The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[SupremeGod7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I know my username is Magic642, but I'm playing with the Heat.

Miami gets:
Dwight Howard
Gilbert Arenas
Ryan Anderson
'11 1st round pick

Orlando gets:
Dwyane Wade
Chris Bosh
Mario Chalmers
'11 2nd round pick

Next...

Miami gets:
David Lee
Brandan Wright

Golden State gets:
Gilbert Arenas

Miami gets:
Jarrett Jack (who is a 74 as a SG instead of 69 as a PG)

New Orleans gets:
Mike Miller

that orlando trade sucks for your team...

[SupremeGod7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Clippers gets:
Carlos Boozer
Jeff Green
13 1st round pick (Grizzlies)
13 1st round pick (Suns)

Chicago gets:
Baron Davis
Blake Griffin

I'm the Bulls. What do you guys think?

nah u gave up a lot jeff green is solid and the 2 first rounders not worth it.

[SupremeGod7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nets trade (me) quinton ross (63) humprhies (69) to the suns (cpu) for marcin gortat (69) , I think its fair, I have no one to backup brook lopez and I wanted a defensive guy and humphries was getting no playing time which he will get in phoenix

good move...

[SupremeGod7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im Orlando...

Orl Gets
Lemarcus Alridge
2nd round pick

Portland Gets
Gilbert Arenas
1st Round Pick
bass

[SupremeGod7]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Phoenix Suns Get
Brandon Bass (PF)
2011 2nd Round Pick
2012 1st Round Pick

Orlando Magic Get
Grant Hill (SF)
Channing Frye (PF/C)
2012 2nd round pick

I'm the Magic, and since losing Gortat, My middle cannot hold up with just 59 ovr Danny Orton. Plus Frye can shoot.

Grant Is a Solid Defender and is a good shooter. could use him in lots of situations.
Plus I want to re-unite my Favorite player and my favorite team.

Who gets better deal?

good deal for orlando... fry and grant is useful...

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im Orlando...

Orl Gets
Lemarcus Alridge
2nd round pick

Portland Gets
Gilbert Arenas
1st Round Pick
bass

Fair deal for both teams, at least you give up Arenas contract which is huge in return for a young future star

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Fair deal for both teams, at least you give up Arenas contract which is huge in return for a young future star

thats unrealistic but very good trade for you, blazers won't give up aldridge man unless they are getting dwight lol

[Mike Lowe]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

While I can't really get an official three way trade to work, this is essentially what I'm proposing. I'm hoping I can hear some feedback on whether or not this is fair:

Oct 2010 (before first game)

Nets (me) get:
SG Redd 73
PG Boykins 65

Bucks get:
PF Murphy 72
SG Vujacic 66
2nd round pick in 2011
2nd round pick in 2012

Personally, I feel like I'm overpaying, but I need a guy who can put up 20 a night consistently, and who can take the pressure off of the young kids the Nets have at least this first year. Redd will be a nice player to kick out to as well, as I have no one at SG. I like the role players I have at SG, but I needed something consistent to not have to rely on 18-22 year old's who really aren't ready to be feature players IMO.

I was dealing a bit with the Pistons too about one of their SG's, but I didn't want to commit to Gordon for 3 years, RIP is going to decline over his 2 year deal, and I liked McGrady actually, but having no bird years...I'd at least like a shot at keeping him if he plays well.

Regardless, I'm happy with Redd if it's a fair deal.

I would be trading Boykins for someone who can give me some depth at C and is rated close to the same overall.

THOUGHTS?!!?

[Mike Lowe]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

While I can't really get an official three way trade to work, this is essentially what I'm proposing. I'm hoping I can hear some feedback on whether or not this is fair:

Oct 2010 (before first game)

Nets (me) get:
SG Redd 73
PG Boykins 65

Bucks get:
PF Murphy 72
SG Vujacic 66
2nd round pick in 2011
2nd round pick in 2012

Personally, I feel like I'm overpaying, but I need a guy who can put up 20 a night consistently, and who can take the pressure off of the young kids the Nets have at least this first year. Redd will be a nice player to kick out to as well, as I have no one at SG. I like the role players I have at SG, but I needed something consistent to not have to rely on 18-22 year old's who really aren't ready to be feature players IMO.

I was dealing a bit with the Pistons too about one of their SG's, but I didn't want to commit to Gordon for 3 years, RIP is going to decline over his 2 year deal, and I liked McGrady actually, but having no bird years...I'd at least like a shot at keeping him if he plays well.

Regardless, I'm happy with Redd if it's a fair deal.

I would be trading Boykins for someone who can give me some depth at C and is rated close to the same overall.

THOUGHTS?!!?

On second thought, I think I'm better to do this deal with the Pistons:

2010

Nets (me) get:
SG Gordon 76
SG White 66
PF/C Wilcox 62

Pistons get:
PF Murphy 72
SG Vujacic 66

I get to keep my picks, and I get a "better," younger Gordon with more potential than Redd. I'm not crazy about the 3 year deal Gordon has, but that brought his pricetag down a bit, and he's a player who should play well through his contract. I really, honestly think Gordon will be a good fit for my Nets here.

White is a nice prospect player who should get some minutes, but not a ton in 2010 honestly.

Wilcox will give me some depth at C, albeit it very below average as he doesn't bring much to the table, but was needed to complete the deal from a numbers standpoint.

For the Pistons, it seems that getting rid of a multi-year contract is a huge plus, not to mention they still have RIP and McGrady. Murphy could probably start for the Pistons over Maxiell and CV31. The Pistons also get two expiring contracts with Murphy's being $12M+.

I had no use for Murphy and was happy to get rid of Vujacic as well. Gordon should be a nice vet to add into the mix.

THOUGHTS??!

[Boling4Humor]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

^i feel the first trade involving the bucks was more realistic than the pistons deal. but as far as trading goes, you definetely got the better end of the deal from the pistons and hopefully the talent you got will come alive for you on the court.

[dazpoo23]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nets (me) get:
SG Gordon 76
SG White 66
PF/C Wilcox 62

Pistons get:
PF Murphy 72
SG Vujacic 66

THOUGHTS??!

^^ I like this trade a lot more, Pistons get cap relief from Gordon's contract, I know you dont want to give up picks, but if your prepared to do it for Redd & Boykins then surely you can muster 2 2nd rounders for gordon.
In any case, both good trades. If its a fair deal then over-ride the computers idiocy.

[jasn88cubs]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Kings(Me) get Taj Gibson and Ronnie Brewer

Bulls get Carl Landry, 2012 1st rd pick

[jonmchugh007]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Just started up with the post-trade deadline rosters with the Knicks. Any ideas how I can improve my back court? I picked up Troy Murphy as a Free Agent but Turiaf is a waste. Who could I trade for a decent center? I want to keep Amare' at the 4.

[cena101]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ok so I just restarted my Knicks franchise because of all the recent trades that my Knicks made in real life. Anyway in the game I am not a big fan of Billups and his big contract, so I am looking to trade him, and I got an offer from the Washington Wizards.

Knicks(Me) Get:
Nick Young
Kirk Kinrich

Wizards Get:
Billups
Bill Walker

I am most likely going to do this because since I currently live in D.C. but grew up in new York and loving the Knicks since I can remember. I get to see Nick Young a lot and he has great upside you just have to be patient, and with Kirk he can help develop both Young and Fields. He is also a pass first kind of person which give Melo and Stat more shots per game. So let me know what you guys think, should I do it or not.

[loloben]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nets (Me) get
SF Omri Cassipi
Kings get
SF Travis Outlaw
Nets 2011 1st rounder