Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Da_Czar
    NBA 2K Gameplay Producer, Offensive AI System - SIM NATION
    • Jul 2002
    • 5408

    #1

    Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

    Preseason poll for those who have or had both games at one point. Which game to you out of the box is more of a sim of the nba game ?

    I would appreciate a few words posted on your vote. I plan to include some pro and cons statements from the community in different parts of the show this year. So anything posted in here should be posted with the knowledge that it could be included.

    Sim in this instance meaning out of the box which game plays most like the nba.
    75
    Nba 2k10 Reigning Battleground champion
    0%
    20
    Nba live 10
    0%
    55

    The poll is expired.

    Catch me on that #SimNation #SimHangOut Friday's @ 10:00 pm est https://www.youtube.com/playlist?lis...N7yxMiElOpMl_B
  • DirtyJerz32
    All Star
    • Aug 2007
    • 7617

    #2
    Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

    Without questoin, Live wins for "out of box" sim with 12 min qtrs. With some teaks though it's a little early to say.
    Moderator
    YouTube: DirtyJerz32
    Twitter: DirtyJerz32

    Twitch: DirtyJerz32


    Originally posted by bluengold34_OS
    No longer shall you be referred to as DirtyJerz32, but simply BOSS -

    Comment

    • Mr.Wednesday
      The Magic is back
      • Feb 2007
      • 1927

      #3
      Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

      I have allready made tweaks in 2K after playing for a few days. Shooting % were too high.

      I just installed Live game data on the PS3. I have to put some time in first. From what I hear, Live may be "it" as far as out of the box gamepay. I'll give some input after I play Live for a few days.

      Edit: I still think I need some extended play time with both games. But IMO, Live is a better sim of the essence of the NBA. Still have yet to make any tweaks. Not to say I will never adjust any sliders in the future. Right now I find myself playing Live within the framework the designers see as a representation of the NBA (which I think is accurate). I think you have to have a realistic approach in Live to be successful.
      Last edited by Mr.Wednesday; 10-08-2009, 09:43 AM.
      PSN: PhiNuPi
      XBL: Payday Loans

      OSFC Champion 2013

      Comment

      • nccomicfan
        MVP
        • May 2006
        • 1530

        #4
        Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

        Live wins because shooting percentage needs tweaking in 2k...However, it's a narrow win because Live needs adjustments to blocks and steals for both user and cpu

        Comment

        • Tha_Kid
          All Star
          • Oct 2002
          • 6550

          #5
          Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

          Out of the box sim goes to Live for shooting percentages, level of focus & strategy required, and the playsets. Once you know how Live handles challenging shots, D feels good. Sketchy looseball AI and randomness within 5 feet of the basket as far as blocks and steals are the main knocks i'd put on Live.

          2K's playsets are still sameold and I didn't notice the CPU adjusting to shut down my goto plays outside of doubleteaming if it wasn't a catch and shoot. I found that I could just kind of sort of play around and use the 2K 3rd/4th quarter runs to make a game of it. Shooting percentages are high and there still doesn't seem to be much in the way of contesting shots down there. And those alleyoops? Fun, but not sim.

          2K is definitely a fun game, though i don't if things bugged me less because i knew LIVE was my fulltime game and just looked past them or because I was used to them.

          Comment

          • Stumbleweed
            Livin' the dream
            • Oct 2006
            • 6279

            #6
            Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

            Out of the box, Live by a country mile. No insane shooting %s, no alley-oop catches flying in from the 3PT line, less PIP from cuts, great stats on 12 minute quarters, individual player stat lines look pretty spot-on. Even with tweaks, I'd say that Live is the more "sim" experience simply because it's more halfcourt oriented and it's tougher to just drive into the paint and score at will, especially against the AI (which is a little too psychic for my tastes but still makes for a challenging and not cheap-feeling game).
            Send your Midnight Release weirdo pics/videos to my new website: http://www.peopleofmidnightreleases.com!

            Comment

            • stewaat

              #7
              Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

              You ruined the poll by saying out of the box.

              No sane person can say NBA 2K10

              Comment

              • eDotd
                We ain't cool de la?
                • Jul 2006
                • 6284

                #8
                Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                Gotta roll with Live with this one. The %'s are scary realistic straight out the box. Thing about it is that it doesn't feel forced. I don't feel like the game is making me miss shots just to get to a certain percentage, everything just flows naturally within the pace of the game.

                Originally posted by Con-Con
                Honestly, some of the posters on here are acting like Rob Jones boned your girl while you were at work, on you own sheets BTW.
                Originally posted by trobinson97
                Mo is the Operator from the Matrix.

                Comment

                • Jasong7777
                  All Star
                  • May 2005
                  • 6415

                  #9
                  Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                  Neither game plays great out of the box.
                  Redskins, Lakers, Orioles, UNC Basketball , and ND Football
                  PSN: Jasong757
                  Xbox Live: Monado X

                  Comment

                  • bodean
                    Rookie
                    • Aug 2008
                    • 294

                    #10
                    Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                    Live 10.
                    BoDEAN -- XBOX Live

                    Comment

                    • Kully
                      MVP
                      • Jul 2007
                      • 3178

                      #11
                      Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                      Live 10 for basically everything Stumbleweed said.

                      Comment

                      • Thadeus
                        Pro
                        • Aug 2002
                        • 885

                        #12
                        Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                        2K10, no question.

                        Comment

                        • goh
                          Banned
                          • Aug 2003
                          • 20755

                          #13
                          Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                          Live of course.

                          2K has sky high FG% by default,the score came out to a realistic one on 7 minutes but I didn't like how it got there.

                          While Live plays a little too fast out of the box both teams shots in the 40's and with the same teams/7 minute quaters the score was a lot less than realistic. I believe it was 67-63.

                          There wasn't enough fouls called in either game.

                          Comment

                          • The 24th Letter
                            ERA
                            • Oct 2007
                            • 39373

                            #14
                            Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                            even though it feels incredibly scripted...Live..as far as getting simulation stats..

                            Comment

                            • Da_Czar
                              NBA 2K Gameplay Producer, Offensive AI System - SIM NATION
                              • Jul 2002
                              • 5408

                              #15
                              Re: Battleground 2010 Poll Out of the box sim ?

                              Originally posted by Jasong7777
                              Neither game plays great out of the box.
                              Jasong my brother that was not the question. Out of the two games which one is the best sim out of the box.
                              Catch me on that #SimNation #SimHangOut Friday's @ 10:00 pm est https://www.youtube.com/playlist?lis...N7yxMiElOpMl_B

                              Comment

                              Working...