The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Badgers]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Playing association mode as the Bulls, I did this trade

Bulls receive : Joe Johnson, Etan Thomas
Hawks receive : Carlos Boozer, Keith Bogans

Not sure if its one the Hawks would actually do, the lineups are now;

Bulls :

Derrick Rose
Joe Johnson
Luol Deng
Taj Gibson
Joakim Noah

Hawks :

Kirk Hinrich
Jamal Crawford
Josh Smith
Carlos Boozer
Al Horford


Not too sure how effective Smith would be moving back to the 3

[Kemba1Walker]

Thanks for all of the feed back guys. I really could not decide if Patty Mills' trade value was high enough to not throw in another pick. He is definitely raw potential on the game.

I am messing around with an OKC association too. I decided to play a new angle with this one and start Maynor at the PG position and bump Westbrook to the SG. I am also looking to run with a really small rotation so that I can use each player effectively.

Here is the trade..

I receive: 2011 1st round Pacers, Dahntay Jones, Lance Stephenson

I trade: Thabo Sef.., Cole Aldrich, Dequaun Cooke, and B. Mullens( shipped the last 2 off to get them off the roster haha)

I almost didnt go with the 1st rounder. The thing is that it will probably end up about middle of the pack as the Pacers are rated highly. Aldrich gives them another young big behind Hibbert, and Thabo will jump over Rush, and atleast be a solid role player.

What do you guys think?

Depends on if Pacers make playoffs or not. If its a lottery pick or if pacers get 7th/8th seed, go ahead and do it. If pacers are going to be 1-6th seed, they should add something else.

[bobcats55]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Here is an interesting 3 team trade,

Bobcats trade: DJ Augistine
Bobcats receive: Eric Maynor, Cole Aldrich, '12 1st round Thunder

Rockets Trade: Hasheem Thabeet, '11 1st round Rockets
Rockets Receive: Thabo Sef.

OKC Trade: Thabo Sef. Cole Aldrich, Eric Maynor, 12 1st round Thunder
OKC Receives: Hasheem Thabeet, DJ Augistine, '11 1st round Rockets


What do you guys think about the realism of this trade?

The Bobcats will be looking to move DJ with the addition of Kemba. Gaining Aldrich and a future pick will be a solid deal.

The Rockets gain an excellent defender who will give great minutes.

OKC recieves a solid PG so that Westbrook can be bumped to the SG slot. They also gain a solid Center prospect to develop. Basicly a tiny step backwards from Aldrich.

What are you guys thoughts?

[Raider131]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Couple of trades

Suns get:Beabouis, Dominque Jones, Brendan Haywood 2012 first round pick
Mavs get: Steve Nash, 2012 second round pick

Jazz get: Landry Fields, Chauncey Billups, Shawne Williams
Knicks get: Devin Harris, Ak-47 2012 2nd rounder

Bulls(me): Damion James
Nets: Keith Bogans 2012 1st rounder

Lastly doubt im actually going to do this but
Bulls:2013 2nd round pick (Magic)
Cavs Dwight Howard
Magic:Hickson,Kay(75/C), Jamison 2012 1st round, 2012 first round, 2013 first rounder, 2012 2nd rounder

[Badgers]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Here is an interesting 3 team trade,

Bobcats trade: DJ Augistine
Bobcats receive: Eric Maynor, Cole Aldrich, '12 1st round Thunder

Rockets Trade: Hasheem Thabeet, '11 1st round Rockets
Rockets Receive: Thabo Sef.

OKC Trade: Thabo Sef. Cole Aldrich, Eric Maynor, 12 1st round Thunder
OKC Receives: Hasheem Thabeet, DJ Augistine, '11 1st round Rockets


What do you guys think about the realism of this trade?

The Bobcats will be looking to move DJ with the addition of Kemba. Gaining Aldrich and a future pick will be a solid deal.

The Rockets gain an excellent defender who will give great minutes.

OKC recieves a solid PG so that Westbrook can be bumped to the SG slot. They also gain a solid Center prospect to develop. Basicly a tiny step backwards from Aldrich.

What are you guys thoughts?

I think the issue with this is that the Rockets are giving up what will most probably be a lottery pick for Sefolosha, who wouldn't even be a starter since they have Kevin Martin

[MagicSuns]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Who says no to this trade?

WIZARDS GET: Dwight Howard, Gilbert Arenas
MAGIC GET: John Wall, JaVale McGee, Rashard Lewis, 1st Round Pick

Its essentially Howard for Wall, McGee & 1st Round Pick. Arenas and Lewis get flipped back for each other for money reasons and Orlando would have 3 PG's to 0 for Washington plus Dwight and Gil are friends.

Does Orlando get too much, not enough or is it just right?

[Rhyster95]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Kings Trade: D.Cousins, 1st Round Pick
Knicks Trade: C.Anthony
I'm the Kings. Is it a good trade? Still got Dalembert.

[Rhyster95]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Who says no to this trade?

WIZARDS GET: Dwight Howard, Gilbert Arenas
MAGIC GET: John Wall, JaVale McGee, Rashard Lewis, 1st Round Pick

Its essentially Howard for Wall, McGee & 1st Round Pick. Arenas and Lewis get flipped back for each other for money reasons and Orlando would have 3 PG's to 0 for Washington plus Dwight and Gil are friends.

Does Orlando get too much, not enough or is it just right?

Thie would be your lineup if you Did it:
PG:G.Arenas
SG:N.Young
SF:Josh Howard(I believe)
PF:Blatche
C.Howard

I would say do it.

[RedSceptile]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Kings Trade: D.Cousins, 1st Round Pick
Knicks Trade: C.Anthony
I'm the Kings. Is it a good trade? Still got Dalembert.

Not fair for the Knicks as much as I despise Carmelo's lack of defensive dominance when he should be because of his physical gifts.

[Rhyster95]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I did it, And after half a Season they were like 15-24 I remember XD.

[Kemba1Walker]

Nets receive (me): Ersan Ilyasova, 2011 second round pick

Bucks receive: Nikola Mirotic

Ersan Ilyasova: 8.4ppg, 6.7rpg, 1.2apg, 16 minutes per game

Nikola Mirotic: 7.1ppg, 5.2rpg, 1.5apg, 14 minutes per game (rookie)

[DarkOzzy1]

Celtics trade (me): Delonte West
for
76ers: Louis Williams

[bobcats55]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Here is an interesting 3 team trade,

Bobcats trade: DJ Augistine
Bobcats receive: Eric Maynor, Cole Aldrich, '12 1st round Thunder

Rockets Trade: Hasheem Thabeet, '11 1st round Rockets
Rockets Receive: Thabo Sef.

OKC Trade: Thabo Sef. Cole Aldrich, Eric Maynor, 12 1st round Thunder
OKC Receives: Hasheem Thabeet, DJ Augistine, '11 1st round Rockets


What do you guys think about the realism of this trade?

The Bobcats will be looking to move DJ with the addition of Kemba. Gaining Aldrich and a future pick will be a solid deal.

The Rockets gain an excellent defender who will give great minutes.

OKC recieves a solid PG so that Westbrook can be bumped to the SG slot. They also gain a solid Center prospect to develop. Basicly a tiny step backwards from Aldrich.

What are you guys thoughts?

Thanks for the feed back on this trade, I went back and adjusted it to make it more fair. It worked out well for me(OKC)

OKC gets: DJ Augistine, Chase Budinger, Hasheem Thabeet, DeSenaga Diop, '11 1st round Charlotte

Charlotte gets: Kendrick Perkins, Eric Maynor

Houston gets: Nate Robinson, Cole Aldrich

What do you guys think of this trade?

[Rajon Rondo Fan]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thanks for the feed back on this trade, I went back and adjusted it to make it more fair. It worked out well for me(OKC)

OKC gets: DJ Augistine, Chase Budinger, Hasheem Thabeet, DeSenaga Diop, '11 1st round Charlotte

Charlotte gets: Kendrick Perkins, Eric Maynor

Houston gets: Nate Robinson, Cole Aldrich

What do you guys think of this trade?

Thats Realistic finally someone not trading a bunch of star players but yet trade good solid role players. But I would see if I could get a 1st round pick from okc even thou it wont be that valuable OR try to get 3 second round picks which some teams will trade for a 1st rounder

[bobcats55]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thanks for the feed back!

I agree. Those who swap up stars left and right might as well do a fantasy draft. Its so unrealistic.

The only other trade I am considering is trading Thabo Sefaloshia and Nick Collison in a package deal to relieve cap space. Any suggestions on players to look at?

Here is my line up without the above players:

PG: DJ Augistine, Reggie Jackson

SG: Russel Westbrook, James Harden

SF: Kevin Durant, Chase Budinger

PF: Serge Ibaka

C: Greg Oden( signed FA ) Nazr Muhammed

Thoughts?