nation/Bills Backer HQ using Tapatalk

[thedream2k13]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

How can you not have Noah in the 90s?

He literally carried his entire team the whole year, was a candidate for MVP too. He's a great defender, tenacious rebounder, and he was a great facilitator on offense too.

Not high 90s but I think he definitely deserves a 90-91 rating.

What those stats looking like ?? Those decide rating

[ojandpizza]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

The only way LBJ doesn't earn a 99 (again, which he won't) is because he didn't play the same level of defense of the previous two seasons. He should definitely still be the best player in the game and league, but I think they may have knocked down his defensive ratings - and maybe defensive awareness too - which hurt his overall rating. His last few 99 overall ratings were very well deserved, IMO.

from Spurs Nation/Bills Backer HQ using Tapatalk

I agree with this completely, if the rating system hadn't changed and everyone else took a big jump then I wouldn't have said anything.. Just seems odd that other players overalls are higher, almost to the point that they are too high with this new system, yet LeBron is going down. Not like it really matters one way or the other though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[cmac2k13]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

How can you not have Noah in the 90s?

He literally carried his entire team the whole year, was a candidate for MVP too. He's a great defender, tenacious rebounder, and he was a great facilitator on offense too.

Not high 90s but I think he definitely deserves a 90-91 rating.

He was an 80 last year. No shot in hell does he jump 10 points nor does he deserve to.

[KingTocco]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

This is just my opinion but I feel like he is definitely an elite top-tier player. Defensive ratings should factor in more too, defense seems to get forgotten about a lot. I'd like to see some defensive gameplay improvements and videos instead posterizing dunks everywhere.

Melo is a pretty questionable defender and yet he made it into the 90s.

I'm not sure how you can say Noah is a better passing version of Ben Wallace...Ben Wallace was literally all defense and no offense at all. Noah is much better offensively

[KingTocco]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Rating - Kendall Marshall (Overall 74) Shane Larkin (Overall 72)

I don't really want to side track this thread with Noah debate, everyone has their own opinions. Also, his rating of 80 last year was way too low IMO.

[cmac2k13]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

I get the fact that Noah carried a huge load once D-Rose went down and arguably carried that team in the Playoffs, but if you think Noah is a top 10 talent in the league you are flat out wrong. Easily a top player at his position, but there aren't many great 5's in the L these days. Noah's a fantastic rebounder, a good shot blocker, but he's not as good offensively as you're giving him credit for. He didn't even shoot 50% from the field last season.

I'm actually a big fan of Noah and have picked him for my fantasy squad the last 3 seasons, but if I'm making the ratings I'm not putting him over 83-84.

[redsox4evur]

Alright so Andrew Wiggins and Jabari are going to rated in the low 80s going to be pissed when this happens.

[KingTocco]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

Alright so Andrew Wiggins and Jabari are going to rated in the low 80s going to be pissed when this happens.

Jabari is the highest rated rookie at 78

[darkknightrises]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

So we now 4 players are going to be in the 90's and KD is 1 have we heard who else yet? We know james of course will be but then who are the other 2 going to be. I am going to say kevin love and CP3. I wonder with kobe only playing like 10 games last year what is rating will be?

[KingTocco]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

So we now 4 players are going to be in the 90's and KD is 1 have we heard who else yet? We know james of course will be but then who are the other 2 going to be. I am going to say kevin love and CP3. I wonder with kobe only playing like 10 games last year what is rating will be?

Kobe should be like an 85 at best.

[turty11]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

the issue i have is this.

it appears the majority of NBA players will be rated as 75-85's

what you are then telling me is that overall speaking, these rookies, and more than half the league are all the same kind of all around talent.

i dont know if the issue is the overall system...still, or 2k rosters..still

[darkknightrises]

Re: NBA 2K15 Player Ratings - Embiid 77, Marshall 74, McLemore 74, Larkin 72, Gobert

Kobe should be like an 85 at best.

Yeah I could see that. He is older and coming off a bad injure so you don't know how he is going to bonce back. I am wored that he wont be the same has no one has really came back form that injure he has at his age and been the same but at the same time I think that after the first like 6 games he played last season before he got hurt he started to show some sings of being able to maybe play at a high level again in games like 7-10 but then got hurt again. I just wonder how do you really go about rating guys when they are coming back form big injures same thing with rose yes he is a lot younger then kobe but he has only played like 10 games in 2 years. Same thing with rookies has they are unproven.