NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Yukk
    Pro
    • Jul 2002
    • 817

    #1

    NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

    LOL!!!
    Basically its almost the same game as last year excet for slam dunk contest. So if all you want is slam dunk then go and buy it otherwise it might not worth $40.
  • Bnyce
    Rookie
    • Jul 2004
    • 255

    #2
    Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

    Reviews online or otherwise make NO BEARING on whether I buy a game or not, heck I wont listen to half the cats here, but the beta stuff was a real plus, very informative from videos to screenshots, and TO ME they fixed the problems that plagued last years game, still cant say for a 100% cause I havent played it for myself, but I'll be able to get the game tommorow and make my own discernments...


    Anyhow its seems like you wanted this game to fail from the start, why do people wish for the worst, I loved live last year that doesn't mean I want 2k to fail, I want 2k to be one of the best Bball videogame experiences as with Live 05, as a basketball fan how could you think otherwise iono, but to each his own ...


    But for those who continue to wish for the worst, I feel sorry for them ...
    Last edited by Bnyce; 09-28-2004, 07:55 PM.
    Benjamin D of Insufficient Funds

    Comment

    • Bnyce
      Rookie
      • Jul 2004
      • 255

      #3
      Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

      Reviews online or otherwise make NO BEARING on whether I buy a game or not, heck I wont listen to half the cats here, but the beta stuff was a real plus, very informative from videos to screenshots, and TO ME they fixed the problems that plagued last years game, still cant say for a 100% cause I havent played it for myself, but I'll be able to get the game tommorow and make my own discernments...


      Anyhow its seems like you wanted this game to fail from the start, why do people wish for the worst, I loved live last year that doesn't mean I want 2k to fail, I want 2k to be one of the best Bball videogame experiences as with Live 05, as a basketball fan how could you think otherwise iono, but to each his own ...


      But for those who continue to wish for the worst, I feel sorry for them ...
      Benjamin D of Insufficient Funds

      Comment

      • OffThaCha1nX
        Banned
        • Mar 2004
        • 60

        #4
        Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

        Sega pays Gamespot off

        i mean all u see on the side of the gamespot site is ****in ESPN NBA ads, coincidence? ha

        Comment

        • OffThaCha1nX
          Banned
          • Mar 2004
          • 60

          #5
          Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

          Sega pays Gamespot off

          i mean all u see on the side of the gamespot site is ****in ESPN NBA ads, coincidence? ha

          Comment

          • nkhera1
            All Star
            • Oct 2003
            • 5913

            #6
            Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

            no gamespot has plenty of ea adds if i remember correctly, but i would wait for user reviews, because they aren't always spot on, but i think they are better than ign. (Not saying live is good or bad, but that its not always reliable.)
            Just wait till Arsenal moves into Emirates Stadium.

            Comment

            • nkhera1
              All Star
              • Oct 2003
              • 5913

              #7
              Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

              no gamespot has plenty of ea adds if i remember correctly, but i would wait for user reviews, because they aren't always spot on, but i think they are better than ign. (Not saying live is good or bad, but that its not always reliable.)
              Just wait till Arsenal moves into Emirates Stadium.

              Comment

              • iamthemaster121
                Rookie
                • Aug 2004
                • 131

                #8
                Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                Originally posted by Yukk
                LOL!!!
                Basically its almost the same game as last year excet for slam dunk contest. So if all you want is slam dunk then go and buy it otherwise it might not worth $40.
                I cant believe it. Live 04 got a better rating than Live 05!!
                Wow. At least Gamespot told the truth. I thought that Live 05 would get at least an 8.2!!

                Comment

                • iamthemaster121
                  Rookie
                  • Aug 2004
                  • 131

                  #9
                  Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                  Originally posted by Yukk
                  LOL!!!
                  Basically its almost the same game as last year excet for slam dunk contest. So if all you want is slam dunk then go and buy it otherwise it might not worth $40.
                  I cant believe it. Live 04 got a better rating than Live 05!!
                  Wow. At least Gamespot told the truth. I thought that Live 05 would get at least an 8.2!!

                  Comment

                  • Perfection
                    Rookie
                    • Oct 2002
                    • 276

                    #10
                    Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                    Originally posted by iamthemaster121
                    I cant believe it. Live 04 got a better rating than Live 05!!
                    Wow. At least Gamespot told the truth. I thought that Live 05 would get at least an 8.2!!
                    Yeah that does surprise me. It is DEFINITELY better than 04. But I agree with the fact that it feels largely unchanged. He has a point there, but a 7.9 is downright HARSH.

                    Comment

                    • Perfection
                      Rookie
                      • Oct 2002
                      • 276

                      #11
                      Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                      Originally posted by iamthemaster121
                      I cant believe it. Live 04 got a better rating than Live 05!!
                      Wow. At least Gamespot told the truth. I thought that Live 05 would get at least an 8.2!!
                      Yeah that does surprise me. It is DEFINITELY better than 04. But I agree with the fact that it feels largely unchanged. He has a point there, but a 7.9 is downright HARSH.

                      Comment

                      • Tha_Kid
                        All Star
                        • Oct 2002
                        • 6550

                        #12
                        Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                        I dont think you should compare it too previous years, as every year games are looking better and competition is getting tougher. If this was the game that came out last year, it would prolly get a higher score than 04 did, but due to minimal improvements and EA essentially staying on path, Gamespot rated it for what we should expect this year. Also keep in mind 8.0 is still good, its like the player ratings, too many look at a number and get the wrong impression.

                        Comment

                        • Tha_Kid
                          All Star
                          • Oct 2002
                          • 6550

                          #13
                          Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                          I dont think you should compare it too previous years, as every year games are looking better and competition is getting tougher. If this was the game that came out last year, it would prolly get a higher score than 04 did, but due to minimal improvements and EA essentially staying on path, Gamespot rated it for what we should expect this year. Also keep in mind 8.0 is still good, its like the player ratings, too many look at a number and get the wrong impression.

                          Comment

                          • Ice Cream Truck
                            Money Makin' Sonny
                            • Nov 2003
                            • 2200

                            #14
                            Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                            Originally posted by OffThaCha1nX
                            Sega pays Gamespot off

                            i mean all u see on the side of the gamespot site is ****in ESPN NBA ads, coincidence? ha
                            No wonder you only have 8 posts. The admin deleted the rest cuz they're all [***]in stupid

                            The game was rated fairly. When you play the game you'll find out if much has changed or not. But after looking at the videos, gamespot's rating looks pretty accurate. Steve said the dunks were crazy hard. Which does make the contest less fun.

                            And the gameplay hasn't improved much, just minor tweaks. It's like they adjusted sliders.

                            You haven't played the game, they have. O whatever, let's just wait til the game comes out shall we? Call me back and we'll continue this discussion
                            Xbox 360 GamertagRAW 910

                            Philadelphia Eagles


                            Phoenix Suns


                            Comment

                            • Ice Cream Truck
                              Money Makin' Sonny
                              • Nov 2003
                              • 2200

                              #15
                              Re: NBA LIVE 2005 Gets...............7.9 from Gamespot!!

                              Originally posted by OffThaCha1nX
                              Sega pays Gamespot off

                              i mean all u see on the side of the gamespot site is ****in ESPN NBA ads, coincidence? ha
                              No wonder you only have 8 posts. The admin deleted the rest cuz they're all [***]in stupid

                              The game was rated fairly. When you play the game you'll find out if much has changed or not. But after looking at the videos, gamespot's rating looks pretty accurate. Steve said the dunks were crazy hard. Which does make the contest less fun.

                              And the gameplay hasn't improved much, just minor tweaks. It's like they adjusted sliders.

                              You haven't played the game, they have. O whatever, let's just wait til the game comes out shall we? Call me back and we'll continue this discussion
                              Xbox 360 GamertagRAW 910

                              Philadelphia Eagles


                              Phoenix Suns


                              Comment

                              Working...