The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[ohvitser12]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I traded wilson Chandler, randolph and Felton for Chris Paul.What you think of that trade?

[richyung62]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I traded wilson Chandler, randolph and Felton for Chris Paul.What you think of that trade?

Trade override?

[ROABS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I traded wilson Chandler, randolph and Felton for Chris Paul.What you think of that trade?

if your going for a realistic trade then this would never happen. The trade is great for the knicks though

[ewing6]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Tried to come up with a fair gilbert deal, think i did want some thoughts. It was basiclly a 3 way but i did in two seperate trades.

I traded:
Gilbert 81 overall sg 4 years 80 mil
Hilton Armstrong 61 overall C 1 year 600k
AL thorton 70 overall sf 1 year 2 mil mil

Mavs Traded:
Brandon Heyward 71 overall C 6 years 52.27
Beaubois 76 overall SG 3 years 4.62 mil
Shawn Marion 76 overall sf 4 years 7. something mil deal
Deshuan Steveson 61 overall sg 1 year 4.15 mil

They get Gilbert in thier push to win now, while they dump two big contracts for players that had just as good if not better starters in with Butler and Chandler. They get two solid backups at those postions back on 1 year deals. Since they had Terry and Gilbert at the 2 guard spot, Beaubois was expendable and i get my young player out of it.

Then I trade:
Heyward
2011/2012 2nds

Bobcats trade:
Nazr Mohhamd 66 overall center 1 year 6.88 mil deal

They get a upgrade at C and 2 picks and i get a backup to replace armstrong. Thoughts? This is prob the best one i could get that makes sense

[drodri90]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I've started a new Association with the Wolves and the first thing I wanted to do was trade Milicic's ugly contract for a PF so I could start Love at center. So I made this trade

Minnesota gets

-Zach Randolph
-Sam Young
-Grizzlies' 2011 1st round pick

Memphis gets

-Darko Milicic
-Luke Ridnour
-Minnesota's 2011 1st round pick

My current lineup is:

-Flynn
-Wesley Johnson
-Beasley
-Randolph
-Love

At first sight I tought I robbed the CPU, but I gave the Grizzlies a decent big man like Milicic, a very good backup PG in Ridnour and a presumably high draft pick. At the end of the season I'll let Randolph go so I can go after big names in the FA. What do you think of this trade.

Sorry for my english, I'm spanish.

[cmcghs]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Dallas Gets: Carmelo Anthony

Denver Gets: Caron Butler, Rodrigue Beaubois, Tyson Chandler, 2011 1st, 2012 1st

Thoughts?

[THE POLISH HAMMER]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I like it. They get a big, a good young player, a guy to fill in for Melo and picks. It fits what they need.

[thaprodigyisback]

Dallas Gets: Carmelo Anthony

Denver Gets: Caron Butler, Rodrigue Beaubois, Tyson Chandler, 2011 1st, 2012 1st

Thoughts?

Good trade but it would've been better if you could've done a 3 team trade with Beaubois getting sent to the 3rd and the 3rd team send denver

[cmcghs]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thanks for the opinions/suggestions guys!

I have not done the trade yet I was just sort of putting pieces together and seeing what seemed right.

[J-Clutch1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm just fantasizing here, and I won't do this in my Association, but I'd like opinions.

New Jersey Nets would receive:
Carmelo Anthony
Al Harrington
Andre Miller

Denver Nuggets would receive:
Derrick Favors
Troy Murphy
Nicolas Batum
1st Rounder

Blazers would receive:
Devin Harris
Damion James
1st Rounder

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm just fantasizing here, and I won't do this in my Association, but I'd like opinions.

New Jersey Nets would receive:
Carmelo Anthony
Al Harrington
Andre Miller

Denver Nuggets would receive:
Derrick Favors
Troy Murphy
Nicolas Batum
1st Rounder

Blazers would receive:
Devin Harris
Damion James
1st Rounder

This is a fair trade,

[richyung62]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm just fantasizing here, and I won't do this in my Association, but I'd like opinions.

New Jersey Nets would receive:
Carmelo Anthony
Al Harrington
Andre Miller

Denver Nuggets would receive:
Derrick Favors
Troy Murphy
Nicolas Batum
1st Rounder

Blazers would receive:
Devin Harris
Damion James
1st Rounder

fair trade, not a bad idea

[richyung62]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I've started a new Association with the Wolves and the first thing I wanted to do was trade Milicic's ugly contract for a PF so I could start Love at center. So I made this trade

Minnesota gets

-Zach Randolph
-Sam Young
-Grizzlies' 2011 1st round pick

Memphis gets

-Darko Milicic
-Luke Ridnour
-Minnesota's 2011 1st round pick

My current lineup is:

-Flynn
-Wesley Johnson
-Beasley
-Randolph
-Love

At first sight I tought I robbed the CPU, but I gave the Grizzlies a decent big man like Milicic, a very good backup PG in Ridnour and a presumably high draft pick. At the end of the season I'll let Randolph go so I can go after big names in the FA. What do you think of this trade.

Sorry for my english, I'm spanish.

MEM already have enough Centers with Thabeet, Haddidi...i dont think they will take on Darko & his contract, Mike Conley just signed an extension, he's no different from Luke Ridnour.

look at these that needs a decent back up C & PG, pull off a three team trade if you can.

[thaprodigyisback]

I've started a new Association with the Wolves and the first thing I wanted to do was trade Milicic's ugly contract for a PF so I could start Love at center. So I made this trade

Minnesota gets

-Zach Randolph
-Sam Young
-Grizzlies' 2011 1st round pick

Memphis gets

-Darko Milicic
-Luke Ridnour
-Minnesota's 2011 1st round pick

My current lineup is:

-Flynn
-Wesley Johnson
-Beasley
-Randolph
-Love

At first sight I tought I robbed the CPU, but I gave the Grizzlies a decent big man like Milicic, a very good backup PG in Ridnour and a presumably high draft pick. At the end of the season I'll let Randolph go so I can go after big names in the FA. What do you think of this trade.

Sorry for my english, I'm spanish.

Your going to get destroyed on Defense from positions 3-5

[Helios12787]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I've been tryin to get a trade similar to that in the works trying to go for young back to basket guys and so far I've struck out. My biggest issue is deciding whether it is worth it to keep both Flynn and Rubio (imported from player dna) or trade one away for some young talent.

I really wanted rubio to be my future star but flynn is making a damn good case on why he should be in my association (leading scorer, assists leader, and usual player of the game each game)