What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

[CountryBoy74]

I have a few actually...

Tommy Morrison= How can you take one of the Greatest Punchers in the History of the Heavyweights an give him Modest Punching Power. Also, His Handspeed and Heart is too low also. One other rant, They made his Chin too weak...He had crap for Defense .Everytime he got knocked down he got right back up and fought harder.

Mike Tyson= Weak Chin and no Heart....Cmon now, We all know Tyson had Greatness in Both.

Joe Frazier=The Best Chin in the Game.....All I can say .........Favoritism, He should be about a 86 at the most.

Eddie Chambers= Too Slow

Evander Holyfield= Although he is no slouch, Holyfield power should come down some. Also, Holyfield Chin should be the best in the game period.

Muhammad Ali= Too Strong of a Puncher

Wladimir Klitschko=Should have a better Right than his Brother and Chin and Heart too High.

Vitali Klitschko=Punching Power to high, Should be slower.

Gatti= Some Genius gave this guy a Great chin, I think Gatti has been knocked down more than 50 times in his career.


I could go on and on, But I will let you guys speak your mind.*Jumps down from Soap Box.

[mesk]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

chavez...a 86 overall?are u kidding me?SRL a 91.....maybe a 89,he was so overrated it makes me so mad!!!
and even though i hate to say it ,pac needs to be a 90 at least

[Relentless]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

Tyson there is obvious hate from the commentary of Atlas to his chin and heart ratings.. just listen to the commentary.

Ali is overpowered in this game.. he hits like Tyson should

Augustus.. should be quicker and have faster body movement/hands

[SteelerSpartan]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

They kind of fell into the madden trap with the ratings as well


Id like to see them a bit lower across the board for the mid range guys

Like how the hell is Victor Ortiz an 84

[SHAKYR]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I want ratings for every punch hook, uppercut , jab, etc; but people get caught up in the overall ratings. If a boxer has 95 r. straight 85 jab 90 hook 80 l. uppercut 80 r. uppercut and then you add other things about the boxer his overall isn't going to be what you think it should be.

This how they are suppose to get the overall but fans still are going to argue.
95
85
90
80
80
-----
420 5/420= 84

[CountryBoy74]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I want ratings for every punch hook, uppercut , jab, etc; but people get caught up in the overall ratings. If a boxer has 95 r. straight 85 jab 90 hook 80 l. uppercut 80 r. uppercut and then you add other things about the boxer his overall isn't going to be what you think it should be.

This how they are suppose to get the overall but fans still are going to argue.
95
85
90
80
80
-----
420 5/420= 84

Well their Ratings do not add up to their Overalls anyway.

[mesk]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

Well their Ratings do not add up to their Overalls anyway.

isnt that the truth?none of the stats add up.i tried to recreate a fw pac using th e stats he was given in the morales rivalry,and in the rivalry he is a 90,but when i did it i ended up with a 83 overall pac!!!

[dorismary]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

Tyson by far but i wish EA would have took this to the max maybe 3 different versions of each boxer young-middle and end of career with proper ratings and dress.

[Relentless]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I think that would be a bit much.. and give them and excuse to not add other ****.. simply having the fighters look and fight like the prime fighters that they were.. and also having the ratings/attire reflect the rivalaries woudl be necessary

[SHAKYR]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I think that would be a bit much.. and give them and excuse to not add other ****.. simply having the fighters look and fight like the prime fighters that they were.. and also having the ratings/attire reflect the rivalaries woudl be necessary

I don't think it would be much. Different versions of a boxer doesn't take slots/spots of potential boxers EA might get or fans want.

[mesk]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

love the new banner sig poe,its true a boxing sim has never been made,who knows it could fly off the shelf like hotcakes.I wonder how many boxing fans passed on rd 4 once they saw its gameplay i know of 3 friends personally that played it at my house when it first came out and they all passed cause it was too "fake"just like madden,live and nhl.ea should realize that casual gamers will buy it just cause it has fighting in it.im willing to bet that some ppl didnt even know half of the boxers in the game but bought it anyways just cause they like to fight

[SHAKYR]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

love the new banner sig poe,its true a boxing sim has never been made,who knows it could fly off the shelf like hotcakes.I wonder how many boxing fans passed on rd 4 once they saw its gameplay i know of 3 friends personally that played it at my house when it first came out and they all passed cause it was too "fake"just like madden,live and nhl.ea should realize that casual gamers will buy it just cause it has fighting in it.im willing to bet that some ppl didnt even know half of the boxers in the game but bought it anyways just cause they like to fight

So true! My brother and at least 15 other people I know passed up on the game because it didn't have many of the things that represent true boxing was absent.

[Iron-M-Tyson]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I want ratings for every punch hook, uppercut , jab, etc; but people get caught up in the overall ratings. If a boxer has 95 r. straight 85 jab 90 hook 80 l. uppercut 80 r. uppercut and then you add other things about the boxer his overall isn't going to be what you think it should be.

This how they are suppose to get the overall but fans still are going to argue.
95
85
90
80
80
-----
420 5/420= 84

I'd love it if each punch in a boxers arsenal had it's own rating and personally it's not the overall rating (even if they were done properly as actual averages in FNR5) that bothers me, only the individual attributes themselves.

I agree with Country's post, but i'll go into detail about the boxers with the attribute ratings that I am the most unhappy with.

Tyson: Let's be honest it looks like he was rated by a Tyson-*****. Considering the game refers to him as prime Tyson (1986,87,88) I only find agreement with his ratings for "Left Hand Power", "Head Movement" "Stamina" and "Cuts". His and Ali's "Hand Speed" should be above the 80% heavyweight limit and the 70% "Foot Speed" limit.

Morrison: Appears as if he was rated by one of those "Morrison is a bum" morons. His power in both hands, heart, chin, toughness, accuracy, hand speed, foot speed and head movement are underrated, yet they gave him an imaginary great block.

Might write about some more later.

@Relentless: Yeah Atlas still holds a grudge against Tyson for when Cus D'Amato sacked him for holding a gun to Mike's head...

[SHAKYR]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

Iron-M-Tyson, I glad fans like you are here.

I'd love it if punch in a boxers arsenal had it's own rating

I totally agree!

[CountryBoy74]

Re: What Fighter or Fighters Rating are you the most Upset with?

I'd love it if each punch in a boxers arsenal had it's own rating and personally it's not the overall rating (even if they were done properly as actual averages in FNR5) that bothers me, only the individual attributes themselves.

I agree with Country's post, but i'll go into detail about the boxers with the attribute ratings that I am the most unhappy with.

Tyson: Let's be honest it looks like he was rated by a Tyson-*****. Considering the game refers to him as prime Tyson (1986,87,88) I only find agreement with his ratings for "Left Hand Power", "Head Movement" "Stamina" and "Cuts". His and Ali's "Hand Speed" should be above the 80% heavyweight limit and the 70% "Foot Speed" limit.

Morrison: Appears as if he was rated by one of those "Morrison is a bum" morons. His power in both hands, heart, chin, toughness, accuracy, hand speed, foot speed and head movement are underrated, yet they gave him an imaginary great block.

Might write about some more later.

@Relentless: Yeah Atlas still holds a grudge against Tyson for when Cus D'Amato sacked him for holding a gun to Mike's head...

Yep both of those fighters got shafted.