Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bigsmallwood
    MVP
    • Aug 2008
    • 1474

    #1

    Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

    Does NBA Live play a better game of basketball than NBA 2K9? I own 2K9 but have heard REALLY good things about Live 09'...please advise...I Like 2K9 but the gameplay seems to have some hiccups like the players sometimes glide like they are on ice and i do not like isomotion...it is just not very well done IMO...
    “What’s better than one billionaire? 2.....”
  • johnny4LSU
    Tiger Country
    • Nov 2008
    • 248

    #2
    Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

    live is a good game man and the 365 DNA is great and i cant really say which game is better because to each his own but lives fun to play . one thing nba 2k9 has on live is graphics and the crowds but yeah i know what you mean about it seems like the players are skating on ice at times because you're right but its till good game and live is a good game also .. you should just download the demo man and check it out because i dont think you would be disappointed
    PSN xjohnnyjohnsonx Gamertag xjohnnyjohnsonx
    NFL SAINTS, NCAA LSU TIGERS, NBA NEW ORLEANS HORNET.







    currently playing wwe 13, ncaa college football 2014

    Comment

    • bigsmallwood
      MVP
      • Aug 2008
      • 1474

      #3
      Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

      Originally posted by xjohnnyjohnsonx
      live is a good game man and the 365 DNA is great and i cant really say which game is better because to each his own but lives fun to play . one thing nba 2k9 has on live is graphics and the crowds but yeah i know what you mean about it seems like the players are skating on ice at times because you're right but its till good game and live is a good game also .. you should just download the demo man and check it out because i dont think you would be disappointed
      Thanks!
      “What’s better than one billionaire? 2.....”

      Comment

      • Altimus
        Chelsea, Assemble!
        • Nov 2004
        • 27283

        #4
        Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

        Without turning this into a VS thread, I'd say Live plays a terrific game of sim basketball. Both games have theirs ups and downs but if I was to pick one for this year (and I did), it is Live. As the poster above said though, best thing to do is to try the demo.

        Comment

        • Stumbleweed
          Livin' the dream
          • Oct 2006
          • 6279

          #5
          Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

          Originally posted by bigsmallwood
          the gameplay seems to have some hiccups like the players sometimes glide like they are on ice and i do not like isomotion...it is just not very well done IMO...
          You get animation hitches and random weird stuff like that in Live (it's just not as silky smooth looking), but a lot of that is because the foot-planting and collision detection is much better in Live. If your two main issues with 2K9 are the player movement (including IsoMotion) and footplanting, I'd say that you're exactly the type that I'd recommend Live to, as it beats 2K9 hands-down in those areas.

          If you're an offline gamer mostly, if you like running a halfcourt offense (calling a play every time down), and you don't mind the sometimes limited animations, Live (and NCAA 09, which I actually prefer gamepaly-wise) is a great game and I'd recommend it over 2K9. If you're more interested in isolation play, fastbreaks, smooth (and tons of signature) animations, and online play (there are just more people playing, a better sim community, and a much better league interface), I'd recommend 2K9.
          Send your Midnight Release weirdo pics/videos to my new website: http://www.peopleofmidnightreleases.com!

          Comment

          • 23
            yellow
            • Sep 2002
            • 66469

            #6
            Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

            All of these vs and comparison threads belong in the basketball forum

            Comment

            • BIG CAROLINA
              MVP
              • Aug 2007
              • 1762

              #7
              Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

              Originally posted by bigsmallwood
              Does NBA Live play a better game of basketball than NBA 2K9? I own 2K9 but have heard REALLY good things about Live 09'...please advise...I Like 2K9 but the gameplay seems to have some hiccups like the players sometimes glide like they are on ice and i do not like isomotion...it is just not very well done IMO...
              Not to be rude or anything, but man just go rent it and check it it out for yourself. That's is the one and only true way to find out for yourself without buying it.
              GT: BIG CAROLINA23

              PSN: BIG_CAROLINA


              "Life is too short for a man to hold bitterness in his heart."
              Marshall W. "Major" Taylor

              Comment

              • Kully
                MVP
                • Jul 2007
                • 3178

                #8
                Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

                You'd have to rent it as Big said, but honestly, I give the slight nod to Live this year, based on strictly out of the box comparisons.

                With 2K, there is a lot of tweaking you would have to do to get an enjoyable experience. For some people that's okay, but I don't think that we should be at a point where the default rosters are bad, the default sliders are bad, and the default gameplay sliders are bad. Controls are not where they should be either.

                Comment

                • LingeringRegime
                  Hall Of Fame
                  • Jun 2007
                  • 17089

                  #9
                  Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

                  I have both games, but if I were to pick only one it would be Live. It really feels like basketball, especially with L4D's sliders.

                  Comment

                  • bonjob
                    Rookie
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 3

                    #10
                    Re: Is Live 09 a better game than 2K9? Help me out

                    I think both games are the same.
                    but if i were to choose, it would be Live 09 because of its outstanding graphics. it feels like you're the one playing in the game.
                    SHOES are COOL! :):D

                    Comment

                    Working...