Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

[AIRJ23]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Seconding this. Hopefully for next year's game.

Screw defensive three-seconds.

Imagine if a hockey goalie occasionally had to leave his net wide open. That's this rule.

Exactly. It’s a terrible rule intended to coddle players into appearing better than they actually are (e.g, score easily without much true brute opposition). Far as I’m concerned, if you haven’t been tested via having to drive into a key clogged by big men waiting to pounce you, you haven’t been tested. Rules intended to keep the paint wide open is just soft on top of soft.

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Well I think you can blame the Knicks Heat 90s battles for all these rules that favor the offense. They played some ugly games lol. Final scores like 77-70. I didn’t have a problem with it, they were both so great defensively.

[Boogee134]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

I always put high schoolers in the draft.

And as someone said, since I do 29 games/season, I change the playoffs seeding rule for 1 to 16 regarding of the conference. However, I was wondering how does it affect the play-in tournament ?

[TarHeelPhenom]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Exactly. It’s a terrible rule intended to coddle players into appearing better than they actually are (e.g, score easily without much true brute opposition). Far as I’m concerned, if you haven’t been tested via having to drive into a key clogged by big men waiting to pounce you, you haven’t been tested. Rules intended to keep the paint wide open is just soft on top of soft.

I agree with you simply because I'm form the 80's/90's era. But, the question is...which centers in the current NBA would actually put somebody on the seat of their pants? I can't count many. There are very few "enforcer" types in todays game. But, I agree...they should add the elimination of the defensive 3 seconds as an option.

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

I always put high schoolers in the draft.

And as someone said, since I do 29 games/season, I change the playoffs seeding rule for 1 to 16 regarding of the conference. However, I was wondering how does it affect the play-in tournament ?

I can’t help with that lol. I turn the play in off, I hate everything about it. But I’m old school so I don’t like these changes.

[Luke Skywalker]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

* Change shot clock back to 24 following a rebound.

* Bring back Rookies vs Sophomores

* All Star game top vot getters

* Change the trade rule so you can do something like the 2013-14 Nets when they aquired KG/Pierce.

thats all really. i got into basketball back in 2010, so i try to reinstate the rules from back then.

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

* Change shot clock back to 24 following a rebound.

* Bring back Rookies vs Sophomores

* All Star game top vot getters

* Change the trade rule so you can do something like the 2013-14 Nets when they aquired KG/Pierce.

thats all really. i got into basketball back in 2010, so i try to reinstate the rules from back then.

Yea, I even move teams back where they were when I started watching(80s) or where they were when they started play. Nets back to Jersey, Washington becomes the Bullets(surprised the game even lets me do this) again, Hornets become Pittsburgh Condors, Pelicans return to be the Charlotte Hornets, Grizzlies back to Vancouver, Clippers move to San Diego. Thunder back to Seattle SuperSonics, and I make my own expansion Tampa Geckos.

[Levistick]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Wait you can rename and relocate teams with the customize league option??

[xCoachDx]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

In regards to the shot clock change - how much did it affect your final scores ?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Haven’t tried it this year, but in years past, simulated scores would drop SIGNIFICANTLY when raising the shot clock.

[Cold Snap]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

As for rules I do make happen in this game:

The lottery tournament. It's not perfect, but I like it more than the system we have now. And I still like it more than the "draft wheel" idea, which should also be an option for those that DO like it.

Eliminating the backcourt violation. I don't support this in real life--I only eliminate this rule due to seeing too much of this call made on passes between players on or near the halfcourt stripe. Again, I don't want it in reality, but for this game, it ends an annoyance.

Eliminating the 5-second back-to-the-basket violation. That rule makes about as much sense as making the team lose the ball because the point guard held onto it at the arc too long. I think they actually HAVE a rule like that in college ball. And we already have the perfect solution for pace-of-play--it's called the shot clock.

Elam/fixed-score ending. As an oldhead, I LOVE this idea. It's brilliant. We experimented with it in the All-Star Game, and it killed two birds with one stone: no more end-game stalling, and no more late-game fouling to artificially extend the game. You play until YOU win. Every point brings us closer to finality...that being said, I would like another option regarding this, as I'll state below.

Full 24 seconds off offensive rebounds. Changing that rule was a solution in search of a problem. Before the 14-second rule, less than 10% of offensive rebounds resulted in possessions that took longer than 14 seconds. Pointless.

Change eight-second violation back to ten. As explained by another, this is due to the play-calling menu. I'm fine with the rule in reality, though honestly I don't know why the real league so needed to get those extra two seconds...

Eliminate the play-in tournament. Over half the teams (16/30) already make the playoffs, and you want to add MORE? Needless overcomplication.

One-and-one for the first five team fouls, two shots after ten. If you can't make free throws, that's YOUR problem.

Euroleague goaltending. Once it hits the rim, it's a free ball. The current "offensive interference" rule was put in place because of Wilt Chamberlain, and it was an overreaction even then.

Eliminate the Stepien Rule. If GMs want to be idiots, let them. You can't legislate intelligence.

High-schoolers can enter the draft. Duh.

Rules that need to become options in future 2Ks:

Draft wheel. As stated above, I understand the drawbacks involved, especially when a college player decides "eh, I don't want to play for that team--but look who's got the top pick NEXT year!" But I'll understand if the league eventually does something like this, since tanking teams will have brought it on themselves--thanks a LOT, Sam Hinkie.

Elam ending ONLY for regular-season games. Playoffs and Finals will continue to have overtimes. I understand that players don't want to play two or three overtimes to conclude one out of 82 games. But in the playoffs, tickets are that much more expensive, and fans will feel they got their money's worth with occasional free basketball.

Eliminate defensive three-seconds. See prior post. I also want to bring hand-checking back, but that's not possible in this game engine, plus 2K started in 1999, the year the league ended it, so I understand this one.

And finally, my pipe-dream rule change option:

Eliminate the three-pointer. Probably not possible, given how court graphic files are stored in memory--the arc is likely hard-coded into the graphic and can't be removed. But about 40% of all shots taken are now three-pointers, and it's INCREASING. In fact, it's BEEN increasing every single year since they moved it back to 23'9" in 1997. 40% of all shots, and more taken every year (extrapolated for 82 games) for 24 years? THAT IS NOT SUSTAINABLE.
Besides, remember that Nuggets-Wizards ending?

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

As for rules I do make happen in this game:

The lottery tournament. It's not perfect, but I like it more than the system we have now. And I still like it more than the "draft wheel" idea, which should also be an option for those that DO like it.

Eliminating the backcourt violation. I don't support this in real life--I only eliminate this rule due to seeing too much of this call made on passes between players on or near the halfcourt stripe. Again, I don't want it in reality, but for this game, it ends an annoyance.

Eliminating the 5-second back-to-the-basket violation. That rule makes about as much sense as making the team lose the ball because the point guard held onto it at the arc too long. I think they actually HAVE a rule like that in college ball. And we already have the perfect solution for pace-of-play--it's called the shot clock.

Elam/fixed-score ending. As an oldhead, I LOVE this idea. It's brilliant. We experimented with it in the All-Star Game, and it killed two birds with one stone: no more end-game stalling, and no more late-game fouling to artificially extend the game. You play until YOU win. Every point brings us closer to finality...that being said, I would like another option regarding this, as I'll state below.

Full 24 seconds off offensive rebounds. Changing that rule was a solution in search of a problem. Before the 14-second rule, less than 10% of offensive rebounds resulted in possessions that took longer than 14 seconds. Pointless.

Change eight-second violation back to ten. As explained by another, this is due to the play-calling menu. I'm fine with the rule in reality, though honestly I don't know why the real league so needed to get those extra two seconds...

Eliminate the play-in tournament. Over half the teams (16/30) already make the playoffs, and you want to add MORE? Needless overcomplication.

One-and-one for the first five team fouls, two shots after ten. If you can't make free throws, that's YOUR problem.

Euroleague goaltending. Once it hits the rim, it's a free ball. The current "offensive interference" rule was put in place because of Wilt Chamberlain, and it was an overreaction even then.

Eliminate the Stepien Rule. If GMs want to be idiots, let them. You can't legislate intelligence.

High-schoolers can enter the draft. Duh.

Rules that need to become options in future 2Ks:

Draft wheel. As stated above, I understand the drawbacks involved, especially when a college player decides "eh, I don't want to play for that team--but look who's got the top pick NEXT year!" But I'll understand if the league eventually does something like this, since tanking teams will have brought it on themselves--thanks a LOT, Sam Hinkie.

Elam ending ONLY for regular-season games. Playoffs and Finals will continue to have overtimes. I understand that players don't want to play two or three overtimes to conclude one out of 82 games. But in the playoffs, tickets are that much more expensive, and fans will feel they got their money's worth with occasional free basketball.

Eliminate defensive three-seconds. See prior post. I also want to bring hand-checking back, but that's not possible in this game engine, plus 2K started in 1999, the year the league ended it, so I understand this one.

And finally, my pipe-dream rule change option:

Eliminate the three-pointer. Probably not possible, given how court graphic files are stored in memory--the arc is likely hard-coded into the graphic and can't be removed. But about 40% of all shots taken are now three-pointers, and it's INCREASING. In fact, it's BEEN increasing every single year since they moved it back to 23'9" in 1997. 40% of all shots, and more taken every year (extrapolated for 82 games) for 24 years? THAT IS NOT SUSTAINABLE.
Besides, remember that Nuggets-Wizards ending?

I actually like the backcourt violations because it adds some non steal turnovers, which is badly needed.

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Wait you can rename and relocate teams with the customize league option??

Yes. Inside your MyNBA you can take control of any team and rebrand/relocate. Consoles have a limit where you have to enable online saves after three rebrands/relocates, probably because of memory. Once servers shut down you lose your MyNBA save. This is why I like PC version(I know it's not next gen yet), there's no limit on PCs.

[AIRJ23]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Yes. Inside your MyNBA you can take control of any team and rebrand/relocate. Consoles have a limit where you have to enable online saves after three rebrands/relocates, probably because of memory. Once servers shut down you lose your MyNBA save. This is why I like PC version(I know it's not next gen yet), there's no limit on PCs.

If you change up to 3 teams though, the file is saved locally which means you should be able to access that MyNBA save after servers shut down, correct?

[AIRJ23]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

Oh yeah! Eliminating the 5 setting back to the basket rule is a must. Another dumb rule that’s changed the game for the worse to me. Bringing back hand checking would be amazing. Probably wouldn’t change how the AI interacts since they can code them to stick to you and anticipate what you’re about to do as hand checking allows in real life, but it would be a great visual and is another rule stupidly removed to coddle players into scoring easily and not feeling the effects of truly physical ball.

[NYJin2011tm]

Re: Does Anyone Ever Change Any Rules In Their MyNBA Franchises

If you change up to 3 teams though, the file is saved locally which means you should be able to access that MyNBA save after servers shut down, correct?

Yes you can do three before online save would be needed.