The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • thaprodigyisback
    Rookie
    • Oct 2010
    • 180

    #391
    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

    Originally posted by Freak123
    Agreed. The Blazers said just recently that Batum will not be included in any deal that doesn't involve Carmelo Anthony or Chris Paul going to their team. As for Aldridge, well he's pretty much untradable as well, as he is a huge part of their offense. It is just a video game though, doesn't have to be realistic.
    Yea its because of this new Star Rating thing Bargnani was 4 and a half stars and Batum was only 1 star and Aldridge was 3 Stars and I took their 1st so I did rape them.

    I agree I deff raped the wolves but I tryed to convince my self that Kahn would make a trade for another PG and Love is only 3 Stars

    I actually had a way to get B.Jennings w/o letting go of Bargnani but I opted for Turner because they already have Iggy but those two have been putting in work for the Sixers
    Milwaukee Bucks Dynasty:
    http://www.operationsports.com/forum...sociation.html

    Comment

    • JBH3
      Marvel's Finest
      • Jan 2007
      • 13506

      #392
      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

      My First Non-Mavs (All-30 Teams) Trade...

      Season1 [as] Mavs (All-30 Teams) Association:<O</O
      <O</O
      With the Hornets struggling in my association, and also losing Emeka Okafor early on to a broken foot for 8 weeks...Made a 3-team deal to try and salvage the Hornets season, and also help out a couple of other teams in the process; who either needed to clear cap space or add a piece to the puzzle.

      Hornets are 5-15 and in the cellar in the west through the 1st week of December. They are really down, but not out and have recently lost a string of close games; mainly due to trotting out Aaron Gray out at the starting 5, and dealing w/ injuries and a lack of depth in the frontcourt.

      Pistons have started 6-15 and lack a great deal of chemistry. They've got some young guys who need minutes, but some vets w/ big contracts that are blocking their way.

      The Bobcats are 12-9 and playing great D, but are lacking scoring as they sit 3rd worst in the league in PPG. Their defense has propeled them so far, but adding some offensive punch will greatly help them move from 8th in the east (and one in done in the 1st round) to a possible 2nd rd playoff push.

      THE DEAL:

      Hornets Get: Ben Wallace (DET), Charlie Villanueva (DET), and Jason Maxiell (DET).

      Pistons Get: Peja (NO), Jason Smith (NO), 2011 1st & 2nd Rd picks (NO), SG Gerald Henderson (CHA), PF/C Kwame Brown (CHA), and a 2011 2nd Rd pick from Charlotte.

      Bobcats Get: Rodney Stuckey.

      Hornets get Big Ben who can start at center till Okafor comes back, and add two big men that are MUCH needed since the Hornets lack frontcourt depth.

      Pistons get a $13 mil expiring contract in Peja, another deal that expires w/ Jason Smith ($2+ mil), two 2nd rd picks, & a 1st Rd Nawlins pick (which could still be a lotto pick if this deal doesn't work out for Nawlins).

      Coming from Charlotte, Detroit gets SG Gerald Henderson who seems to fit better on a Detroit team that isn't going anywhere, and backup Kwame Brown reunites with Detroit.

      Altogether Detroit will have $29 mil in cap space to use in the offseason. Do they go after Melo? The guy they should've drafted over Darko? Who knows. But now they have the cap room to do so. They will also be able to get solid minutes for rookie Center Gregg Monroe, and youngsters Austin Daye, DeJuan Summers, and Will Bynum. Jonas Jerebko is out for another couple of weeks with an injury, but he will continue to see consistent minutes too.

      As for Charlotte, they get Rodney Stucky for next to nothing. The Pistons couldn't leverage anymore because teams know that they didn't want to re-sign Stuckey longterm. So Detroit cuts their losses, and moves Stuckey for Henderson and Brown and a CHA 2nd rounder.

      Now Charlotte will have to decide if THEY want to sign Stuckey for big money longterm. Stuckey is averaging 18.5 ppg while shooting 44% from the field, but DJ Augustin has been playing solid ball too. Bobcats coach Larry Brown has stated that "Rodney will come off the bench to start, but will still see at least 30 minutes a night". Shaun Livingston has really struggled, and he would be no threat to steal any minutes away from Stuckey. Charlotte will be running w/ a 9-man rotation with Tyrus Thomas, Stuckey, Diop, and Najera getting all the backup minutes.

      Thoughts?
      Originally posted by Edmund Burke
      All that is needed for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing.

      Comment

      • thaone08
        Rookie
        • Oct 2010
        • 488

        #393
        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

        Originally posted by JBH3
        My First Non-Mavs (All-30 Teams) Trade...

        Season1 [as] Mavs (All-30 Teams) Association:<O</O
        <O</O
        With the Hornets struggling in my association, and also losing Emeka Okafor early on to a broken foot for 8 weeks...Made a 3-team deal to try and salvage the Hornets season, and also help out a couple of other teams in the process; who either needed to clear cap space or add a piece to the puzzle.

        Hornets are 5-15 and in the cellar in the west through the 1st week of December. They are really down, but not out and have recently lost a string of close games; mainly due to trotting out Aaron Gray out at the starting 5, and dealing w/ injuries and a lack of depth in the frontcourt.

        Pistons have started 6-15 and lack a great deal of chemistry. They've got some young guys who need minutes, but some vets w/ big contracts that are blocking their way.

        The Bobcats are 12-9 and playing great D, but are lacking scoring as they sit 3rd worst in the league in PPG. Their defense has propeled them so far, but adding some offensive punch will greatly help them move from 8th in the east (and one in done in the 1st round) to a possible 2nd rd playoff push.

        THE DEAL:

        Hornets Get: Ben Wallace (DET), Charlie Villanueva (DET), and Jason Maxiell (DET).

        Pistons Get: Peja (NO), Jason Smith (NO), 2011 1st & 2nd Rd picks (NO), SG Gerald Henderson (CHA), PF/C Kwame Brown (CHA), and a 2011 2nd Rd pick from Charlotte.

        Bobcats Get: Rodney Stuckey.

        Hornets get Big Ben who can start at center till Okafor comes back, and add two big men that are MUCH needed since the Hornets lack frontcourt depth.

        Pistons get a $13 mil expiring contract in Peja, another deal that expires w/ Jason Smith ($2+ mil), two 2nd rd picks, & a 1st Rd Nawlins pick (which could still be a lotto pick if this deal doesn't work out for Nawlins).

        Coming from Charlotte, Detroit gets SG Gerald Henderson who seems to fit better on a Detroit team that isn't going anywhere, and backup Kwame Brown reunites with Detroit.

        Altogether Detroit will have $29 mil in cap space to use in the offseason. Do they go after Melo? The guy they should've drafted over Darko? Who knows. But now they have the cap room to do so. They will also be able to get solid minutes for rookie Center Gregg Monroe, and youngsters Austin Daye, DeJuan Summers, and Will Bynum. Jonas Jerebko is out for another couple of weeks with an injury, but he will continue to see consistent minutes too.

        As for Charlotte, they get Rodney Stucky for next to nothing. The Pistons couldn't leverage anymore because teams know that they didn't want to re-sign Stuckey longterm. So Detroit cuts their losses, and moves Stuckey for Henderson and Brown and a CHA 2nd rounder.

        Now Charlotte will have to decide if THEY want to sign Stuckey for big money longterm. Stuckey is averaging 18.5 ppg while shooting 44% from the field, but DJ Augustin has been playing solid ball too. Bobcats coach Larry Brown has stated that "Rodney will come off the bench to start, but will still see at least 30 minutes a night". Shaun Livingston has really struggled, and he would be no threat to steal any minutes away from Stuckey. Charlotte will be running w/ a 9-man rotation with Tyrus Thomas, Stuckey, Diop, and Najera getting all the backup minutes.

        Thoughts?

        i was going to say something mean but after reading it, it do make sense. bobcats needs a pg, pistons got rid of alot of money, and your did what chris paul wanted and made them a contender. so after all of that you did good but one thing larry brown would have stucky startin because he a better defenseive player and it would make the team better

        Comment

        • thaone08
          Rookie
          • Oct 2010
          • 488

          #394
          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

          Originally posted by MYRM1D0N
          boozer is a solid rebounder. anyways, why dont u try and trade some role players for tyrus thomas back from bobcats. lol
          lol you right but when you look at it you just trading offense for defense.tyrus thomas is a downgrade from boozer because he not a scorer. with smith you have someone who can run the fastbreak and take away the pressure from noah

          Comment

          • Ferrari997
            Pro
            • Mar 2008
            • 667

            #395
            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

            Bulls (Me) get:

            Melo

            76ers get:

            Deng
            1st Rounder
            James Johnson

            Nuggets get:

            Iguodala
            1st Rounder
            Boozer (or Gibson)

            I'll admit....IF I did decide to do this trade, only way to pull it off is to trade override it because Melo is almost impossible to trade for (at least with the Bulls). However, I wouldn't feel as bad doing it if it was a fair trade and its something I feel would happen in real life. That is where you guys come in....thoughts?

            Comment

            • osubeavs721
              Banned
              • Dec 2008
              • 1577

              #396
              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

              Originally posted by mvspree8
              Why don't you try just one of those three (likely Gallinari) and Curry's expiring contract? I don't think the Wizards are in a position to fleece anybody (i.e. two young guys, capspace, picks) but a deal like that would be pretty realistic if you ask me.
              for what gil does for me i need atleast two of them. preferably gallo and randolph. I had no problems taking on a bad contract and such but its ridiculous. I even offered my 1st rd pick

              Comment

              • thaone08
                Rookie
                • Oct 2010
                • 488

                #397
                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                Originally posted by osubeavs721
                for what gil does for me i need atleast two of them. preferably gallo and randolph. I had no problems taking on a bad contract and such but its ridiculous. I even offered my 1st rd pick
                see you not goin get all three just for gil. see gallo and randolph are young and 3 or more stars each, so trading just gilbert not goin for them not goin happen

                Comment

                • thaone08
                  Rookie
                  • Oct 2010
                  • 488

                  #398
                  Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                  Originally posted by Ferrari997
                  Bulls (Me) get:

                  Melo

                  76ers get:

                  Deng
                  1st Rounder
                  James Johnson

                  Nuggets get:

                  Iguodala
                  1st Rounder
                  Boozer (or Gibson)

                  I'll admit....IF I did decide to do this trade, only way to pull it off is to trade override it because Melo is almost impossible to trade for (at least with the Bulls). However, I wouldn't feel as bad doing it if it was a fair trade and its something I feel would happen in real life. That is where you guys come in....thoughts?

                  that trade wouldnt go through in real life. on here you just get melo for the season than he leaves. Overall it help you but any trade u gotta use trade override for isnt a fair trade

                  Comment

                  • Ferrari997
                    Pro
                    • Mar 2008
                    • 667

                    #399
                    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                    Originally posted by thaone08
                    that trade wouldnt go through in real life. on here you just get melo for the season than he leaves. Overall it help you but any trade u gotta use trade override for isnt a fair trade
                    Why wouldn't it go through in real life? I've read rumors that Iggy is unhappy in Philly and Collins prefers a more true SF. Melo doesn't want to go to Philly, and Chicago and NY are among teams he'd want to do to. Cue three team trade. Which part is unfair about it?

                    I think fair trades in the game vs fair trades in real life is vastly different. The trade I am trying to do more reflects what is going on right now in rea life. I seriously do not think Nuggets will get a superstar in return for Melo. In the game, they ask for Rose, Noah and Melo. That's not realistic to me...
                    Last edited by Ferrari997; 11-03-2010, 11:37 PM.

                    Comment

                    • thaone08
                      Rookie
                      • Oct 2010
                      • 488

                      #400
                      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                      Originally posted by Ferrari997
                      Why wouldn't it go through in real life? I've read rumors that Iggy is unhappy in Philly and Collins prefers a more true SF. Melo doesn't want to go to Philly, and Chicago and NY are among teams he'd want to do to. Cue three team trade. Which part is unfair about it?

                      I think trade override is what determines what is fair IN THE game. The trade I am trying to do more reflects what is going on right now in rea life. I seriously do not think Nuggets will get a superstar in return for Melo. In the game, they ask for Rose, Noah and Melo. That's not realistic to me...
                      because the nuggets made it clear with any trade involvin melo goin to the bulls they would HAVE to get noah back. if you doing it based on real life than noah wouldnt be in the red and black.

                      Comment

                      • pabby21
                        Rookie
                        • Nov 2009
                        • 331

                        #401
                        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                        Hey all, anyone got suggestions for the Celtics? I feel like I'm betraying them by even thinking of making some trades haha but at the same time I'm interested in having some fun taking them forward.......????

                        Comment

                        • thaone08
                          Rookie
                          • Oct 2010
                          • 488

                          #402
                          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                          Originally posted by pabby21
                          Hey all, anyone got suggestions for the Celtics? I feel like I'm betraying them by even thinking of making some trades haha but at the same time I'm interested in having some fun taking them forward.......????
                          look at every postion ok and see what players you can replace and get younger at.

                          Comment

                          • Yeah...THAT Guy
                            Once in a Lifetime Memory
                            • Dec 2006
                            • 17294

                            #403
                            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                            Originally posted by pabby21
                            Hey all, anyone got suggestions for the Celtics? I feel like I'm betraying them by even thinking of making some trades haha but at the same time I'm interested in having some fun taking them forward.......????
                            If you wanna keep it real, I'm not really sure it would be realistic to trade anyone. If you just wanna blow the team up, use trade finder to find what kind of value your boys have. In 2k10, I traded Ray Ray for Steph Curry before Steph Curry was a beast and built my team around Rondo, Curry, and a big man I drafted.
                            NFL: Bills
                            NBA: Bucks
                            MLB: Cubs
                            NCAA: Syracuse
                            Soccer: USMNT/DC United

                            PSN: ButMyT-GunDont

                            Comment

                            • JBH3
                              Marvel's Finest
                              • Jan 2007
                              • 13506

                              #404
                              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                              Originally posted by thaone08
                              i was going to say something mean but after reading it, it do make sense. bobcats needs a pg, pistons got rid of alot of money, and your did what chris paul wanted and made them a contender. so after all of that you did good but one thing larry brown would have stucky startin because he a better defenseive player and it would make the team better
                              Since you responded in both threads to the same post...again I ask...

                              How is my deal vastly unrealistic? What's so different about IT, than when Haywood, Butler, and Stevenson went to Dallas in exchange for cap relief for Washington. At which point Washington then orchestrated moving Jamison to CLE...essentially blowing up their roster, like I've done to the Pistons to some extent.

                              You can't just blanketly say something would not go through without providing any logic to base your claims.
                              Originally posted by Edmund Burke
                              All that is needed for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing.

                              Comment

                              • thaone08
                                Rookie
                                • Oct 2010
                                • 488

                                #405
                                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                                Originally posted by JBH3
                                Since you responded in both threads to the same post...again I ask...

                                How is my deal vastly unrealistic? What's so different about IT, than when Haywood, Butler, and Stevenson went to Dallas in exchange for cap relief for Washington. At which point Washington then orchestrated moving Jamison to CLE...essentially blowing up their roster, like I've done to the Pistons to some extent.

                                You can't just blanketly say something would not go through without providing any logic to base your claims.
                                dude i just said it do make since in this one the other one was a mistake wtf lol. calm down and i know u wrote it in both of them

                                Comment

                                Working...