My thoughts/rant on this year’s MVP discussion, not that it matters or anything but that’s what we are all here for. I do not believe Anthony Davis, regardless of record, should be this year’s MVP, and I’ll explain.
I keep seeing the “he does everything for them” and/or similar comments, and he does to an extent but I believe that it’s more so that he records a bulk of the stats. Obviously those can mean one in the same, but in Davis’s case the context is a little different. Watching the Pelican’s play, Davis is not the life of their offense, it doesn’t run through him, it’s not built on him… I realize that can be difficult to do at times as a big man, but it’s hard to argue that he provides more for his team if that’s the case.. We’ve seen guys like KG, Dirk, TD, etc have that role, the role of not just being a leading scorer but the guy who everything rises and falls with.. Davis doesn’t have that responsibility yet.
He doesn’t have to create for others, or really even for himself. Statistically 72% of his points are assisted.. You watch him play and you can see lots open looks, and among the leaders in dunks.. Props to him for being able to convert them at an efficient rate, but at the same time his role in those opportunities isn’t a Curry, Harden, James, Durant level role. Doesn’t have the burden of having to get his own shot when defenses are keyed on him…. On the opposite side of that, Davis averages less than 2 assists per game. Not saying it’s a big man’s job to rack up assists, but he has a somewhat limited overall output on his team’s offensive production. As of right now he generates 4 points per game from assists.. Also his assisting opportunity is very low (3.1), most of his passes are simply swinging the ball back to a guard… Just for comparison Blake Griffin (who isn’t even in the MVP discussion, but a PF) creates 12 points a night off of assists. Not only that, but his passing sets him up for 9 assist opportunity a night. Davis’s total offensive output 28.6 points, Blake’s is 34.8.. and that’s not adjusted for equal minutes.. Per 48 (nba.com doesn’t have 36) Davis is 38.2, Blake is 46.9…
For the most part that comparison is pointless.. But what I’m getting at is, it’s hard for me to back the idea that “he does everything for them” when we have guys that literally mean everything to their teams production. Harden for example scores 34% of his team’s points and dishes out 43% of his teams assists, Davis 32% and 10%. Harden is responsible for 44 points a night, his per 48 would be 58 a night.. Which would be over half of his teams output every single game. That’s a very, very large difference, and very massive chunk of responsibly. Same goes for someone like Curry, or LeBron. They generate so much more than looking at a stat-line will show, and you can see it show in every game.
But putting all of that aside, and forget the W/L record. Just looking a numbers alone, when has 24 and 10 ever been so mind blowing? Lol….. Blake did it last year, as well as 23 & 12 as a rookie, Bosh did it in Toronto, Love in Minny, Aldridge is doing it, Cousins at nearly 24 and 13… I realize he plays well at both ends, I realize he gives an extra block more per game than the average big man, I realize he’s been efficient, but we have posts around here that make it sound like this dude is averaging 30 and 14 and throwing in 5 blocks a night for good measure. He’s giving you run of the mill solid big man numbers, he’s not shooting through the roof with astronomical numbers that we’ve yet to see before. And even if we tossed out team record and compared him to Harden statically, Harden leads the league in scoring, 2nd in assists from non-point guards (LeBron), rebounds just as well as Davis per his position.
Also, defensively I do think he is very good (verge of great even, or too soon?). But he’s not that team’s back-bone as a defender. Their defense, at this point, doesn’t rely on his strengths like a Noah, or Marc Gasol, or arguably even a LeBron/Bosh in Miami. He makes lots of great individual plays, lots of plays with his length. Great at reaching perimeter shots quickly for blocks, passing lanes and deflecting skip passes, he’s very good in all those areas. But he’s not a great rim protector, he still needs to work on guarding strong guys inside too. I know “he averages over two blocks a night”, so does Pau Gasol…. Obviously Davis is a much better defender than Gasol, that’s not my point. My point is staring across a stat-line without context shouldn’t be the biggest factor in MVP votes.
Also as far as the PER thing goes.. I do believe it can be a useful stat, but I don’t think it should be strongly relied upon for MVP, also hate that “efficiency” is often used when discussing PER. Remember before Durant came back Russ’s PER was like 33.something (Mr. Efficient lol)…. Anyways, PER only rises and falls with your plusses and your minuses. Up with positive stats like made shot, steal, block, etc. and down with negatives like fouls, misses, turnovers. Davis, as mentioned with the passing, assisting, limited offensive responsibly, earlier in my post isn’t in a lot of positions to turn the ball over. Can you guess what the strongest weight for the negative part of PER is? Turnovers by far. Davis makes the most of his shots, but his FG% isn’t so mind-blowing that I would assume he would have the best PER ever. (why I looked up the formula). Right now what Davis is doing to maintain his super PER is avoid fouls, and make free throws.. Obviously the points, rebounds, etc. help but as mentioned before those numbers aren’t anything we haven’t saw before. I don’t think Davis having the best PER ever is really “something we’ve never seen before” but more so that usually marquee, superstar level guys are put in positions where they can’t average virtually zero turnovers. Probably why someone like Steve Nash, Chris Paul, Duncan/KG, or LeBron James doesn’t already have an unbreakable PER record anyways.
Anyway I’m not trying to nitpick or undervalue Davis in any way with this post. All of you who think he’s the future star of the league I am in complete agreement with you, 100%. In fact, in the redraft thread I think I was the only person who said I would pick him over Durant. So I obviously think very highly of his game, and he has multiple MVP awards coming his way. But I do not believe he deserves it this year, from watching him play or statically stacking him against others, even if we didn’t put as much weight on team record. There are 3-4 guys that I would for sure put ahead of him right now.
Comment